view counter
On Jerusalem Day, Don’t Write Off Liberals
Mon, 05/03/2010 - 20:00
Special To The Jewish Week

May 12 (Iyar 28) will mark 43 years since the Israeli army’s triumphal entry into the Old City of Jerusalem. This is certainly a moment for the Jewish People to celebrate the restoration of Judaism’s holiest sites to our people.

Recently, however, rather than providing a moment for us to come together to celebrate our spiritual patrimony, Jerusalem Day has been seized upon by some as an occasion to divide us, to push aside those who are pro-Israel and pro-peace and to impugn their devotion to Israel. We are told that we must either adopt an uncompromising view on the future status of Jerusalem including its conquered Palestinian neighborhoods or be written out of the pro-Israel community.

The reality of Jerusalem is complex, and has been throughout its history. The “official” view that presents Jerusalem as seamless and undivided is inaccurate, and it is misleading and unconstructive to accord the same measure of holiness granted to the Western Wall to every new Jewish suburb or Palestinian village that is added to the city by expansion. Furthermore, the notion that Jerusalem can be both undivided and shared is viewed as naïve, and those who suggest such an alternative are accused of disloyalty, or even of endangering the State of Israel itself. If we want to talk peace, we’re told, Jerusalem must not be on the table. But, of course, this precludes genuine negotiations.

In recent weeks, some in the “pro-Israel” camp have made clear that they have little interest in promoting substantive peace talks, including any discussion of the future of Jerusalem, which in the eyes of the world remains to be resolved. This has become part of a larger pattern of resistance to any progress towards peace, under the false assumption that the status quo is beneficial for Israel and can be sustained. The assertion by President Obama that progress toward peace between Israel and the Palestinians is vital both for Israel and for the United States is claimed as evidence that Obama is hostile to Israel.

It’s time for the pro-Israel, pro-peace community to speak out. It must not allow itself to be intimidated by well-intentioned but ultimately dangerous voices whose resistance to genuine progress towards peace endangers the future of Israel as a Jewish and democratic state.

Jerusalem is the spiritual heart of the Jewish people — the whole Jewish people. But Jerusalem belongs to the whole Jewish people, not to one side of the political spectrum. What could be more politically offensive than using our attachment to Jerusalem’s holy sites to forestall progress on resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict? What can be more dangerous to Israel’s future than placing obstacles on the road to peace through a two-state solution that respects the differing narratives of two peoples? 

At a recent protest over Palestinian home evictions and demolitions in the east Jerusalem neighborhood of Sheikh Jarrah, Israeli author David Grossman offered a scathing indictment of our heretofore uncompromising attitude: “We actually cultivated a kind of carnivorous plant that is slowly devouring us,” he said, “consuming every good part within us, making the country we live in a place that isn’t good to live in. Not [for anyone] ... who cherishes some hope to be in a place where ... humanity, morality, and civil rights aren’t dirty words.”

The ongoing conflict threatens not only our values, but the State of Israel itself. The demographic realities indicate that it will soon be impossible to maintain a state that is both demographic and Jewish. Israel’s security and prosperity can only be achieved through a negotiated two-state solution, whereby a peaceful and viable Palestinian state lives alongside a secure Israel. Jerusalem can remain undivided and serve as the capital of two independent countries. This is only solution that is compatible with both our interests and our values and will restore Israel’s standing in the international community.

A majority of American Jews already knows this to be true. Jerusalem Day is the appropriate occasion for us to come together and reaffirm our commitment to peace. “Jerusalem” means “city of peace” and “city of wholeness.” We need to come together on Jerusalem Day to support a peace, strategic, spiritual and ethical, which leads to a restoration of relationships and an end to the demonization of the other.

On this Jerusalem Day, I pray with the Psalmist: “Pray for the well-being of Jerusalem; May those who love you be at peace. May there be well-being within your ramparts, peace in your citadels. For the sake of my kin and friends, I pray for your well-being; for the sake of the house of the Lord our God, I seek your good.”

Rabbi David Gordis is the former president of Hebrew College and a member of J Street’s rabbinic cabinet.


Signup for our weekly email newsletter here.

Check out the Jewish Week's Facebook page and become a fan!  And follow the Jewish Week on Twitter: start here.


Our Newsletters, Your Inbox


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


Liberal Jews are the main problem. Imagine if all Jews - liberal, conservative, reform, conservative, reconstructionists,orthodox - were united behind a strong Israel and Yerushalayim.We have an enemy that is steadfast about destroying us. They are sworn to delegitimize the Jewish connection to Israel and especially Jerusalem. If the Jewish community stopped acting like sheep and started believing in their religion and the almighty, we would not be facing this kind of enemy. Our enemy uses our divisiveness to their advantage. Unlike our enemy, we are not united behind a strong Israel and Jerusalem. We as a people are willing to surrender our heritage to the enemy, which is sad. We have lost our way - we believe in materialism instead of the true meaning behind life. we believe if we give in to our enemy, we will be accepted. As a people, we have to be taught a lesson before we realize the true significance of Israel and what it means to the entire Jewish people, not just the Orthodox. A united Jewish peopel will bring peace and strength in our land. The future is bleak if we continue the pathof divisiveness.
As a Likud voter, I can contemplate splitting off certain Arab neighborhoods of Jerusalem to a future Palestinian state for the sake of a true peace. True peace will come when the Palesitinians the the rest of the Arab world stops denying our historical connection to this land and to Jerusalem in particular, when they stop inciting violence because we have rededicated the Hurva Synagogue which they destroyed in 1948, and when they accept that we have fundamental rights to this land that go back way before the word "Palestine" was given to the land by the Romans. The moment the Palestinians stop telling the world we are outside collonialists, then you will see any Israeli government in power, be it left or right, will bend over backwards to make a Palestinian state viable and successful. Mr. Gordis, it behooves you and J-street to internalize these facts: that the root cause of the entire conflict is actually Palestinian and Arab intransigence and their denial of our historical connections here, and therefore their continued attempts to, yes, destroy Israel, either through warfare like Hamas, or lawfare like Abbas. J-sreet and the Obama Administration have not helped at all. Their finger-pointing at Israel has only hardened the Arab position and made peace less likely, not more.
Anyone talking about Jerusalem as 'undivided' has never tried to catch a cab from a Jewish neighborhood on the west side to an Arab neighborhood in the city center, like Sheikh Jarah. It's a bitterly divided city. Palestinians, secular Jews and Orthodox Jews all despise each other to a greater or lesser extent. God willing, after my fellow Israelis figure out how to withdraw from Arab East Jerusalem, we'll figure out how to allow women to read the torah at the kotel without having soiled diapers hurled at them. Give me Tel-Aviv any day over Jerusalem. Charles Lenchner Brooklyn