Aberdeen Israel Fund
view counter
NY Post Under Fire For Coverage Of Chasid Murder Case
Photo Galleria: 

Local politicians, including State Senator Simcha Felder and New York City Council Member Stephen Levin , as well as many Brooklyn politicians,  called on the New York Post to apologize for a cover story about the murder of Hasidic landlord Menachem Stark.

“Who Didn’t Want Him Dead?” blared the headline of the Sunday edition, next to a photo of Stark wearing a large shtreiml and graying side curls.

According to the story, Stark “had so many enemies that investigators say they almost don’t know where to start looking.”

The article cited an unnamed law-enforcement source as saying Stark, a 39-year-old father of eight, was involved in several “shady” real-estate deals and was far in debt.

Stark’s body was found on Dec. 3 on suburban Long Island some 16 miles away from his Williamsburg office, from where he was kidnapped the previous evening. He reportedly was suffocated before his body was placed in the dumpster outside a Great Neck gas station and burned, according to police.

Video footage taken from his office reportedly showed Stark being taken into a van after a struggle outside his office in heavily Satmar Williamsburg. The identity of his abductors is not known.

Stark’s brother-in-law, Abraham Buxbaum, speaking on behalf of the family, told The Algemeiner that the headline was “disgusting,” and that “Instead of giving comfort it is just adding salt to the wound.”

He added: “Apologies won’t help, the damage is done, I think,” he added.

“The Post does not say Mr. Stark deserved to die, but our reporting showed that he had many enemies, which may have led to the commission of this terrible crime,” the newspaper said in a statement, in response to criticism of the article and its headline. “Our thoughts and prayers are with the family at this time of loss.”

Stark was remembered by friends and relatives as a “go-to guy” and for being very charitable, as well as for his warmth and sense of family.

Many have threatened to cancel their subscriptions to the newspaper and to organize a boycott of the newspaper, according to reports.


Last Update:

01/08/2014 - 16:18
Algemeiner, Menachem Stark, NY Post, Smcha Felder
The Jewish Week App -- Now Available!
view counter


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.

At the same token, the Jewish community must also embrace the abrupt question as to how this crime came to happen and what it is about Stark or their community that may have incited such behavior in the first place or whether it was just the lonesome act of a madman who may have facilitated such behavior?

As much as any one of us has the right to believe and act in any way that we wish or affirms our belief system one ought to also be aware that sometimes there are points of views and retributions when it comes to transgressive behavior… something that the community ought to be willing to discuss.


The boycott is well under way.I thought it was very irresponsible for the NY POST to rely on unnamed sources and publish negative remarks while ignoring positive ones.They accused him of a crime but neglected to say that Stark sued over it and the city lost.The Post,including Andrea Peyser has a very long history of Orthodox bashing and it is time to fight back.

view counter