New York Review of Books

The last word on Peter Beinart and the American Jewish leadership

 Can you stand a few more comments and questions about Peter Beinart's controversial article on “The Failure of the American Jewish Establishment” in the New York Review of Books?

It seems to me that on the question of whether big pro-Israel groups reflect the views of the broader Jewish community, Beinart is right, but so are some of this critics.

Beinart Pleasantly Surprised He Hasn’t Been Marginalized

Peter Beinart, the former New Republic editor whose strong critique of the American Jewish establishment in a New York Review of Books essay continues to reverberate in the community, says he has been pleasantly surprised by the responses he has received from pro-Israel critics

Beinart's Buddy: Chait's Rebuttal on TNR.com

Nothing like the satisfaction of being right.  Yesterday, in a blog post, I predicted Peter Beinart's piece in The New York Review of Books would ignite a much needed debate.  And by this morning, dozens of media outlooks were linking to it: here, at Jeffrey Goldberg's Atlantic blog, on Ezra Klein's Washington Post blog, and so on. 

To Elie Wiesel, Please Read Me.

By now Elie Wiesel's newspaper advertisment, which attacked Obama's position on east Jerusalem settlements, is well known.  My editor, Gary Rosenblatt, even got an exclusive interivew with Wiesel about it, which is certainly worth a read.  In short, Wiesel's letter basically said that Obama did not understand the signficance Jerusalem has for Jews.  "Jerusalem is above politics," Wiesel noted, which I'm guessing will be remembered by many as an egregious snaf

Syndicate content