view counter
Needed: Creative Solutions For Jewish Schools
Mon, 10/18/2010 - 20:00
Special To The Jewish Week

Growing up in Riverdale, I attended Salanter Akiba Riverdale Academy, known as SAR, a private, Jewish Modern Orthodox day school. The school is built on a hill overlooking the Hudson River, and, in a manner somewhat similar to step farming, is composed of various levels, on and between which there are no walls. I remember taking a test in eighth grade, and doing my best not to be distracted by the first graders learning the difference in pronunciation between the Hebrew letter vav with a dot on top (they all touched their heads and screamed Oh!) and the letter vav with a dot near its center (they grabbed their tummies and screeched Oooooh!). When my father drove carpool in the morning, and we began the descent down the big hill, the glistening river looming in the near distance, we’d yell, Don’t drive into the river!

A lot has changed since the late 1970s, when SAR knocked down school walls, got rid of report cards in favor of anecdotals, and built a learning institution on a precarious hill at the edge of a great river. What do our structures look like now? And who is knocking down the walls? PEJE, the Partnership for Excellence in Jewish Education, is gearing up for its 2010 Assembly for Advancing the Jewish Day School Field. In a sense, it’s convening thought-leaders from across the spectrum of Jewish day schools to continue to try and ensure that, as a community, we don’t drive into the river.

UpStart Bay Area works with Jewish innovators within and beyond existing institutions to identify the greatest challenges facing our community today, and to imagine creative approaches to meeting them. Here, in my opinion, are some of the most important challenges facing the world of Jewish schools. We need innovative thinkers and actors to help identify the problems, and to imagine and act on creative solutions to address them.

1. After Hours

Research done by Brigid Baron at Stanford University has shown that children spend only 18 percent of their time at school. That means that 82 percent is spent outside of school, many hours of which they are online or in front of screens. How can our day schools collaborate creatively with parents and others to create a wider-reaching learning environment for children, which extends not only beyond the school’s walls, but beyond its hours? How can existing communal structures, and new ones, work with schools to meet the learning needs of children outside of school?

2. Competitive Edge

What can our schools learn from the best innovative practices of other institutions? Jewish day schools need to think hard about their competitive edge. The New York Times Magazine recently published its education issue, with a story focused on a teacher at a New York City public school offering a “Sports for the Mind” class, in which students designed their own video games. The article notes that in this class, students receive grades like they do at the end of a game, like “novice” or “expert.” The kids also experience setbacks differently, according to the piece: “they play for five minutes and they lose … they play for ten minutes and they lose. They’ll go back and do it a hundred times. They’ll fail until they win ... failure in an academic environment is depressing. Failure in a video game is … completely aspirational.” Do our schools have “Sports for the Mind” classes, or their equivalent? How are we motivating students to be excited about school, to keep school relevant and interesting? How are we challenging the notions of what a learning environment should be? Which of our day schools are held up as models for the rest of the country, and perhaps the world?

3. Innovative Models

We have tools at our disposal that are both ancient and innovative, like, for example, chavruta learning, the Talmudic method of Torah study in pairs. Today’s educational research reveals that cooperative learning yields curious, engaged, knowledgeable students. How can we harness the unique tools at our disposal to create innovative, replicable learning methodologies?

4. Purpose

Finally, and perhaps most importantly, what is the purpose of a Jewish day school education? Our schools need to think hard about the passionate goals and values that are their foundations. What are the lessons behind our lessons, the meta-lessons, that Jewish day schools, and no other learning environment, can provide our community’s children? And what is the relationship between those lasting values and passions? Can we create a Jewish community of highly aware, passionate, curious, creative individuals who share powerful common values, respect differences, and interact in a global environment with holiness and integrity?

This is a timely point in the Jewish calendar to be grappling with these issues. We are emerging from the cocoon of the New Year’s holiday cycle. We have been involved in deep personal introspection, and communal celebration. It’s time to get back out there, and get to work. Let us be inspired to re-imagine our schools, to take risks in building learning environments that may, at first, seem to totter at the edge, but which, in the long run, will prevent us from ending up in the river. 

Maya Bernstein is the Director of Education at UpStart ,  which works with innovators within and beyond existing organizations to implement creative solutions to meet the changing needs of the Jewish community in the 21st century.


Brigid Baron, Day Schools, Jewish Education, Salanter Akiba Riverdale Academy

Our Newsletters, Your Inbox


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


I appreciate very much that you are encouraging us to question some fundamental assumptions of design, not just to tinker around the edges of the way we approach learning and educational institutions. I found the quote, "failure in an academic environment is depressing. Failure in a video game is … completely aspirational" totally moving. Our education systems (FT and PT) should be cultivating this appetite -- not only while in school, but for a lifetime.
Maya, you raise some interesting challenges for us to consider. The research you cite about what little time children spend in school (18%) is quite provocative. The next generation is being influenced by so many competing forces. If we want day school learning to have traction for the long haul, then we must conceptualize learning as being life-long. Jewish education is not just for kids. Adults, including parents and grandparents, need opportunities to learn about Jewish life, values, and teachings and, in turn, transmit their joy and enthusiasm to the younger generation. But first we need to define “life-long learning.” What might such learning look like it is to be both compelling and long term? There are many wonderful examples throughout the country. PEJE’s upcoming Assembly will spotlight innovative projects such as the growing PJ Library (sponsored by the Harold Grinspoon Foundation) and a new venture of the Kohelet Foundation whereby parents receive a modest day school tuition support for their children in return for a yearly commitment to traditional learning. Combined Jewish Philanthropies just began an initiative in Boston through which first-time day school families with a child entering kindergarten receive 25% off tuition. I think that the impact of all three projects is worth watching and tracking carefully. Maya’s call to heed best practices is right on. I have benefitted tremendously from the wisdom that emanates from several publications—notably National Association of Independent School’s Trustee Handbook, Philanthropy at Independent Schools, Guide to the Head Search Process, and Reducing Reliance on Tuition, and from Independent School Management’s monthly publications. Maya also cites George Lucas’ edutopia website as a valuable and under-utilized resource for Jewish schools. I agree: it is well worth a look by every teacher and administrator. I am always curious to hear about other projects and best practices the field is following and look forward to continuing this conversation.