Paterson Apologizes For Kosher-Enforcement Cut
12/09/10
Assistant Managing Editor
Photo Galleria: 

Eliminating the state’s kosher food inspection unit was a regrettable, but necessary decision forced by the state’s $10 billion deficit, Gov. David Paterson told The Jewish Week on Wednesday.

“We’re in a recession and I’m not going to make any bones about that,” said the governor. “I hate having done that and we’ll take responsibility for doing it. We’ll be very sympathetic to any criticism I get about it, but it’s gotten to the point where we have depleted our resources to reduce the deficit and have to go now into some places where we did not want to go.” He noted that staff conducting health code and environmental protection inspections will also be reduced.

“I apologize to everyone that we have had to make that decision,” said the governor, who leaves office Jan. 1 after completing the term of his predecessor, Eliot Spitzer. The former lieutenant governor, a Democrat, did not seek election to a full term.

This week the last two kosher inspectors retained by state’s Department of Agriculture and Markets received layoff letters as part of an effort to cut the state payroll by $250 million. “The list of those being targeted for abolition includes your non-competitive position of Kosher Food Inspector,” read a copy obtained by The Jewish Week. The director of the unit, Luzer Weiss, remains on the job. The kosher unit once had 11 inspectors but was downsized in 2004, after a successful U.S. Supreme Court challenge to the state’s century-old kosher law prohibited Albany from enforcing Orthodox kashrus standards. Under later guidelines the inspectors ensured only that establishments marketing themselves as kosher display their certification standards and adhere to those standards.

In the interview for The Jewish Week’s MetroPolitics video blog, Paterson said his successor, Andrew Cuomo, was likely to face even more drastic choices.

“[He] is about to be put in as difficult a position as any governor in the state has ever faced as he tries to lead us out of this recession,” said Paterson. “Hopefully people will realize that he is trying to keep the state from becoming insolvent and get behind him and be supportive.”

State Sen. Carl Kruger, a Brooklyn Democrat, said in a statement following the publication of Paterson's remarks here that the governor's elimination of the inspectors amounted to the end of the kosher enforcement unit. “I have been vocal in my opposition to any reductions in the kosher inspection division and was up front in relaying this opposition to the Governor,” Carl Kruger said. “But to leave an administrative director without any staff amounts to the de facto elimination of the entire division ... That he’s doing so despite the growing need and demand for kosher food is particularly disturbing.”

 

 

Last Update:

12/11/2010 - 20:27

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.

The Kosher enforcement bureau of NY State is absurd and Obscene! Why should the people of NY State be paying for any Religious organization's food requirements that not all people are using ??? I am sure NY Politicians are getting the vootes they deserve on this one too....it is a violation of Church and State laws !
Dear Editor: It was extremely difficult to read Governor Patteron's statement that the elimination of the Kosher law Enforcement Bureau of the New York State was over budgetary issues. This is a smoke screen. The truth is, as was told to me and reported in the press, that the State is eliminating kosher law enforcement because of the legal battles they have had over kosher: the two challenges to kosher by the Commack butchers (the first of which toppled the New York Kosher Law and forced a rewrite to eliminate the word Orthodox and to eliminate the State deciding what is in fact kosher) and the horrific Hebrew National challenge which took years and was never settled. The facts are that all lawyers used are on state payroll, and, while litigation is cumbersome, it is necessary to protect the citizens of this state. Let us hope that despite the state's monetary problems, the new governor, Andrew Cuomo, will realize the importance of resurrecting the Kosher Law Enforcement Bureau to protect all citizens of the state from kosher fraud which had been prevalent until the enactment of the state's kosher law. Rabbi Yosef Wikler Editor, KASHRUS Magazine Editor, New York Kosher News

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.