‘We Had No Homes To Return To’
04/13/10

Polish-born Frank Blaichman, a member of a Jewish resistance unit during World War II, was the only member of his immediate family who survived the Holocaust. A teen when the war started, he obtained arms by posing as a Polish policeman, traveling through the countryside by bike, committing acts of sabotage against the Nazis, refusing to wear the yellow Jewish star.
The author of “Rather Die Fighting: A Memoir of World War II,” he spoke Sunday at an Upper West Side Yom HaShoah commemoration, hosted by Congregation Ohab Zedek. His speech gave the personal side of Jewish fighters, glamorized in such recent films as “Defiance” and “Inglourious Basterds.”
 

Q: After decades of the “sheep to the slaughter” image of Jews-as-victims, Hollywood has finally discovered Jews who fought back. Why now?

A:I don’t really know how Hollywood operates — I’m a builder and developer. However, when we arrived in the United States, most of the fighting men and women became busy building new lives. Many of us also had to learn a new language — which made it difficult to express myself and tell my story.

At the same time, Jewish organizations were rightly focused on the victims. I became shy of telling my story of armed resistance. I didn’t want to make them feel uncomfortable, as if they could have done what I did, but didn’t. The reality is that resistance during the Holocaust took many forms, and to stay alive was the ultimate resistance.

Why is it important that Jewish resistance be known?

When my comrades and I survived, we thought that Nazism, fascism, racism, anti-Semitism and bigotry were gone forever. We now see that they are alive and well and must be continuously fought.

How accurate is the Hollywood depiction of the partisans? How is it different from what you did?

I have not yet seen a film that accurately and comprehensively depicts what Jewish partisan brigades did. That being said, there are several very fine films. “Defiance” depicted the story of the Bielski group. The Bielskis were dedicated to sheltering Jews and survival rather than military action against the Germans. They had a remarkable story to tell, and it was a very good film.

How different was the experience of Jewish partisan units from mixed units or all-gentile units?

Many units decided to remain under Jewish command in order to hide and shelter Jews who were unable to fight. Jewish partisans in mixed units did not have the opportunity to help other Jews.

We also faced far more hardships and difficulties than the Polish and Russian partisans. We had become orphans overnight and were traumatized. A gentile partisan could decide to quit and return home if he wanted to — we had no homes to return to.

“Inglourious Basterds” focused on revenge. Was that your motivation?

Our first motivation was survival, but that doesn’t mean we didn’t think about revenge. Early on, we had to decide whether we would exact simple revenge when we caught collaborators. We decided, however, that in a world in which there was no justice for Jews, we would hold on to our Jewish principles.

Mitch Braff’s Jewish Partisan Educational Foundation is documenting the memories of members of resistance units. How important is his work?

Very important. There are many organizations in the U.S. that are dedicated to Holocaust remembrance, but the foundation is the only one that teaches about Jewish partisans and armed resistance.

 

 

Signup for our weekly email newsletter here.

Check out the Jewish Week's Facebook page and become a fan!  And follow the Jewish Week on Twitter: start here.

 

Last Update:

11/20/2013 - 20:15

Comments

Sad that Mr. Bleichman in his book, he accuses the Polish resistance, especially Home Army of anti-Semitism. In the Home Army from 1941 was the Office of the Jews, who collected information about the fate of the Jews, send them to the Western Allies, organized help. The Army has worked with subordinate to the Polish exile government "Zegota" Polish Council to Aid Jews, eminently deserved in saving Jews from extermination. Referring to the anti-Semitic organization, it is shameful, especially when using the Jews was irrevocable and immediate death of facilitator, and his family.

At the same time you Bleichman shamefully ignored in a diary their share of the communist apparatus of repression, in leading positions in the Voivod Office of Public Security in Kielce.

In the case of Mr. Bleichman, because of the opportunity to participate in the crimes of Stalin and because of the murder of participants of the Polish resistance movement in Poland initiated an investigation.

I am very proud of the Jewish Partisans. I had the Jewish Partisans Education Group speak at my ORT group. I thank them for keeping the memory of their heroism alive in that terrible 2nd WW time period.btsr Selma Soss Walnut Creek, Ca. 94595
My father was also a partisan in the Genovice Woods in Poland during the Holocaust and it is with great pride that I read of others who resisted and fought back.

my father also was a partisan in the Genovice woods of Poland during the Holocaust. Would love to speak with you. Can you please email me?

We're all very proud of Frank and his life as a partisan and as a Jewish hero after the war. His revenge has been a family and circle of friends who made Hitler's dream of Jewish destruction a failure. Larry Glinzman
I have not heard of this book before, but will buy it immediately and share it with other educators at my school. What an inspiring story. I am glad the Jewish Partisan Educational Foundation was mentioned as well. We use their lessons and study guides all the time. I did not see their website mentioned, www.jewishpartisans.org. JK - Miami

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.