view counter
Survivors Meet Again, Worlds From Sosnowiec
Photo Galleria: 
Ann Welner, left, and Bella Ellerton, center, natives of the same city in pre-Holocaust Poland. Hanie Ellerton
Ann Welner, left, and Bella Ellerton, center, natives of the same city in pre-Holocaust Poland. Hanie Ellerton

Nearly 74 years ago, a pair of young Jewish women left their hometown in southwest Poland, on a transport to a Nazi concentration camp. Both survived the Holocaust, but went their separate ways after World War II.

A random conversation on Long Island last month led to their unplanned reunion.

Shanie Ellerton, a member of Chabad of West Hempstead, brought her mother, Roz Speiser, to one of the synagogue’s Sunday morning social programs for seniors for the first time a few weeks ago. Mother and daughter sat at a table next to a stranger, Ann Welner, a 90-year-old West Hempstead resident who regularly attends the events.

Ellerton detected an accent.

“Where are you from?” she asked.


“Where in Poland?”

“Sosnowiec,” Welner answered.

“My mother-in-law is from Sosnowiec,” Ellerton said. “Maybe you knew her.”

Ellerton’s mother-in-law, Bella — maiden name, Baila Steiglitz — was at home that Sunday morning, but Welner remembered the name Baila Steiglitz from Sosnowiec. “You have to bring her,” Welner told Ellerton. She did, the next week.

While they hadn’t known each other growing up in their hometown, Welner (née Hanka Jerzy) and Steiglitz were together later.

“We were together on the transport, we were together in the camps,” Welner said.

Welner and Bella were on the first major deportation of Jews from Sosnowiec in May 1942. The pair of teenagers was sent to Waldenburg, a labor camp in what is now southwest Poland. They remained together until liberation came in early 1945.

The two women eventually found husbands, immigrated to the United States, had children and made careers. Several years ago they both moved to West Hempstead to be near their children. Although they live about a half-mile from each other, they never crossed paths.

Until Ellerton brought her mother-in-law to the Chabad seniors program.

When Bella was introduced to Welner, she “lit up,” Ellerton said. They started talking in Polish.

“I was just shocked. I didn’t think this was possible,” Welner said.

They’ve since gone back each Sunday, renewing their long-interrupted friendship.

What do they talk about?

They’re not telling. And since the conversations are in Polish, Ellerton doesn’t know. Probably not the war years. Bella never talks about that time, Ellerton said. She said her mother-in-law was born in 1922 or 1923. “No one knows.”

Bella’s memory about details of that time is fuzzy. “I don’t want to remember,” she said.

Ellerton has managed over the years to put together scraps of information about what happened to her mother-in-law during the war — a series of concentration camps and escape from a death march, a story that parallels Welner’s. Both women lost their parents in the Shoah.

Sosnowiec had a Jewish population of 28,000 in September 1939, at the start of the war. About 700 returned after, but most quickly left for the United States or Israel. Today, only a handful of Jews live there.

Both women enjoy the weekly reunion.

Watching the two women get together after all these decades is “an incredible feeling,” said Rabbi Yossi Lieberman, who has served as the Chabad emissary in West Hempstead for the past 14 years. If you do something to bring people together, sometimes they come together in surprising ways, he said.

Welner believes the reunion was not random.

“There are no coincidences,” she said. “Everything is being made above.”

Last Update:

01/18/2016 - 08:17
The Jewish Week App -- Now Available!
view counter


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.

Thank you for such a heartwarming article. What a blessing for these two ladies. And I too agree that there are no coincidences… May I share as gently as possible something that has stuck with me since the thought crossed my mind several days ago...and burdens me terribly? As we lose our Holocaust survivors often their story is lost to us forever. And yet it is the individual’s story that acts to keep our heart pliable toward one another, able to embrace another’s experience with compassion. Perhaps the memories are too hard to bear, too shameful to recount, and when they are we must remember…the story isn’t for us…it is for them…those already forgetting…and their children after them who need to know. It is our gift to the world to help them recognize senseless hate so as to not let it happen to them. Please encourage your parents to allow their stories to be told and preserved through Yad Vashem and USHMM and Prague…ask them to let their voice be heard for many tomorrows, and people they will never meet. Because they are right, G-d causes paths to cross, there are no coincidences. It may be their story that saves a life. Shalom

This is a lovely story and brings up another coincidence. Our organization, The Memory Project Productions, did a Holocaust Remembrance program in Sosnowiec. The program is in partnership with the Galicia Jewish Museum in Cracow. The Memory Project exhibit tours Poland and there are also workshops in which participants make portraits of Holocaust victims and survivors and rescuers. You can see the portraits made by students in Sosnowiec here.

view counter