Aberdeen Israel Fund
view counter
Move The Mosque
Mon, 08/02/2010 - 20:00

 The Jewish Week misses the point in its editorial concerning the Ground Zero Mosque. (“A Mosque Near Ground Zero,” July 30)

It is safe to say that a New York mayor’s leadership can move mountains on virtually any issue. I say categorically that Michael Bloomberg’s leadership is a gift that this great city shall not soon see once his term concludes. Particularly in education and public safety, I have seen his proficiency up close. It is therefore disappointing that he has, in a most facile manner, dismissed the opposition to the Ground Zero mosque.

Americans, and indeed New Yorkers, are good people who take others at their word. However, as columnist Cal Thomas has noted, “One cannot fight an eastern war with western values.” Islamists play by different rules. Suffice to say that Imam Feisal Abdul Rauf’s recorded pronouncements to varied audiences are not consistent with pluralistic American values. It is difficult for the mayor to accept that some do act in a duplicitous manner to achieve their goals. This is akin to the fruitless negotiations that our president engaged with the president of Iran. While Imam Rauf is surely no Ahmadinejad, he nonetheless shares the trait of “stretching the truth with the infidels.” I will not repeat his outrageous statements on America’s complicity in 9/11, Shari’a advocacy and the like — they are available to all who are interested. Further, even the Vatican would be in no position to erect a $100-plus million house of worship. The federal government sees fit to examine the bona fides of foreign funding sources. Why do we not care in New York?
This is at its most basic level a matter of common decency. Rubbing salt in the wounds of the 9/11 families and Americans in general is indecent. There are many, many mosques in New York City and many other locations where Imam Rauf can make a statement with a grand mosque (which already exists on 96th Street), and where he can preach pluralism and common decency to the many millions of Islamists amongst the followers of the prophet.
Jeffrey S. Wiesenfeld
Great Neck, L.I.
The writer is a former aide to Mayor Ed Koch and Gov. George Pataki and a current trustee of the City University of New York.


Our Newsletters, Your Inbox


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


Mr Weisenfeld's editorial says it perfectly! There is no doubt that "Islamists play by different rules." Americans are easily taken in by kind words and promises, but do not understand the real game--which is really about those who may wish to impose their culture, rules and religion on us. How many times must it be stated that the majority of the families and friends, and people living nearby, do not wish to have this mosque built in this area?! How can it be that the Mayor, the Community Board and many politicians have forgotten the events that devastated so many Americans on that day? Would the building of this mosque have ever been an issue during the years just following this tragic event? But unfortunately, there is a smaller segment of the population who have become so "politically correct" in their thinking, that they have lost the true meaning of what is right, and what is seriously wrong here. As Mr Weisenfeld states, there are many other mosques throughout NYC, so why this particular venue, especially one where there is great controversy? If the Imam really wants to demonstrate his understanding and feelings for the 9/11 victims and their families, the project should be moved to another location in the City. The longer it takes for the Imam to disclose the funding and answer any other pertinent data needed regarding the proposed mosque, the more apparent it becomes that it is being built for less than legitimate reasons!
As a student of Middle East History and Culture I can attest to the accuracy of Mr Weisenfeld's remarks. Erecting the so-called community center at ground zero marks and memorializes the victory that Radical Islam believes it achieved there. It will represent our weakness and their ascending strength. This is a slap in the face of the families who lost their loved ones and friends there and to our American values in general. It is our obligation to stop it if we are to maintain our Western Ideals and Values