In Brooklyn Redistricting, Eggs In One Basket

Senate releases superdistrict with heavy Orthodox base, but some question the logic; race for Kruger seat turns ugly.

01/31/12
Assistant Managing Editor
Photo Galleria: 

As anticipated, New York’s legislative task force for redistricting last week released a map that packs several heavily Orthodox neighborhoods into one Senate bailiwick for a Jewish Brooklyn “superdistrict.”

But not everyone is embracing the idea.

“This is a smoke-filled, backroom deal,” said Councilman David Greenfield, who represents parts of Borough Park and Flatbush. Last year, Greenfield testified before the redistricting committee that two or three senators, rather than the current six should represent Orthodox areas.

“Six senators may have been too much, but one is too little,” he said. “If you take a population of several hundred thousand and divvy it up into several districts you can have a swing vote in each of those districts.” He said other prominent community members were mobilizing their opposition.

The legislative task force is appointed by the leadership of both houses and the minority leaders of both houses.

If approved, the map would also empower Asian Americans, who are underrepresented in the Legislature, with only Queens’ Grace Meng in the Assembly and no one in the Senate. The map melds the current district of Democrats Toby Stavisky and Tony Avella, forcing them against each other, with a possible third, Asian candidate, which might, not incidentally, pave the way for a Republican to win the Northern Queens seat, which was occupied by the GOP’s Frank Padavan from 1973 to 2010.

Gov. Andrew Cuomo has said he’ll veto the current map.

The “superdistrict,” No. 17 on the map, would include all of Borough Park, most of Midwood extending into Flatbush, including the young and growing Orthodox community in the East 30s. Its formation is widely seen as an attempt by Senate Majority Leader Dean Skelos to hand over a district to Orthodox Jews in central Brooklyn, heavily affiliated with Agudath Israel of America, in exchange for their support for a Republican candidate who will help Skelos keep his majority.

David Zwiebel, executive vice president for governmental affairs at Agudah, denied media reports that his organization had made a deal with Skelos to that effect.

“I have no personal knowledge of any such deal, and I have confronted my colleagues who are in direct day-to-day contact with various government officials, including Dean Skelos, and they also told me there was no such deal,” said Zwiebel. “All I know about that are rumors I read about in the papers.”

On the question of whether the Orthodox community is better off with one representative who can’t get elected without its overwhelming support or with several who must curry its favor, Zwiebel said, “There are valid arguments to be made on both sides of that equation. It will obviously depend on how large of a say we might have in the various districts where we are represented. But the current situation is not a healthy one because we are so dissipated among five districts that it’s hard to say we have very significant influence on any one of the representatives who reach out to us for our votes.”

He added, “I for one am supportive of the idea of a district that would clearly consolidate the community under one banner, thereby ensuring [the senator] would be responsive to our sensitivities.”

The idea of a superdistrict emerged after all but one of the six senators representing the Orthodox area (Republican Martin Golden being the exception) voted in favor of same-sex marriage last year. Shortly after that, Republican newcomer Bob Turner defeated establishment Democrat David Weprin in the race to succeed U.S. Rep. Anthony Weiner.

A coalition of minority organizations is fighting the legislative district changes because it creates a new upstate district in the state’s Capital Region, but fails to add one in Nassau County, where black and Hispanic representation has surged in areas like Hempstead and Elmont.

The winner of the race to succeed Sen. Carl Kruger, who resigned after pleading guilty to corruption charges late last year, will likely become the de facto representative of the 17th District.

Other candidates who may later vie for the seat include former Democrat councilman Simcha Felder and his predecessor, Noach Dear.

The race to succeed Kruger in a March 20 special election is already getting ugly, with Councilman Lew Fidler, a Democrat, suggesting his opponent, Republican David Storobin, has “ties to skinheads, and neo-Nazi groups and white supremacist groups.”

Both candidates are Jewish. Storobin, a lawyer, is a Russian immigrant who came here in 1991.

Fidler made the charge because some foreign policy columns Storobin has written for a site called Global Politician were linked, without his consent, to neo-Nazi websites. The original articles began to disappear when Storobin announced his candidacy.

“Mr. Storobin should stop hiding his true beliefs,” Fidler spokeswoman Jenn Krinsky said in a statement Tuesday. “If there was nothing offensive in any of these writings or interviews, then why did Mr. Storobin delete them from his website, and leave us only the writings that still exist on white supremacist and hate sites, such as Stormfront, American Renaissance or Phora?”

Storobin’s spokesman David Simpson said Global Politician deleted the posts because it didn’t want to be associated with Storobin’s campaign. He said the allegations were “not only incorrect but offensive.”

Storobin held a press conference with rabbis from Brighton Beach to bolster his Jewish street cred.

“David Storobin is a devout member of our synagogue,” said Rabbi Mordechai Tokarsky of the Brighton Beach Jewish Center, which Storobin attends. “His ancestors, like many of ours, were wiped out by the Nazis, and he himself fled the former Soviet Union to escape religious persecution because of his faith. No one can in good conscience suggest that he has ties to Nazi sympathizers.”

The state’s congressional redistricting map has yet to emerge, but many eyes will be on the 13th District, which now includes all of Staten Island and a small slice of Brooklyn, including Bay Ridge and part of Borough Park.

Incumbent freshman Republican Michael Grimm, who unseated Democrat Michael McMahon in 2010, is facing some uncomfortable questions about fundraising ties to Ofer Biton, an Israeli citizen who is under federal investigation over accusations that he embezzled millions of dollars from Rabbi Yoshiyahu Yosef Pinto’s congregation.

The New York Times reported Saturday that followers and associates of the rabbi, who splits his time between Israel and New York and is often consulted about business dealings by Jewish and non-Jewish personalities, said Biton, Rabbi Pinto’s former aide, strong-armed donations for Grimm that were over the legal limit and from foreign donors without green cards, which is illegal.

The Grimm campaign collected some $500,000 from Rabbi Pinto’s followers for the 2010 race, the Times reported, but not for his re-election campaign this year.

“Any suggestion that I was involved in any activities that may run afoul of the campaign finance laws is categorically false and belied by my life of public service protecting and enforcing the laws of this country,” Grimm, a Republican, said in a statement issued Jan. 27. 

Biton reportedly is pursuing a green card so he can remain and work legally in the United States, according to the Times, and sources told the paper that he may have sought help from Grimm, a former FBI agent.

“It does not look good for him,” said Democrat political consultant Hank Sheinkopf of Grimm’s prospects. “He is a nice, clean law-and-order type who took on the mob. This doesn’t help, but the question is can he be beat? Can the Democrats, instead of eating each other for breakfast raise money and put all their energy into beating Grimm if he remains on the ballot?”

He could only be taken off the ballot if he is convicted of a crime.

“We also don’t know what the lines are going to look like,” said Sheinkopf. “The likelihood is it will probably go further into Brooklyn, to a portion that is becoming more Republican.”

McMahon won the seat after Republican Rep. Vito Fossella decided not to seek re-election after a 2008 drunk-driving arrest and revelations that he had an affair.

JTA contributed reporting to this column.

Last Update:

02/09/2012 - 10:41

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.

Redistricting is really something we all should be concerned with. Sometimes it is a good thing but other times it isn't. I think the problem that most of the public has is that is it all so complicated at times.

Statement on the Proposed Reapportionment of the 49th Assembly District

by Lucretia Regina-Potter

As the Female Republican District Leader of the 49th Assembly District, I vehemently oppose the latest proposed reapportionment of the 49th AD by the NYS Legislative Task Force on Demographic Research and Reapportionment (LAFTOR). The lines that have been drawn are arbitrary, capricious, and politically motivated attempts by the legislators of BOTH parties whose only preoccupation is to preserve their political position.

In my opinion, their actions of self-preservation go even further in the 49th Assembly District. I strongly believe these actions show a clear conspiracy and the outright and prevailing intent to eliminate my position as the duly elected Female Republican District Leader of the 49th AD. This is in fact evident when we look at the map of the new district as suggested by LAFTOR. http://www.latfor.state.ny.us/maps/prop2012a/pa049.pdf

The camouflage becomes more evident when LAFTOR claims that their intent is to create an Asian-American district out of the 49th AD, which has historically been an Italian –American district: a falsis principiis proficisci or a false starting premise. At this point, the question can be raised: Why is an Asian-American district better than an Italian-American district? Why the change? A change of a district lines based only on ethnic reasons is outright wrong, divisive, and even against the law. When we consider that affinity and community interests should be an integral part of the make up of any district we discover that these factors are conspicuously missing.

To cut me out of the 49th AD and place me into the 46th AD serves only to get rid of a viable opponent and possible challenger through a candidacy for office to the powers that be, regardless of political affiliation. It is for these reasons that I strongly support Governor Cuomo’s determination to veto all the proposed redistricting plans. To that effect, I have sent the following letter to only person who has the power to stop this farce and bring positive changes to the actions of those people who make up what has been described as the most “dysfunctional legislature in the United States.”

No one has crossed the Rubicon yet! I strongly urge all people who love good and fair government “of the people, by the people, for the people” to do something. Step up and be counted!

“Ante alea iacta est” or before the die is cast.

Lucretia Regina-Potter is the Female Republican District Leader of the 49th Assembly District in Brooklyn, N.Y. She can be reached at contact@LucretiaRegina-Potter.com

www.LucretiaRegina-Potter.com

Letter to Governor Cuomo:

_________________________________________________________________________________

January 30, 2012

Dear Governor Cuomo:

As the Female Republican District Leader of the 49 Assembly District, I would like to add my opposition to the proposed reapportionment of the NYS Assembly Districts and in particular, of the 49th AD in Brooklyn. The politicians of both parties camouflage the issue under the appearance of creating districts that better represent their ethnic composition. However, they are disenfranchising thousands of people, mostly of the same background who have lived in the same community for generations. The proposed reapportionment of the 49th AD also denies these people of their constitutional right to live in an area of their choice. Many the reasons that affect their choice include affinity, as well as shared geographic and community interests.

My Italian-American ancestors, just like your ancestors, decided to live and raise their family in an area of their choice. I have lived and raised my children in Bensonhurst, one of the most Italian-American communities in the State of New York. This community has always welcomed immigrants of many ethnic groups, and today we can proudly say that our community is one of the best examples of people living together and working hard regardless of their ethnic background. I believe to express the opinion of the greatest majority of the people of Dyker Heights, Bath Beach, Bensonhurst, and Bay Ridge when I say that reapportionments based only on ethnic reason, and disregarding the natural geographical locations and affinity denomination of the population of a community, is not the intended objective of the law.

One example of the political manipulation and distortion of the intent of the law is the 46th Assembly District, where a part of the district is connected to the rest of the district only by virtue of miles of unpopulated highway. This is not only absurd, but also against any practical reason for the establishment of the disparity of such a district.

In my modest opinion, the only reason why the 49th AD is being “sliced and diced” appears to be a direct and blatant attempt to eliminate and remove me from my strong position of District Leader and the destruction of the base of my constituency, thus eliminating any possible future challenges as candidate for public office.

I support your stand on this issue and I sincerely hope that you will veto such a blatant disregard of the rights of the people and reckless actions of members of the legislature of both parties.

Sincerely,

Lucretia Regina-Potter

Republican District Leader 49AD

___________________________________________________________________________________________

Proposed Map of 49th AD-LAFTOR

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.