Battle at Rutgers: When ‘Never Again’ Is Misused
Wed, 02/02/2011
Special To The Jewish Week
Photo Galleria: 

Never Again!

These words express the determination of all who vow never to allow another Holocaust against anyone. Yet these words are being abused by a new national tour entitled “Never Again For Anyone,” a program that seeks to link the atrocities committed against the Jewish people by the Nazis to Israeli governmental policies.

Many have heard about the events that unfolded at Rutgers University last Saturday when the “Never Again For Anyone” organizers changed their entrance policy and barred students and members of the community from entering. Some 400 pro-Israel students and community members gathered before the event to stage peaceful demonstrations against it.

The program’s sponsors and campus endorsers, including Rutgers’ student organization BAKA: Students United for Middle East Justice, had advertised that this program was “free and open to the public.” However, that night, in the face of the rapidly growing number of protesters, the decision was made to charge admission to all in attendance. Sara Kershnar, founder of the International Jewish Anti-Zionist Network (IJAN), explained to those already inside the event that, “When we saw that there were … Zionists outside, we decided to charge.”

After witnessing the removal of a sign outside proclaiming that no one would be turned away for lack of funds, I saw that many students who were BAKA members and their partners entered the event for free. Since BAKA members were receiving preferential treatment, I asked to join the group. My attempt was denied (violating a Rutgers policy that requires official organizations to accept all Rutgers students), and so I joined the hundreds of students waving their student ID’s above their heads chanting, “Free and open to the public,” the language that had been used on invitations as well as the “Never Again For Anyone” website.

Unfortunately, my friends never made it inside the event, but I was kindly given $5 and pushed to the front to enter.

But this is not about $5, $10 or $20. It is about honesty and integrity.

According to Kershnar, Israel’s policies toward Palestinians mirror the murder, starvation and dehumanization that Jews experienced at the hands of the Nazis and that the intent of the “Never Again For Anyone” national tour was to send a universal message of “Never Again” in the face of what she terms “the ethnic cleansing” of Palestine.

Members of the panel, which included two Holocaust survivors, asserted that Zionists had manipulated the experiences of Jews in Europe to justify Israel’s mistreatment of Palestinians. The personal accounts of Hedy Epstein and Dr. Hajo Meyer, both Holocaust survivors (and veteran anti-Israel activists), as well as Dawud Assad, a survivor of the Deir Yassin massacre were incredibly sad and moving. Yet moved though I am by their stories, I reject their baseless conclusion that Israeli policies are akin to those of the Nazis.

Speaking to the 130 individuals who had gained admittance, the program’s final speaker, Osama Abu-Irshaid, a member of American Muslims for Palestine, charged, “You have the offspring of the victims of the Holocaust justifying a Holocaust committed against another people!” Make no mistake, despite repeated assertions that this event would not suggest that Israeli policies in the West Bank and Gaza constituted a Holocaust, Mr. Abu-Irshaid expressed that this was the case.

There are three issues involved with linking the Holocaust to the current situation in Gaza and the West Bank. First, the Holocaust cannot be compared to any event in human history without insulting the memory of those executed by the Nazis. Politicizing the Holocaust diminishes its significance and minimizes the suffering of its victims.

Second, by comparing it to the Holocaust, the event organizers have also done an injustice to many Palestinians who are truly suffering. Delegitimizing the experience of those who live in Gaza and the West Bank promotes hatred, not healing, the true goal of the event organizers. Yes, Israel is at fault for some of it, but focusing solely on Israel completely absolves Hamas and Fatah, both of which have committed the crimes of which they accuse Israel, as well as terrorist funders across the Arab world and in Iran.

Third, the demonization of the State of Israel is unjustified as it focuses solely on Israel as the root of all problems.

According to the U.S. State Department’s definition of anti-Semitism, “Criticism of Israel similar to that leveled against any other country cannot be regarded in itself as anti-Semitic.”

However, “Drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis” is, in fact, not only anti-Zionist, but anti-Semitic as well.” The “Never Again for Anyone” tour will bring its message to 12 different cities. Campuses and communities across America must understand its message and goal. Its target is not only Israel, but the right of the Jewish people to our history.

We are ready for this fight. Last Monday evening, Reps. Leonard Lance and Frank Pallone attended a dinner sponsored by Rutgers Hillel and local Jewish federations to speak to over 100 student leaders about the significance of the U.S.-Israel relationship. My fellow students and Israel activists are unafraid of passionate debate, but we are prepared to confront all those who undermine Israel and threaten the security of the Jewish people. Never again should anyone misuse the Holocaust to advance a political agenda.

Never again!

Sam Weiner is junior at Rutgers studying Jewish Studies and Political Science. He is a member of Rutgers Hillel and is a member of the board of directors of Hillel International.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.

Comments

WHEN HOLOCAUST SURVIVORS DO NOT DEFEND ISRAEL AND SUPPORT THOSE WHO CALLS US ZIONISTS IN A DEROGATORY FASHION, WE NEED TO SPEAK OUT. I WAS THERE. THEY DID NOT WANT THE 150 ZIONISTS TO SPEAK OUT. THESE HOLOCAUST SURVIVORS ARE TRAITORS AND SHOULD BE ASHAMED OF THEMSELVES. HOW DARE THEM USE THE TERM NAZI IN THE SAME BREATH WITH ISRAEL.HAVE THEY FORGOTTEN THE ARABS WANTED TO ANNIHILATE THE JEWS IN ISRAEL. WHAT ABOUT THE ARABS WHO SIDED WITH HITLER AND CREATED SS UNITS. HAVE YOU FORGOOTEN THE MUFTI OF JERUSALEM WHO LIKE HITLER WANTED EVERY JEW TO PERISH.
The two comments by so-called Anonymous shows how one sided the event was. The simple fact that over four hundred Jewish students and their campus supporters were denied entrance to a Rutgers student event reeks of anti-Semitism. Rutgers officials should be ashamed of themselves for their Nazi-like attitude of making a Rutgers event "Judenrein" with the exception of a few select Kapos.
No one was denied entrance. Here is a letter in today's Daily Targum explaining what happened: http://www.dailytargum.com/opinions/baka-deserves-apology-for-defamatory-accusations-1.2459186 check your facts next time.

He was there, and so was I. I think we know better than a newspaper reporter.

Alarming programs like this one and the abuse of Jewish students on college campuses as documented by "Crossing the Line" a film by The Clarion Fund is extremely alarming. These are our future leaders. While Israeli teenagers do their military service, our children are being indocrinated with lies on college campuses. Watch the documentary by SWC, "Against the Tide" to see what happened in the US during the Holocaust and how indifference and inactive can result in death. Israel is our homeland. It is our refuge. It is essential to the security of the US. The world's problems do not come from thius tiny country. As Jews we have an obligation to our people to teach our history to our children. As US citizens we have an obligation to keep our country safe from terror. My parents were Holocaust survivors who despirately wanted to go to Israel or the US. They were trapped and went by cattle car to Aushwitz instead. Go to www.jerusalemonlineu.com and take the course, Israel Inside/Out.
This article is absurd and is riddled with logical fallacies. 1. This has nothing to do with politics. 2. It's clear that you missed the entire point of the event, to show that both peoples have suffered and it's not an entirely one sided affair as so many Israelis would have you believe. 3. This is an absurd generalization, I don't think anyone solely blames Israel. Also, the claim about anti-Semitism is completely illogical. The holocaust is a part of history, no more or less sacred than any other part. This has nothing to do with "the right of the Jewish people to our history," and everything to do with seeing another side of an issue that goes wholly undiscussed in American politics.
I completely agree. Being an attendee of the event, I can say that there was absolutely no Antisemitism present at the event - on the contrary, there was a deplorably massive case of Islamophobia and racism. The event was about Justice in the Middle East for All. The end of the conflict would bring peace to everyone, so still, days later, I am unable to comprehend why the event fostered so much trouble. From what I have been hearing however, this has been a long time coming on Rutgers. As an organization, RU Hillel is famous for its anti-Islam propaganda. We at the school are still dealing with the loss of Tyler Clementi, we have no need for the kind of racist slanders and cyberbullying that the Middle Eastern students of our school have been subject to.

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.