view counter
‘Failed Messiah’ Blogger Steps Down

Orthodox community watchdog calls it quits.

Editorial Intern
Photo Galleria: 
Screenshot. Via
Screenshot. Via

After nearly 12 years of exposing controversies, crimes and cover-ups within Orthodox and charedi communities, Failed Messiah blogger Shmarya Rosenberg announced that he will no longer be running his controversial website.

In a Feb. 2 post entitled “Goodbye and Thank You All,” Rosenberg wrote that he plans to work on “anti-poverty issues,” but did not go into further detail, promising to keep readers in the loop through his social media.

Rosenberg created Failed Messiah in 2004, mocking the belief among some Chabad chasidim that the late Lubavitcher Rebbe Menachem Mendel Schneerson is the messiah. Formerly a Chabad chasid himself, Rosenberg, who lives in Minneapolis, was excommunicated from his synagogue and community after a few months of posting about messianism, but continued his work, eventually expanding his coverage to other sects of Judaism. Perhaps most notably, his Internet sleuthing following the raid and subsequent legal action against the Agriprocessors kosher meatpacking plant in 2008 was cited in The New York Times.

Failed Messiah has not been without some controversy of its own. While hailed by some as a sharp investigator and crusader against sexual abuse, political extremism and financial indiscretions committed by Orthodox leaders, the blog has also faced criticism for Rosenberg’s relentless mud-slinging and dismissed as a trolling, attention-hungry tabloid.

While Rosenberg may be leaving the blogosphere, debates surrounding the issues he raised and how he raised them will surely continue in online chatter.

Last Update:

02/09/2016 - 09:12
blogger Shmarya Rosenberg, Chabad chasidim, Failed Messiah
The Jewish Week App -- Now Available!
view counter


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.

As a commenter on failedmessiah pointed out:

Shmarya wrote with his very first post that “Haredim are our enemies."
He also wrote that “Haredism=Lies & Deceit.”
But he he also wrote that “non-haredi Orthodoxy is no better."

Bottom Line: He was someone who considers millions of Jews his "enemy," and I think that is the saddest fact of all.

In addition, I think the recent revelations about his 'books' really shook him...people began to see the vulnerable Shmarya. Sad. [Google "Shmarya Rosenberg books" if you don't know what I am talking about]

So far, no one knows who purchased the site since they have yet to respond to questions. This may well hurt them with their readership.

Goodbye bye and good riddance to this muckraker.

A tremendous loss for all of us. However, the mysteriously abrupt manner of the departure despite Shmarya's unrelenting passion suggests some kind of buyout. We can only hope that the flame will be kept alight, and that Shmarya finds solace and serenity in his new endeavors.

view counter