view counter
EU Commissioner Apologizes for ‘Irrational Jews’ Remark
Photo Galleria: 

(JTA) -- The European Union's trade chief apologized for saying that rational discussion about Israel was impossible with Jews and that the Jewish lobby is the most influential in Washington.

Karel De Gucht, a former Belgian foreign minister who is now the E.U.'s Trade Commissioner, had been asked in a radio interview on Thursday for his opinion on renewed Israeli-Palestinian peace talks launched in Washington.

"That is the best organized lobby that exists there," De Gucht was quoted by The Associated Press as telling VRT, a Dutch-language radio network. "There is, indeed, a religion, I can hardly describe it differently, among most Jews that they are right. So it is not easy to have a rational discussion with a moderate Jew about what is happening in the Middle East. It is a very emotional issue."

The European Jewish Congress immediately blasted the remarks and said they were part of an increasing pattern of anti-Semitism.

“What sort of environment allows such remarks to be made openly by a senior politician?” said Moshe Kantor, the EJC president. “This is part of a dangerous trend of incitement against Jews and Israel in Europe that needs to be stamped out immediately.”

By Friday, De Gucht was apologizing. In a statement he said it was not his intention "to cause offense or stigmatize the Jewish Community. I want to make clear that anti-Semitism has no place in today's world and is fundamentally against our European values."

The European Commission, a body of 27 commissioners from each of the E.U.'s member nations, each handling a different policy area, distanced itself from De Gucht's comments.

Last Update:

09/07/2010 - 12:21

view counter

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.

Karel De Gucht said that the pro-Israeli and/or Jewish lobby has a strong influence in Washington and that this influence leads to the US being more pro-Israel than they would otherwise be. Although he didn’t mention this in the interview (because it was not part of the question), he most likely agrees that Arab leaders are not helping either. Is Karel De Gucht anti-Jewish, antisemite, racist, etc? No, not at all. He is not even anti-Israeli. He has been extremely vocal against all forms of discrimination and has been fighting Belgium’s far-right parties for ages (he once infamously called far-right leaders “cockroaches”). But one of his weaknesses is that he is not always diplomatic and sometimes is a bit blunt. Instead of calling him names, simply dismissing his statements because you don’t like them and calling for his resignation, one should debate whether (or not) he may have a point after all. Finally, ironically, some of the comments here and elsewhere are proving Mr De Gucht’s point - that criticism on Israel (or those acting on its behalf) is immediately censured by accusations of antisemitism - both by individuals and by organisations representing Israeli and/or Jewish interests.
His "apology" stopped short of admitting his statement was factually in error. He should have included that his opinion was not based on facts but only on what he has heard or read without checking the veracity of those remarks himself..

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.