No Time For The Status Quo
11/23/10
Photo Galleria: 

Moshe Maoz, professor emeritus of the Islamic and Middle Eastern studies department at Hebrew University, was here earlier this month for a panel discussion with the Wall Street Journal’s Bret Stephens about Israel, Iran and Syria. A former director of the Harry S. Truman Research Institute for the Advancement of Peace, Maoz is an expert on Arab and Middle East affairs. He spoke to The Jewish Week about prospects for peace.

Q: There are some who argue that peace with the Palestinians is not in the offing and that the best one can do is to manage the situation. Do you agree?

A: This is no time for keeping the status quo. It’s dangerous to do that in the Middle East — there could be another intifada. How long can you keep the Palestinians under occupation and claim sovereignty over east Jerusalem? Without a settlement, there will be no peace with the Palestinians, the Arabs and Muslims. … And the fabric of our society is affected by the occupation and brutalization [of the Palestinians].

If there is no two-state solution, there would be a binational state that has not worked anywhere, as well as requests for Israel to extend equal rights to all Palestinians. I don’t know of any Israelis who would do that, and so we would end up with an apartheid state that the world would not tolerate.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu insisted that Jerusalem should not be included in the 90-day settlement- building freeze, saying Jerusalem would always remain Israel’s undivided capital. Can a Palestinian state be created without east Jerusalem as its capital?

I don’t see any Palestinian Authority government or leader that would accept a deal with Israel without Jerusalem and an arrangement regarding the status of the Jerusalem’s holy places. … If Israel settles those issues with the Palestinians, Arab and Muslims states would then recognize Israel.

What would you recommend?

The Arab Peace Plan, which the Arab League has reconfirmed every year since it was proposed in 2002. Muslim countries also support it. If adopted, Israel would have peace and security and a normalization of relations [with its neighbors] in return for a Palestinian state along the 1967 lines with east Jerusalem as its capital. The refugee issue would also be resolved. In [earlier] negotiations, the Palestinians spoke of permitting 150,000 Palestinians into Israel over 10 years.

Netanyahu has accepted the principle of a two-state solution.

But a Palestinian state means different things to different people. Netanyahu wants east Jerusalem as a part of Israel forever, and that is not going to work. … I think he needs to renew the freeze on settlement-building for another two months so that negotiations on the Israel-Palestinian border can occur. That is the easiest negotiation. It would be based on the 1967 border and land swaps. There are some Israelis who don’t support it, and there is a fear in Israel that it could cause a civil war.

Do you believe a different government in Israel is needed to make peace?

Only a right-wing government can do it. Bibi [Netanyahu] can do it if he wants to; I can’t tell what he is going to do. But I’m inclined to believe that American inducement is very important.

You believe peace with Syria is possible if Israel would only give back the Golan Heights. But the Israeli public is against that.

Before Israel gave back the Sinai, 80 percent of Israelis were against it. But [then-Prime Minister Menachem] Begin did it and then 80 percent were for him. The Israeli military-security establishment advocates giving back the Golan Heights provided Syria stop arming Hezbollah and cool its relations with Iran. And [Syrian President Bashir] Assad would agree to demilitarize the Golan Heights. [Israel announced last week that it would withdraw from the town of Ghajar on the Lebanese border.]

Would Syria really stop arming Hezbollah and cool relations with Iran?

Syria does not want Lebanon turning into a radical Shia state, because Syria is majority Sunni and secular … and it could threaten Syria. Syria has a military alliance with Iran, and I can’t see it cutting relations with Iran. But it could change its military treaty with Iran to delete the paragraph that calls for a mutual defense pact in the event of a war with Israel. And once Israel settles the Palestinian issue, Iran will not have that pretext to hate Israel.

 

 

Last Update:

08/09/2014 - 16:08

Comments

I think that it will take a long time before Israel and Gaza can have a cease fire. I believe that the Jews need to talk to Hamas about calling it truce between the two countries. Than the president of the of The West Bank, Gaza, and Israel might want to have a discussion about a peace agreement and land swaps.

Sincerely
Elesi Ameko

Dear Mr. Ain:

If the Jews and the Palestinians learn how to put their differences aside, they can work together and they can make a difference, and eventually they will have peace in the middle east. The Jews and the Palestinians should work toward promoting diversity in their community. Diversity can provide a wealth of opportunity in the schools, and in the work place. First, the Jewish people should give East Jerusalem back to the Palestinians. Second, the Jews should leave Golan Heights, and the Syrian government should get compensation for their land. Third, I believe the Jews and the Palestinians have the opportunity to make land swaps. However, there is a chance that the Palestinians can create jobs for their people in Palestine. For example, the young people in Palestine can go to school and learn how to develop marketing skills. The Palestinians can also go to college. They can study political science, medicine, science, auto mechanics, computer tecnology, and engineering. As a result the Palestinians can manufacture products. Israel and the world can buy these products from the Palestinians at an affordable price. The economy will improve in the middle east. The world economy can benefit from Israel and Palestine because their countries have alot of resources. When the Jews and the Palestinians learn how to work together, they can break alot barriers through diversity, equal opportunity and an education. My email address is amekoelesi1@gmx.com

Sincerly, Elesi Ameko

The Israelis are creative when they turn the waste land into a fertile place like the Golan Heights. Golan Heights is a beautiful place. I want to visit Israel.
If the Golan Heights is a part of Syria, Israel should give the land back to Syria.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.