How The Bat Mitzvah Has Changed: A Grandmother Reflects
Tue, 02/08/2011
Special To The Jewish Week

At my daughter’s bat mitzvah celebration on Oct. 31, 1981, I was nervous, excited, joyful and awed at the sight of a 12-year old girl standing on the bima of our Conservative synagogue, reading a large section of the Torah portion from its scroll, then chanting her haftarah.

At my granddaughter’s bat-mitzvah celebration on Jan. 22, 2011, I was nervous, excited, joyful and perfectly at ease at the sight of this 12-year-old girl standing on the bima of our Conservative synagogue, reading the entire Torah portion from its scroll, chanting her haftarah, conducting the Torah service, and leading the congregation in “musaf,” the additional prayer service on Shabbat morning.

Their performances and my reactions to them offer a bird’s-eye view of the enormous changes in Jewish women’s roles during the past three decades.

To be sure, in 1981, bat mitzvah ceremonies were the norm in the Conservative movement, and the sight of a girl on the bima did not shock anyone. Yet, the sight of women in general on the bima was not ordinary, not an everyday occurrence. It would be almost four more years before this movement would ordain women as rabbis, and longer for female cantors. Women might be called for “aliyot,” to recite the blessings before and after the Torah reading (and some synagogues did not even allow that), but not many chanted out loud from the Torah as my daughter did. The bima was still a man’s place, with women putting in occasional appearances.

In the Orthodox movement, a bat mitzvah celebration meant a party on a Saturday night, maybe a Sunday breakfast or luncheon, occasionally a girl giving a d’var Torah, a brief talk on the Torah portion. When my daughter began studying her Torah portion and haftarah, the boys in the Orthodox day school she attended teased her. Why was she doing that? A girl’s reading doesn’t count, after all. The classmates who came to her bat mitzvah were advised by the school to pray at home first and to view her readings as a performance, like an opera or popular musical. They did not really count as part of a religious service.

Nobody today would think to tell my granddaughter that her part in the services didn’t count. Although in the Orthodox community girls may still celebrate their bat mitzvahs on a Friday night or Sunday afternoon, many conduct parts of the ritual themselves. Some read from the Torah or haftarah in a women’s minyan; others give learned d’var Torahs. Almost all know that a girl can be as skilled in Jewish practices as her brother — or more so.

In my granddaughter’s Conservative world, of Manhattan’s Solomon Schechter School and Camp Ramah, it is taken for granted that girls learn the same things boys do and use their skills equally. Not every girl or boy conducts as much of the service as she did (I have to brag a little, don’t I?) but the expectations are the same. All learn to read Torah and each child has a classroom bar or bat mitzvah ceremony. Everyone counts, for one another and for the Jewish community.

I never had a bat mitzvah celebration. Nobody I knew did. Although Judith Kaplan, Mordecai Kaplan’s daughter, had the first bat mitzvah back in 1922, for many years only a handful of girls followed her example. Some of my feminist friends say they resented not having the festivities their brothers had. I didn’t. I heard my brother practice for his bar mitzvah, learned the cantillations with him, and was grateful I didn’t have to perform. He could keep all the fountain pens and Swank tie clips (de rigueur gifts in those days); I was happy to be an observer. Not until much later, not until my daughter’s bat mitzvah, did I recognize the satisfaction that can come from mastering a Torah portion or chanting a haftarah before a congregation.

When someone asked Eliana, my granddaughter, beforehand whether she would be nervous at her bat mitzvah celebration, she said, “I’ll probably be nervous, but I’ll be prepared.” If she was nervous, it didn’t show, but the year of intensive preparation did. She looked poised and confident executing every one of her duties, her beautiful voice chanting the text or leading the congregation in song. It would never occur to her that it was enough, as a girl, to be an observer at her brothers’ bar mitzvahs.

Her mother, my daughter, knew of the battles a previous generation fought to give her a voice in Jewish life and liturgy. To my granddaughter they are ancient history. Why, she might wonder, would a girl not be allowed to come of age Jewishly in the same way a boy does? In that wondering lies the success of the past decades. And I feel blessed.

Francine Klagsbrun’s most recent book is “The Fourth Commandment: Remember the Sabbath Day.”

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.

Comments

Ok, this isn't going to be P.C., but I hope you post it anyway. Francine Klagsburn has shunned the "closed minded" Orthodoxy in which she was nurtured to become the flag waving Conservative Jew within. I have gone the opposite way, fleeing Solomon Schechter, USY, Ramah, and JTS to become an Orthodox rabbi. Although there certainly were many benefits and nice things about CJ, the reality was that few of my friends who grew up that way stayed. Some strayed towards the direction I took, while most abandoned Judiasm altogether mostly marrying out. It is nice that Ms. Klagsburn can shep nachus for her daughter and granddaughter and the latter's Schechter education. But how high are the odds that she'll carry this very far -- what are the odds that she'll go to college, hang out with nice non-Jewish boys and marry one. Even in Schecter they can't stem the tide -- the Jewish ran a story a few years back about students wanting to bring non-Jews to their prom. How many Schecter kids keep kosher? How many will? I am guessing very few. Most will like my friends (and high odds Klagsburn's granddaughter) marry non-Jews and forget everything outside of Pesach Seder. That seems to be the legacy of Conservative Judaism. My daughters attend Orthodox schools. They did not read Torah in synagogue (I don't think the boys should either) but we did finish sections of the Mishna, Talmud, major works of Jewish philosophy, and Tanach for their bat-mitzvah ceremonies. That had Torah oriented celebrations full of excitement, joy, and separate dancing . All the kids come from kosher homes and most if not all will (you can never be 100% sure of anything) will maintain these standards when they marry. I'll take learning Torah deeply and maintaining a Kosher Shabbat observant home over a public reading of Torah in synagogue just to show off any day.

Nice article.

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.