For Argument’s Sake
Tue, 11/20/2007

In my first Talmud class, I was given an invaluable piece of advice.  My teacher told us that if we were ever drifting off, or not paying attention, and were asked a question, to answer “there’s a machloket” — a disagreement.  If you say that, he commented with a sparkle in his eye, you will always be right.

Jews do disagree.  In the Bible Abraham argues with God and the people argue with Moses. The Talmud is one formidable catalogue of argumentation.  As for us — well, we all argue with one other.

But our arguments are not only with each other.  The great Jewish argument goes on with God and also inside ourselves, trying to reconcile ourselves to the mystery of God’s world, trying to understand our place in it.  You might think that arguing inside yourself creates only friction, but the poet Yeats had it right when he wrote that “Out of our arguments with others we make rhetoric; out of our arguments with ourselves we make poetry.”

Judaism is the contrapuntal poetry of points of view contending with each other, seeking always to find the more refined, more accurate, more crystalline view.  Maurice Samuel said years ago that the Jewish people have survived so long because we refuse to die before we have figured this whole thing out.  Well, we haven’t yet, but we’re still arguing about it.

Rabbi David Wolpe is spiritual leader of Temple Sinai in Los Angeles.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.