view counter
U-Turn At J Street
Mon, 09/27/2010 - 20:00

Few Jewish organizations have generated feelings — pro or con — as intense as those ignited by J Street, the pro-peace process lobby and political action committee created two years ago to provide a left-of-center address for politicians and activists who support more aggressive U.S. peace process diplomacy.

That intensity took another quantum jump with last week’s Washington Times disclosure that the group has been getting substantial donations from financier George Soros despite repeated denials from its leaders.

The fact that the lobby lied about receiving support from Soros speaks in part to the critical perception of him in the mainstream Jewish community. A Hungarian-born Jew who escaped the Holocaust as a child, the billionaire has contributed large sums for democratic rights in Central and Eastern Europe. But he has given little if any money to Israel or Jewish causes and has stirred controversy with critical remarks, like blaming Jews for anti-Semitism. Just last week he pledged $100 million to Human Rights Watch, whose bias against Israel is pronounced and longstanding.

But in a sense, Soros is almost beside the point. J Street committed a cardinal sin in Washington by misleading politicians who trusted its integrity. Its leaders acted without regard for the members of Congress they were ostensibly supporting, and sowed a climate of mistrust that can only lend credibility to other claims of its critics, both legitimate and outrageous.

While we strongly disagree with J Street’s continuing emphasis on demands for Israeli concessions while largely ignoring a long list of unmet Palestinian obligations, we also disagree with those in our community who claim it is anti-Israel. Clearly, it recognizes the legitimate rights of Jews to have their own state, and reflects the views of a significant proportion of our community who see negotiations for a two-state solution as an urgent necessity. At times J Street’s opposition to boycotts of Israel and divestment from Israeli companies has held sway among those on the left.

That said, J Street has an obligation to its members and to its primary constituents — the members of Congress and other political figures who agree with its positions — to be truthful and smart when it comes to its brand of activism. The current controversy suggests it has been neither.

The fact that J Street’s donor list was released through an apparent Internal Revenue Service error points to another dimension of the controversy. J Street isn’t alone in trying to keep its donor lists secret. Our community and our nation would be better served by more transparency on the issue of who is paying for the advocacy groups that play such a huge role in the emotional, high-stakes debate over U.S. Middle East policy.

George Soros, J Street, pro-Israel activism

Our Newsletters, Your Inbox


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


George Soros is a Hungarian Jew and a very smart man whose commitment to an open society helped to bring about change in the former Soviet Union. He funds organizations working on behalf of democracy all over the world. I personally have no problem with J-Street receiving funding from his organization, and don't think it's that much of a big deal. The big deal is that J-street felt they couldn't be linked with this philanthropist. Why not? I would be proud to be associated with him.
Without trust we are lost. Honesty leads to trust.
HEY JEWISH WEEK ! Other Pro Israel organizations have survived much bigger scandals in the past, some recent as you well know. The rest of the organized Jewish organization rose to back them as always. Unfortunately J Street is not in line right with these peoples right wing ideology. Instead of receiving backing the organized pro Israel community pushes these negative stories as argument for their demise. The media falls right into the trap. The double standard by these critics and some in the media is sad and unacceptable. This Soros story is simply a pretext for J Streets destruction and a means to their goal which is derailing J Streets role as an advocate for peace talks. These same men attacking J Street call for peace while at the same time hiding their far right views. These people attack J Street simply because it's an organization attempting to achieve the negotiated settlement they secretly dread.
J Street and many of its followers and leftist associates are the reborn Jewish Bund Labor group. Many of the leaders were anti the establishment of Israel. Also, for anti-nationalist reasons they supported the continued use of Yiddish vice Hebrew language. Also, many of them wanted the Jews to associate with the Workers Socialist Labor Movement (Trotsky) and other leftist anti-American and anti capitalist causes. Soros and many of his anti Semetic Jews are part of this group and I saw it in the ideas and language of the J-Streeters. I recall getting into fist fights in Philly with these "Commies" who were tring to sell out Israel. With the establisment of Israel, I thought they died off. I guess not. How do we get rid of these J-Street vampires and their backer Soros.
Support The Torah Deed for The Jewish People's rightful Inheritane. You will se The Torah Deed Banner flying in the Settlements next year.