view counter
Yom HaShoah: Finding A Way To Remember
Tue, 04/06/2010 - 20:00

 I worry that with each passing year in this country, Yom HaShoah, Holocaust Remembrance Day, is quietly and gradually becoming obsolete.

You don’t need an actuary to know that the number of survivors of the Holocaust, which took place between 65 and 71 years ago, is declining rapidly, and thus the authentic voices of those who lived through the horrors are diminished every day.

The highlight and centerpiece of the many Yom HaShoah observances I have attended has been the keynote address by a Holocaust survivor, a personal remembrance that makes the unimaginable seem real and that takes the dizzyingly abstract number six million and reduces — yet deepens — it to one vivid, firsthand account.

What will Yom HaShoah be like in a decade or two when there are no more survivors to give witness to the tragedy and all of our knowledge will be secondhand, at best?

Before we reach that time, our community should be giving serious thought to how best to assure that the message of zachor — the command to remember — lives on. The sad fact is that at its present pace, Yom HaShoah in the diaspora may disappear along with the last survivor.

Part of the problem is that there has been no institutionalized ritual, date or time accepted by all communities to mark the occasion. 

In Israel, an official Yom HaShoah commemoration can be traced back to 1951, based on Knesset legislation. Initially designated for the 14th of Nisan, to coincide with the anniversary of the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising, that date was considered inconvenient as it fell on the day before Passover. It was moved to the 27th of Nisan, just after the festival and eight days before Yom Ha’Atzmaut, Israeli Independence Day.

Some elements of the Orthodox community, particularly the haredim, do not observe Yom HaShoah. They believe that Tisha b’Av, the Fast of the 9th day of Av, marking the destruction of the Holy Temple, is the appropriate occasion to commemorate major tragedies in Jewish history, including the Holocaust.

Those elements of the Jewish community who do commemorate Yom HaShoah, which this year is observed on Sunday, April 11, often hold a solemn service that includes the lighting of six candles, to symbolize the murder of six million Jews by the Nazis, and the Kaddish, the traditional prayer recited by mourners. Some read lists of names of those who perished, to give a sense of the enormity of the tragedy. 

The most dramatic ritual is a national moment of silence in Israel, introduced by sirens at 10 a.m. Throughout the country people stop in their tracks, wherever they may be, and remain perfectly still for two minutes.

In Washington, the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum holds a national observance each year during a week of remembrance.

Among the more creative efforts to mark Yom HaShoah in recent years, the Masorti (Conservative) movement in Israel commissioned a Megillat Yom HaShoah, a scroll and liturgical reading, and a few Modern Orthodox rabbis have designed a home seder, complete with a Yom HaShoah Haggadah that calls for eating potato peelings, to recall the scraps that starving men, women and children ate in concentration camps. 

But these innovations have not been adopted on a wide scale.

This year’s annual Park Avenue Synagogue commemoration will take a new tack and be “conducted entirely by young Jews under the age of 40,” according to a synagogue statement, “as part of the process of integrating the culture and memories” of the victims and survivors “into our collective consciousness.”

Meanwhile, one wonders whether Yom HaShoah can best be preserved through a synagogue-centered service or a home-based ritual. There are precedents for both approaches.

Rabbi Ismar Schorsch, the former chancellor of the Jewish Theological Seminary, is one of the few liberal Jewish proponents of incorporating Yom HaShoah observance into Tisha b’Av. He says current Yom HaShoah and Kristallnacht observances (Nov. 9) are “ritually and spiritually impoverished.

“One of the reasons Yom HaShoah has not penetrated the Jewish consciousness is that it has not taken a liturgical form,” he told JTA last year. “It is rarely a religious day in the synagogue — and it is the synagogue, through ritual, that succeeds in perpetuating Jewish values.

But having just experienced anew the remarkable lasting power of the seder — which the large majority of world Jewry observed this past week, thousands of years after the original Passover — one could make a strong case for a family-oriented program to take place in the home to mark Yom HaShoah. After all, home-based rituals like Friday night candle lighting and Chanukah menorah lighting have been observed for centuries, in part because they focus on the family unit rather than requiring the participation of the community at large. 

In truth, history has shown that it can take many decades, and even centuries, to determine if a ritual introduced to the Jewish calendar takes hold. What is clear, though, is that whether the systematic murder of six million European Jews should best be marked in the synagogue, at home or in some other way, we need to make the ritualized observance of this tragedy a higher communal priority before it is too late. 


Read Gary Rosenblatt’s Editor’s Blog, with new entries daily, at . Check out the Jewish Week's Facebook page and become a fan!

And follow the Jewish Week on Twitter: start here.

Our Newsletters, Your Inbox


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


The Nazis didn't just killed Jews. They killed a large piece of Judaism. Will we let them keep killing it? Read on...
In the early 1950’s an attempt was undertaken by the American Jewish Congress to initiate the recital of a Holocaust remembrance prayer at the Seder. It established the Seder Ritual Committee that worked diligently from 1953 to 1968 to publicize the availability of the prayer and to encourage its recital. If you have never heard of the prayer it is because the prayer never entered into any mainstream Haggadah. More importantly, the Committee was not able to gain the endorsement of any major Orthodox Jewish organization. You can read the history of the Committee’s effort in an article I posted at he Beurei Hatefila Institute Website: under the title: Seder Ritual Of Remembrance. My article is based on the records of the Committee that are available for viewing at the American Jewish Historical Society. My personal belief is that Holocaust Remembrance Day should be moved to Tisha B’Av, the fast day set aside to commemorate all tragedies in Jewish history. I say that strictly on a liturgical basis. Tisha B’Av is the only day of the year on which a Jew may ask the question: why? I am disappointed that to this day our religious leaders are ignorant of the fact that a Jew may ask the question: why? on Tisha B’Av. I think that a prayer commemorating the Holocaust should be composed in which each line begins with the word: why and I would go one step further. I would include lines in which we ask G-d why our relatives had to die and I would have those who recite the prayer name each and every one of their relatives who perished. Even G-d would have to shed a tear hearing the names of so many of those innocent victims. Abe Katz Executive Director The Beurei Hatefila Institute
The RAV, Rabbi Dr. Joseph B. Soloveitchik stated that Yom Hashoah should be observed on Tisha B'Av and not on a separate day. It is already becoming confusing. Some people have services on the exact Hebrew date of Yom Hashoah, 27th of Nissan, some the next day, and others several days later. There is no continuity. Now a new date of commemoration has arisen, the liberation of Auschwitz, January 27th. My prediction is that years from now the Holocaust will become a small part of history just like the inquisition, progroms, and expulsions. A Holocaust Siddur will enable Jews in the future to use a text while praying which will offer Kinot, poems, recollections, historical data and commentary by the great Rabbis and Holocaust historians. I believe that the Holocaust will eventually become a non Jewish issue. My fear is that it will not be a discussion involving six million Jews, but rather fifty million human beings. In the future the only day that will be observed with certainty, will be Tisha B'Av. We should have one Siddur which will incorporate the various tragedies the Jewish people have suffered through history. Rabbi Dr. Bernhard Rosenberg RIETYS 74
On Sunday, April 11, (11pm) THIRTEEN will air Teenage Witness: The Fanya Heller Story, narrated by Richard Gere and based on the memoir by Fanya Gottesfeld Heller, Love In A World of Sorrow. It is a raw and emotional look at survival that resonates with the extremes of fear, starvation and a remarkable tenacity of spirit. Dmitry Sh.
Chaverim If you have not contacted me as a 2g Rabbi please do so. We want you to join us. A number of Holocaust survivors children who became Rabbis are interested in organizing a group. Please contact me if you are interested and we will go from there. Rabbi Dr. Bernhard Rosenberg If enough of us are interested I will attempt to organize a meeting. Any suggestions and input would be appreciated. This is very exciting and meaningful. I believe children of survivors have a unique message to give and can be very helpful to each other as a support group.and can truly help congregants who are children of survivors.and give Chizuk to elderly Holocaust survivors. I serve as Holocaust Chairman for the New York Board of Rabbis and served for six years as interfaith chairman of the New Jersey State Holocaust Commission. I hope we will develop a Holocaust siddur so that a special Holocaust service will be held yearly using a standard text. We are looking into scanning the original Holocaust program I edited for the RA. Work on the siddur project is open to all. If we do not develop a standard ritual for the Holocaust I fear the memory of the Holocaust will become nothing more than a time line in history. Time is running out. Yes we have Holocaust programs, a Holocaust Hagaddah and a Holocaust scroll, but a Siddur is needed. It is up to us to keep the memory of the 6 million alive. We are, I fear the last generation that can do so. The Holocaust is my passion. I apologize in advance for my over exuberance. Rabbi Dr. Bernhard Rosenberg
I'm not a Rabbi nor am I observant, however my Jewishness and my life has been shaped by the fact that so many of my family perished for the simple reason that they were born Jewish. I think those souls require and deserve a Siddur. Although my thoughts often settle on those of my family that survived the war and I was priviledged enough to meet and love, I often cannot stop thinking of all those I never knew and who never knew me or my children. At least once a year all those people should here prayers of praise reach out to the heavens to thank them for the sacrifoces they made in order for us to be here. They deserve our rememberance and the Siddur created for Yom Hashoa will bring those martyrs to the forefront every year, on their special day of rememberance.
A Holocaust remembrance should be incorporated into the Haggadah. Just as the Exodus must be remembered from generation to generation, so too does the Holocaust deserve a permanent place at the Peysakh Seder. The Holocaust and our deliverance from it fits perfectly with the theme of freedom from bondage. -Marcel Kshensky
Contact the Harriet & Kenneth Kupferberg Holocaust Research Center and Archives, 222-05 56 Ave, Bayside NY 11365, Dr. Arthur Flug, Director. They have the Haggaqdah which was used immediately after liberation in DP camps in Germany.
We need a Holocaust siddur. Rabbi Dr. Bernhard Rosenberg
Rituals commemorating the Holocaust are being invented. In 1988 the Reform movement published Six Days of Destruction. This book was co-authored by Ele Wiesel and Rabbi Albert Friedlander. The Megillat Hashoah ( The Holocaust Scroll) was created by the Conservative Movement and Rabbi Avi Weiss wrote a special Yom HaShoah seder. Rabbi Dr. Bernhard Rosenberg New York Board of Rabbis Holocaust Chairman