Walking along the route of the Israel Day Parade on Sunday, from 72nd Street down to 59th Street along Fifth Avenue, we were reminded once again, and in dramatic fashion, how the expression of Zionism in American has become increasingly the purview of the Modern Orthodox community.
The crowd appeared to be made up primarily of relatives and friends of the marchers — many of the large contingents were day school children — and other observant Jews. This is consistent with the turnout at protest rallies at or near the United Nations over the last few years when Iranian President Ahmadinejad comes to town, only bigger in size, and with marching bands.
The good news is that the Modern Orthodox continue to inspire enthusiasm and solid support for Israel from within their community, including taking pride in the Israel Defense Forces and remembering kidnapped soldier Gilad Shalit, now almost four years in enemy hands.
The disturbing news is that much of the rest of the Jewish community — including the haredim and chasidim within Orthodoxy — for a multitude of reasons, lacks the conviction and/or energy to stand up and literally show the flag for Israel.
One friend who belongs to a large Conservative synagogue in northern New Jersey lamented the fact that the congregation could not even put together one busload of participants for the parade.
Some folks may be disillusioned with Israel. Others, convinced that parade organizers primarily represent the community’s right wing, feel disenfranchised. More, we suspect, remain supportive, but not enough to walk the walk.
Much has been written about former New Republic editor Peter Beinart’s stinging critique of the American Jewish establishment, published in the current New York Review of Books. There is plenty to debate about it, but one observation seems indisputable: that the Orthodox community is growing in numbers and becoming increasingly parochial and conservative politically. And as liberal Jews “drift away from American Zionist institutions,” Beinart writes, “their Orthodox counterparts will likely step into the breach.”
It’s happening already, and if visual proof was needed, Sunday’s parade was a vivid example.
Signup for our weekly email newsletter here.
The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.