Food and Wine Editor
Checking In On Peck’s

Ratner’s family-owned Brooklyn food shop teams up with Gefilteria.

Photo Galleria: 

Peck's opened on Myrtle Avenue in January. Lauren Rothman/JW

My conversation with Theo Peck, owner of Peck’s, a specialty food shop on Clinton Hill’s Myrtle Avenue, started with onion rolls. Peck, the great-grandson of the owner of the legendary kosher dairy restaurant Ratner’s, and I were reminiscing about the soft, onion-and-poppy-seed-topped rolls the now-shuttered Lower East Side restaurant served: slathered with fresh butter and eaten with a bowl of soup or in advance of a plate of cheese blintzes, they were a dream.

“Oh man, those rolls,” Peck, a New York native who spent many hours in Ratner’s as a kid, recalled. “Let me tell you, if we expanded, the first thing we would do is add a full Jewish-style bakery,” he said.

Instead, Peck’s sources its onion rolls from Orwasher’s, the highly regarded Upper East Side bakery. Aside from the bread, everything else in the small, light-filled store—from the rotisserie chickens to the brisket to the matzoh ball soup to the tongue—is made in-house.

Theo Peck prepares a box of pastries for a customer. Lauren Rothman/JW

Well, almost everything. The nearly two-month-old shop has teamed up with the gang at The Gefilteria, the young foodie-run pop-up that creates contemporary spins on classic Ashkenazi foods such as gefilte fish, beet kvass and horseradish. The Gefilteria’s Jeffrey Yoskowitz, Elizabeth Alpern and Jackie Lilenshtein are fermenting the half- and full-sour cucumber pickles now sold in the Peck’s refrigerator case.

“I’ve got respect for the pour-over pickle,” Peck said, referring to the simpler type of pickle created by pouring hot brine over fresh vegetables. “But let me tell you: I grew up eating pickles before they were trendy, and fermented pickles are true pickles,” he said. Rather than vinegar, fermented pickles utilize only a saltwater brine.

Old-school pickles made by the younger foodie set perfectly encapsulate what Peck’s is all about: a mix of tried-and-true Jewish recipe traditions, enlivened by the wider world of food trends. Sure, there’s hummus here: but it’s served on a sandwich with eggplant caponata, smoked tofu and frisee; there’s brisket, but it’s served on French sourdough with kimchi, Japanese mayonnaise and cilantro. And on store shelves reserved for grocery items, egg noodles and matzo sit side by side with international groceries like Thai hot sauce.

The counter. Lauren Rothman/JW

“It’s a lot to live up to,” Peck says of the Ratner’s legacy. “But that’s not exactly what I want to do. I want to be myself. The store’s not called Ratner’s,” he said. “I’m looking back to the past, but I’m also looking forward, to the future.”

In the near future, Peck’s has a few exciting developments in the works. The first of these is Purim, for which the store is creating a line of near-classic hamantaschen available with apricot, poppy seed and prune-ginger fillings. For Passover, Peck’s will offer a catered spread of braised lamb shanks, brisket, chopped liver and more. And when the weather finally turns warm, Peck’s will unveil its expansive backyard, where it plans to host food events and serve growlers of craft beer.

“I hope that someday we can be a neighborhood hub like Ratner’s was,” Peck said.

455A Myrtle Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11205
(347) 689-4969

Last Update:

04/03/2014 - 19:20


Like all the above mentioned comments. Kosher is Kosher and you should not have published this especially right before Passach. Those un-affiliated would think that the food is Kosher for Passover. MENTION that food is not kosher and especially right before the greatest EXODOUS

How about a feature on a Kosher restaurant ? Treif doesn't cut it. Shame on you for featuring this place and shame on Mr. Peck for forgetting where he came from and the community that provided a livelihood for his family

What a shame that The Jewish Week would feature a non-kosher establishment that makes its living off of Jewish foods. There are plenty of kosher establishments. You should feature them.

I am truly disappointed that this food establishment is NOT kosher and even more appalled that you would have a feature story about it. Why does the next generation (Mr. Peck from Ratner's and the progeny from Kutsher's) forsake the roots that created memories and success? I'll just hold on to the memories.

You are absolutely correct. However, if you want interesting food that is kosher, come to The Five Towns where choices abound. Zomicks makes delicious sweet onion buns but the onion rolls I had at Ratners as a child were unique.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.