Anti-Semitism In The Backyard

Local anti-Jewish incidents spur community response.

05/21/10
Special To The Jewish Week
Photo Galleria: 

 Swastikas. Anti-Semitic leaflets littering the grounds of a synagogue and the lawns of private homes. Anti-Semitic comments at a sporting event. Anti-Jewish jokes circulating at a middle school. 

These aren’t exactly the sorts of things that Westchester’s Jewish residents expect to encounter.

Such bias is especially disturbing for Jewish residents who live in some of the county’s prettiest communities, like Rye, Scarsdale, Irvington and Edgemont, where these recent incidents occurred.

Ellen Plum-Rosenberg was shocked to receive anti-Semitic flyers on her lawn, first in March 2009 and again last November.

“It’s bigger than just ‘kill the Jews,’” said Plum-Rosenberg, president of Scarsdale Synagogue-Temples Tremont and Emanu-El. “It’s about racial discrimination and hatred. Let’s talk about racism and prejudice. It’s always there. You need the right social and economic conditions for it to bubble to the top. We need to speak about it. It’s a matter of educating each other. It’s just not acceptable to do this.”

The list of unacceptable actions has grown longer in recent months.

Earlier this spring, a swastika was spray-painted on a public works department bulldozer in Irvington. In April, a swastika was found on the wall of the Irvington train station. At Irvington Middle School, anti-Semitic comments and jokes that students have made to one another — including one student telling another to jump into an oven — have caused distress and soul-searching in the school and larger community. And in mid-May, a girls’ softball game between Solomon Schechter School of Westchester and Edgemont’s Seely Place Elementary School was stopped when some Edgemont players made anti-Jewish comments to some of the Schechter students.

The increase in these disturbing incidents has prompted a variety of responses by the Jewish community. The Westchester Jewish Council (formerly the Westchester Jewish Conference) is hosting a round-table focusing on Jewish institutional security and anti-Semitism. On May 16, Scarsdale Synagogue-Temples Tremont and Emanu-El sponsored a community-wide interfaith symposium on “Understanding Differences-Respecting Diversity,” designed to discuss and address bias incidents.

“We want to reach members of many communities,” said event co-chair, Scott Baken, who is also chair of the Westchester Jewish Council’s security round-table.

Towards that end, the panel discussion featured Heide Mason, chief of the hate crimes unit for the Westchester Country district attorney’s office; Ken Stern, American Jewish Committee director on anti-Semitism and extremism, and Calvin Scholar, a civil rights lawyer and former chief of the hate crimes unit for the Westchester County district attorney’s office. Twenty Westchester organizations that fight bias were also represented, as was Yvette Rugasaguhunga, a survivor of the Rwandan genocide who has been a speaker for the Westchester Holocaust and Human Rights Education Center and who delivered a poignant monologue.

Still, as Stern pointed out in a separate phone interview, anti-Semitic leaflets and swastikas “are not a new thing. In the last 15-20 years, there have been things like this in Westchester.”

Referring to the Irvington incidents, Stern said, “The community should take this seriously. The more important question is not focusing on, potentially, a 16-year-old with a spray can, but what is the community doing in the aftermath?”

In Irvington, the school district has held anti-bias assemblies in each school, including a program from the Anti-Defamation League, “Let’s Get Real,” about the harmful effects of jokes. Some Irvington students have been suspended or disciplined for their comments. According to a letter sent by Dr. Elliot Spiegel, headmaster of Solomon Schechter of Westchester to the school community, the Edgemont softball team and its coach have been asked to come to Schechter to apologize to the students. And Baken hopes to involve the organizations that participated in the May 16 event to develop a forum, “communities in concert,” to deal with bias and prejudice issues as an ongoing commitment.

 

 

Signup for our weekly email newsletter here.

Check out the Jewish Week's Facebook page and become a fan!  And follow the Jewish Week on Twitter: start here.

 

Last Update:

06/27/2010 - 14:51

Get The Jewish Week Newsletter

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.

this is not ture at all. And that doesnt make sens first of all because a majority of edgemont students are true. So stop lying.
"And in mid-May, a girls’ softball game between Solomon Schechter School of Westchester and Edgemont’s Seely Place Elementary School was stopped when some Edgemont players made anti-Jewish comments to some of the Schechter students." It's sad that The Jewish week doesn't bother fact-checking articles before printing them, especially when making such serious accusations. What happened to integrity in journalism?
Anti-Semitism is a terrible blight. We must fight it at every turn. But a false accusation of anti-Semitism is also a terrible thing -- and when it is made so carelessly, as in this article, against a group of 13 and 14 year-old girls, many of whom are Jewish, it is truly incomprehensible and profoundly sad. The allegations against the Edgemont modified softball team, repeated without verification in the article above, are very much disputed by all the players on the team, and by Edgemont's administrators and coaches. Your reporter fails to note that neither the Schechter coach, nor the Edgemont coach, nor the game umpire, heard any of the alleged remarks. Your reporter fails to note that the game proceeded through 6 innings -- including a standard end-of-the-fifth meeting between the two coaches and the umpire, at which no concerns were raised by anyone. Your reporter fails to note that when challenged at the start of the seventh inning, all the Edgemont players strongly denied that any anti-Semitic remarks had been made against anyone. Your reporter fails to note that the majority of the Edgemont players are themselves Jewish, and remain completely mystified and deeply hurt that they are being labeled as anti-Semites. In fact, your reporter failed in every respect by relying entirely on the allegations made by Schechter head master Spiegel in a letter to his community, rather than talking to anyone who was actually present at the game. To paraphrase one of Senator Joe McCarthy's victims ... where do these girls go to get their reputations back? Jewish Week and Merri Rosenberg, will you withdraw this grossly misrepresentative and deeply hurtful account -- or at a minimum, introduce the balance necessary to make clear that the incident as alleged by Dr. Spiegel is NOT accepted by many who, unlike Dr. Spiegel, witnessed the event, and by the deeply principled professionals at the Edgemont School District who thoroughly investigated the allegations and found no basis for them?
"And in mid-May, a girls’ softball game between Solomon Schechter School of Westchester and Edgemont’s Seely Place Elementary School was stopped when some Edgemont players made anti-Jewish comments to some of the Schechter students." "According to a letter sent by Dr. Elliot Spiegel, headmaster of Solomon Schechter of Westchester to the school community, the Edgemont softball team and its coach have been asked to come to Schechter to apologize to the students." According to the Scarsdale Inquirer, the administration of the Edgemont School System made extensive interviews of the people involved, including the players and the coach, and were unable to identify any specific anti-semitic comments made by anybody. Also according to the article, the Solomon Schechter School did not cooperate in this investigation, and made their judgement before any investigation of their own was conducted. The Edgemont Superintendant also pointed out that half of the Edgemont team is Jewish. While not specifically stated as such, it appears that the article in the Inquirer was written without the cooperation of the Solomon Schechter School participants. It seems that the job of reporting both sides of this story has not been done yet, either by you or by the Inquirer. Serious accusations like this should not be made without adequate investigation.

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.