view counter
The Sad Downfall Of Anthony Weiner
Mon, 06/20/2011 - 20:00

It’s always unsettling to see a promising political career come crashing down because of a personal failing, a spectacle that has become all too familiar in recent years. We have covered Anthony Weiner’s public service from the time he rose from Chuck Schumer’s aide to city councilman to Congressional representative and strong defender of Israel, to his two surreal press conferences this month. A boon to tabloid sales, Twitter and to late night talk-show ratings, Weiner’s downfall is nevertheless a sad tale that fueled a month-long party of sophomoric public guffawing.

We worry about a culture in which non-criminal private failings usurp significant public accomplishments and in which the will of the people – 56 percent of Weiner’s constituents polled wanted him to stay– is trumped by editorial writers and party leaders with ulterior agendas.

Make no mistake. We don’t mean to minimize in any way the congressman’s behavior, which lowered both his dignity and that of his office. In addition to his ultra-macho behavior online, instructing his staff to lie on his behalf, while lying personally to the media in an air of false indignation, was an egregious betrayal of the public trust.

But if conduct unbecoming an elected official was an impeachable offense, we’d see a regular cycle of special elections around the country and fewer names at roll call. There was a fair amount of hypocrisy in the assertions by the Democrat leadership that Weiner should step down because he was a distraction, an assessment not made when Rep. Charles Rangel, the deposed head of the Ways and Means Committee, was convicted of numerous ethical violations, including non-payment of taxes. In the assessment of many political observers, the demise of Weiner’s congressional career was seen as both suicide and homicide, done in not only by his own immature conduct but by peers who ran for cover. No doubt his aggressive and often self-aggrandizing behavior didn’t help, adding to Weiner’s alienation from his colleagues.

Looking ahead, the Democrats mentioned as possible successors in the short term are accomplished public officials or former officials with a track record of support for Israel and Jewish causes, while the Republican in the mix is something of a blank slate.

As to whether the district is ripe for elimination at a time when the state must shed two House seats, we hope the Legislature and governor won’t make expedient decisions that could adversely impact Jewish voters and others for the next decade. We know Jewish community watchdogs will be looking at proposed map changes to argue that a unified, powerful presence shouldn’t be split into bits and pieces in multiple adjoining districts.

Finally, we hope Anthony Weiner can make good on his pledge to heal himself and his family, and successfully deal with his self-destructive behavior. Perhaps he can return to public service in the future. While our society can be cruel in the midst of a scandal, it is not unforgiving. Just ask Bill Clinton, one of the most popular figures in America today.

Teshuva, or repentance, is key to Jewish religious tradition. As the sages wrote, “those who want to be forgiven must learn to forgive.”

Anthony Weiner

Our Newsletters, Your Inbox


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


what a narrow minded way of thinking- shame on you- this sad excuse for an adult lied to his voters and did it in an aggressively pugnacious way he didn't have the integrity to step down and just because he is a liberal and supports Israel you decide to bemoan his leaving the stage -we deserve better from our representatives than a Weiner

Oh please, spare me! There are a lot of sad things in this world, but the downfall of some politician is hardly one of them regardless of how Jewish, how pro-Israel and how liberal (somehow I doubt you'd shed many tears if Weiner were an evil Republican)he may be.

It's good that you clarified that you don't mean to minimize the congressman's behavior. Silly me, I thought that's exactly what you then proceeded to do (they all do it, others are worse, he shouldn't have been pressured to resign, it's a cruel society blah blah blah).

It's very sweet that you hope he heals himself and his family and returns to public service, but I, for one, couldn't care less.

Finally, the lecture at the end of the editorial about Teshuva and learning to forgive was a charming touch

I totally suport your editorial. In truth, Anthony Weiner’s downfall is, as you state, "a sad tale," and one that was played out by late night TV hosts, real "role models," for all that it was worth.

My wife and I talked at length about what Weiner did, both in terms of criminality and inappropriateness. And inappropriateness, we believe, won the day. Having Congress even consider investigating him for texting on a government-issued phone, and the like, would have been ludicrous if that was needed to determine any illegality. In addition to the obvious fact that every single politician, bar none, uses government resources, to some extent to campaign for either him/herself or for a fellow politician during their work hours, using governmental resources. If we take this to the nth degree, a politician answering his/her phone to say, "I'll see you at the rally tonight," could be brought on charges. So, let's get real.

Weiner's shortcoming was two part: One, he should not, especially as a married man, have been doing what he was doing. Two, even if he couldn't control himself, he should have been aware of the powerful effect of hitting the wrong Send button on his phone.

I agree that this shortcoming should not negate his many accomplishments, especially for our community. And, as you suggest, we hope that Mr. Weiner does what is necessary to regain the public trust and deal with the personal issues which led to this situation. He then could return to public service.

As a former constituent of his (no, I didn't move from his district- redistricting moved him from my district), I wish him the best.