Study: One In Five NY Jews In Or Near Poverty

Community struggles to respond to ‘immense’ needs, especially among elderly and chasidic.

06/11/13
Staff Writer
Photo Galleria: 

A few years out of the State University of New York at Binghamton, where he was a political science major and an active volunteer in several campus activities, Jeremy Levine works every day at the Manhattan headquarters of UJA-Federation of New York, helping to coordinate many of the anti-poverty programs the philanthropy supports.

He’s initiated a college-application program for high school seniors from indigent families and earlier this year worked on the Pick it Up for Purim campaign that delivered kosher food packages to thousands of needy Jews in the Greater New York area.

Levine, 24, is one of 14 young volunteers from AmeriCorps who are spending the year at UJA-Federation, the Metropolitan Council on Jewish Poverty and other local Jewish agencies that offer aid to poor members of the Jewish community.

Under the auspices of UJA-Federation, the Jewish organizations brought in the AmeriCorps volunteers — the two-decade-old federal program, which operates under the Corporation for National and Community Service, sends more than 80,000 people each year to work at a variety of nonprofits and similar organizations — three years ago in recognition of a demographic problem that was noticed anecdotally and confirmed quantitatively last week: Jewish poverty is rising dramatically.

According to a “Special Report on Poverty,” the last of three reports based on a 2011 study of Jewish New York conducted by UJA-Federation in consultation with Met Council, one out of five Jewish households in the New York metropolitan area is poor.

Story continues after discussion below.

“The scale of Jewish poverty in the eight-county New York area — the Bronx, Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens, Staten Island, Nassau, Suffolk, and Westchester — is immense … overwhelming,” the report stated. “More than 560,000 people live in nearly 200,000 poor and near-poor Jewish households.” That figure, which “represents a doubling of the number of people living in poor Jewish households since 1991, despite only a 14 percent increase in the Jewish population,” includes 48 percent of Jewish children in the region who live in poor or near-poor households.

 

In the last two decades, the percentage of the poor as a part of the overall Jewish community has grown from 12 to 20.

“The numbers largely confirm what we’ve seen happening in grass-roots Jewish communities, making clear to us that this wrenching situation is only growing in scope,” said William Rapfogel, Met Council’s executive director. The report “confirmed the increases in clients needing food and assistance with affordable housing, cuts in services to the elderly due to government cutbacks and especially [the need for] help with careers, both for unemployed and underemployed.”

The report, whose findings were obvious over the last decade to local agencies that serve the poor Jewish population, will not lead to an “immediate” creation of new or altered anti-poverty programs, the participants in a conference call last week that announced the results of the study agreed. But the now-confirmed extent of Jewish poverty will lead to an examination of the current programs, they said.

Met Council, said Rapfogel, is considering a “dramatic expansion” of its food programs, especially the Masbia kosher kitchens that serve free meals to the indigent, and expansion of its programs that serve poor elderly Jews. It is too early to offer specific details, he said.

UJA-Federation, anticipating the findings, started to “redesign” its network of anti-poverty programs in the last decade, said John Ruskay, UJA-Federation executive vice president. That includes, he said, the invitation to volunteers from AmeriCorps, and before that, from VISTA, the federally funded Volunteers in Service to America.

While Jewish poverty has assumed a place of greater importance to communal leadership in recent years, it continues to be an uncomfortable subject for many members of the community, said Rapfogel. “There are still some people in the Jewish community who see poverty as a taboo subject.”

The report, which defines “poor households” as those earning less than 150 percent of the 2010 federal poverty guidelines (annual income of $33,000 or less for a family of four), offers no surprises: the bulk of Jewish poverty here is concentrated in families of fervently Orthodox (haredi) Jews, especially chasidic, who have large numbers of children and minimal secular education; and among families of emigrés from the former Soviet Union, especially the elderly, who are often dependent on government assistance.

Those two groups constitute 43 percent of the total poor Jewish households in Greater New York; non Russian-speaking “senior households” make up 16 percent, and “unemployed or underemployed households” 13 percent.

The Bronx and Brooklyn account for some 60 percent of the total number of poor Jewish households in the area; the areas with the largest percentages of poor Jewish households are Williamsburg, Bensonhurst, Borough Park, Coney Island and Brighton Beach/Sheepshead Bay, all of which are home to large numbers of haredim and/or émigrés.

“The poverty is growing in the suburbs as well,” said Scott Shay, chair of the Jewish Community Study.

“The greater increase in the rate of poverty among people in poor Jewish households compared with [overall] Jewish households may be attributable to the growth in the chasidic community, which includes the largest households,” the report states. “The greater increase in poverty among people in poor Orthodox households (93%) than the increase in poverty among Orthodox households (60%) over the last nine years,” since the previous, major Jewish community self-study, “suggests that large, poor Hasidic households are the reason for the extraordinary increase in people living in poor Jewish households in the New York area.”

Since 2002, according to figures in the report, the percentage of poor Jewish households here with five or more children has doubled from 9 to 18.

The study was based on 5,993 telephone interviews with randomly selected Jewish households — those that include one or more “Jewish adults ages 18 and over” — in the eight-county area. It authors were Jacob Ukeles, Steven M. Cohen and Ron Miller.

Jeremy Levine, who lives in West Hempstead, L.I., began his AmeriCorps service at UJA-Federation six months ago; other AmeriCorps volunteers were placed at Met Council and various Jewish centers and community councils, concentrating on work with poor Jews.

Levine, who worked briefly in real estate after graduating college, applied for AmeriCorps because he’s “always been very big on volunteering.” During the Purim package-delivery program, for example, he visited local sites in advance, and helped pack and load the packages at UJA-Federation headquarters.

The volunteers’ service supplements the work of other volunteers, whose other responsibilities prevent them from devoting their time to anti-poverty activities, said Susan Kohn, executive director of volunteers and leadership development at UJA-Federation.

The philanthropy will apply to renew the UJA-Federation’s ties with AmeriCorps, whose three-year contract ends later this year, Kohn said. The government pays the volunteers’ salaries; participating agencies are responsible for benefits and other non-salary expenses.

The volunteers do both hands-on work, dealing directly with indigent individuals, and executive-level work, designing programs and training other volunteers, Kohn said. Their work has expanded both the number of people served by local agencies and the amount of government benefits they are receiving, she said.

The involvement of the AmeriCorps volunteers has served as an effective, proactive step against local Jewish poverty, Kohn said. “We’re going to continue to invest in it.”

steve@jewishweek.org

Last Update:

12/29/2013 - 07:49

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.

My entire experience of the Jewish community over the past ten years is that it has its collective head up its ass when it comes to poverty. Jews are not poor, just as in years gone by Jews did not commit crimes, divorce, suffer domestic violence, etc. The cruelty I see in this regard on a weekly basis is not only galling but destructive of American Jewry. I have no problem at all pointing the finger at wealthy Jews who refuse to see the Jews in poverty around them, and stick to dinner-party circles. And who protest, time and again, that they're not wealthy. They just happen to have money to take trips all over the world and kit their houses out with professional-grade kitchens, send their kids to $200K schools and $8K summer camps, etc. Horrible.

This article, by the way, still refuses to acknowledge unemployment, underemployment, medical issues, and poverty among non-elderly Jewish families in which the adult(s) are well-educated. Can't happen here, right?

I want to commend the AmeriCorps member, Jeremy Levine, who was interviewed for the beginning of the article. Being an AmeriCorps member myself, I dedicated a year full-time work to make the world a better place. During that year you are only compensated 12,100 as a living expense (which is taxed!!). Employers do not give enough credit to someone who worked for an AmeriCorps program.

I want to say I agree with GAON absolutely.

It is heartbreaking and disgraceful when one considers the incredible brainpower being wasted by the ultra-Orthodox and their refusal to educate their children. And now, they subject them to a life of poverty like some poor immigrant or minority group. It's utterly unsustainable.

In some segments of the haredi community, living in poverty is a lifestyle choice.

Jewish pverty in the metro area is very troubling. However, i am beyond amazed that the article fails to point out the fact that huge Chassidic families attend yeshivas some of which proved ZERO secular training, and do not even teach ENGLISH OR MATH to the boys, The girls get a better deal, re secular subjects, but they are married off so young that being meaningful providers for the family while the Chatan is lomdim yom v'layla is not really feasible. Many many of these families have 12-13 children.
So as they pump out the litter, and the RABBIS exhort them not to participate in the secular world, and do not B'KAVANAH prepare the men for secular jobs. Amongst many (NOT ALL) of the chassidic sects, the men are not trained or expected to provide parnassah of any kind. Same situation in Israel. All living off of the government's teat. I am against giving Jewish Tsedakah to a population that REFUSES to make any attempt to provide parnassah, lomdim yom v'layla, is going to keep the Jewish people safe. So they need to take their pick, teach secular subjects in the yeshivot, or somehow stop pumping out the 12 child litters. and the poverty will continue with that new generation. This is true of most of the Charedim. (not of Chabad as far I know, those guys work even if it is as shlichim all over the world) They are not mostly welfare cases. In contrast many of the others notably SATMAR ban the use of computers in school or at home, even though they take millions from the government for technology upgrades in their schools through the ERATE program, as documented . a short while ago in a three part series here on JW.
MY heart does NOT bleed for cults that do not believe in parnassah, but do believe i average size family of 12-13. (or more). Until the Yeshivot start teaching secular subjects, and even attempt to prepare their bocherim to be family providers, they deserve ZERO welfare. This is what they have chosen, here and in Israel (again NOT ALL Charedim, but most).
No parnassah and in Israel no IDF. Every Charedi is destined to become one of the G'dolim. So let the genius of the G'dolim figure out how to feed their families without stealing from govt. programs, welfare or otherwise, nor from Met Council, busha cherpa, shonda. Don't give them a cent, maybe they will then prepare their young men to work an honest living. aND THEY CAN DO THEIR PRAYING AND DAVENING AND LOMDIM BA LAYLA, after they help their wives with the 12 kids, put the kids to bed. Sheer insanity. I would not give to a charity that had funds allocated to the Charedim for this exact reason. The elderly, agunot, unemployed in a really tough economy, lots of "honestly" poor Jews.

I could have tried to show how your 'facts' are false, willfuly or not, but when you start pumping out such hatred like using the description of "litter" on other human beings, then the only thing left to see is "see you on the other side".

Nichts beim mir. Not by me. I live in Boston. The Jewish Agency here just pretends that Jewish poverty doesn't exist. They suck.

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.