Bethany Mandel, 27

@ BethanyShondark
Free spirit, freethinker.

Earlier this spring, with ice still in the Garden (Madison Square Garden), Seth Mandel announced to his wife Bethany, “I have something very important to tell the baby,” the firstborn they’re expecting in the fall.

“That’s how I knew the Rangers won,” Bethany tweeted. Mandel tweets early and often, as might be expected from someone who coordinates the social media presence — Facebook, Twitter, blogs — for Commentary, where Seth is assistant editor.

John Podhoretz, Commentary’s editor, says, “Bethany combines exuberance with moral seriousness. As a young person who has spent much of her life inside the Internet, she manages it like a pilot of an advanced aircraft manages his plane.”

A graduate of Rutgers with a degree in history and Jewish studies, Mandel worked at the Heritage Foundation, the conservative think tank, before moving to Commentary. Aside from her written insights, she’s an increasingly sought-after voice, appearing on CNBC’s “The Kudlow Report,”  “Huffington Post Live” and “BBC World.”

Less than 10 years ago, when she was still a teenager, she had no family to live with after her mother’s untimely death. She learned to wrangle with government bureaucracies over Medicaid and other programs. Then, coming home in the dark to an apartment in a down-and-out corner of the Bronx, she’d race the shadows from her subway stop to the safety of her apartment.

Raised a leftist, “I had never really met anyone who was conservative or Republican. I just assumed they were all racists and crazy,” she laughs. But she met so many young people in the Bronx who “all had horror stories about growing up on welfare; it just didn’t seem that the system was helping anyone. These were smart kids who could have had a chance. It was heartbreaking to see two institutions — welfare and public schools — that I had grown up thinking were helpful to the poor actually hurting them.”

Having had a Jewish father and a non-Jewish mother, she underwent an Orthodox conversion, and lives a Modern Orthodox life in Washington Heights.

“Commentary is really a perfect fit,” says Bethany. “It’s conservative. It’s Jewish. My co-workers are lovely. I’m with my husband. It can’t get better than this.”

Wanderlust: A traveler through 30 countries, having studied in Israel and Belgium and taught in Cambodia, she has also, via Twitter, raised money for North Korean refugees.



Associate Editor


Murray Mizrachi, 28 - A Sephardic Voice
Pamela Schuller, 30 - Spreading the Inclusion Message
Arielle Kandel, 33 - Enabling and Empowering Young Immigrant Women
Daniel Smith, 24 - Students Invested In Israel
Zack Pollack, 22 - ‘I Wanted to Inspire People’
Chaim Levin, 27 - Standing Up For LGBTQ Rights


Wow Bethany! I seem to disagree with you politically, but your life-story, of resiliency and determination and not giving up against such harsh odds, is extremely inspiring. Kol HaKavod!
Woman of Valor! Jewish Week did well in its selection of Bethany, a true inspiration for young women!
this chick is pretty REALLY legit. go RU !
Keep on standing up for what you believe not let others intimidate you....".no weapon formed against you will prosper!"
Public assistance and good public transportation for her growing up, but now she'd deny the same to others? She should work at Commentary...
I write about how my experiences on public assistance were actually instrumental in my becoming conservative here: And here: Thanks for your comment :)

Comment Guidelines

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.