view counter
Flotilla’s ‘Audacity Of Hope’
Tue, 06/28/2011

As Gilad Shalit begins his sixth year in captivity, media attention already has shifted from his plight to the next flotilla heading for Gaza, and a new chapter in provocation against Israel.

The fact that the kidnapped Israeli soldier has been held without Red Cross contact or even an indication that he is alive is an outrage in defiance of international law and human decency. But we have come to expect no more from Hamas, the terror group that decides Shalit’s fate and continues to abide by a charter calling for the death of all Jews, even as it seeks recognition as a legitimate partner in charting the course of Palestinian statehood.

Where is the international indignation against Hamas for holding Shalit captive while it insists that Israel release more than 1,000 jailed terrorists, including those with blood on their hands, so that they may return to their murderous task?

The spineless UN remains silent as the focus turns to the next assault on Israel’s legitimacy, in the form of an international flotilla due to set out soon to break the maritime blockade of Gaza. One of the 10 ships is aptly named “Audacity Of Hope.” The intended reference may be to the Barack Obama bestseller, but it best describes the full-throttled chutzpah of those who claim to seek peace and call attention to the plight of Gazans by bringing humanitarian aid, when in fact their purpose is to provoke Israel, and perhaps attack its soldiers. (Reports from Israel this week said there was a plan discussed by flotilla activists to pour sulfur on Israelis who board the ships and then set them ablaze.)

Why are there no humanitarian aid flotillas launched toward Syria or Libya, where innocent citizens, bravely calling for democracy, are being murdered by their own leaders?

The Jerusalem government is faced with preventing arms from being smuggled by sea into Gaza while seeking to avoid an international incident that results in violence. A year ago, a Turkish-based flotilla surprise attack on Israeli Navy commandos resulted in the death of nine involved in the assault. We hope the IDF is better prepared this time.

Prime Minister Netanyahu has made clear that while Israel will do all it can to avoid bloodshed, it will do what it must to enforce the law and protect its soldiers. The U.S. has backed Israel up, calling the flotilla effort “irresponsible.”

Some would-be participants in the flotilla, persuaded by Israeli officials that humanitarian aid can be, and is, delivered in other ways, have dropped out of the planned trip. All the more reason to question the motives of those who remain involved.

As we mark Independence Day in America this weekend, we urge our readers to pause and reflect on the blessings of freedom too often taken for granted, recalling Gilad Shalit, alone in his private hell, and those setting sail for the Mediterranean Sea, intent on confronting the region’s only democracy.

May Shalit soon taste freedom, and may the flotilla activists be thwarted.

Get The Jewish Week Newsletter

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


The Israeli soldiers boarding the Turkish ship were unarmed when attacked. It was the other Israeli soldiers trying to rescue them who were armed. If the first soldiers had not been attacked, no deaths would have resulted.

One lone Jewish nation among a sea of Christian and Islamic ones, and a nation that insures freedom of religion to all inhabitants, and that's the one you object to?

And when you focus on the Israeli/Palestinian conflict, is that because you want to ignore the 300 million Arabs, the 74 million Persians, the now the 75 million Turks who have ganged up on 5 million Jewish Israelis? Arab hostility preceded the problem with the Palestinians and will continue after the peace agreement.

If the West wasn't so antisemitic and sympathetic to Arab hate, there would be no Mideast conflict between Arabs and Jews. America gives Israel money, that's all. Do you think the Arabs with their oil resources don't have more money than Israel?

Are you serious? A flotilla suprise attack last year resulted in 9 deaths? The whole world was aware of the flotilla's attempt to run the Gaza Strip blockade with humanitarian aid. Absolutely was there any secrecy in the fact of the flotillas purpose. IDF special forces commandos propelled down into the ships fully armed with the best of weapons while the flotilla's passangers tried to fend them off with metal pipes. 9 passanges died while 0 IDF commandos parrished. The Israeli governemnt is known for using excessive force. I love Jews, but not Zionism. I just don't think any country should have a religous adopted state ideology, weather it be Jewish, Islamic, or Christian state.

"Why are there no humanitarian aid flotillas launched toward Syria or Libya, where innocent citizens, bravely calling for democracy, are being murdered by their own leaders?"

Because it's their land and their internal Govt...Israel is intruding and uprooting Palestinian families under the guise of it being a "buffer zone" to protect itself...archeological digging to gain more land as well...between the Jewish controlled media and campaign funding in America, the rhetoric Americans see isn't just and proper. It's a one sided agenda, hence these flotillas are made to seem anti-Semitic...when in reality they have every right to give aid to suffering Palestinians. Both sides twist reality for their own purpose, but one side has a WORLD SUPER POWER on it's side. Take the United States out of the equation so we can stop losing our young to your wars...Settle it amongst yourselves, because every non Jew here is sick of funding it.

As an American I am saddened and outraged at the involvement of US citizens in the flotilla. Israel must defend their people and their nation against those who wish to do them harm. Truth will prevail. G-d will not break His covenant with Abraham. Israel will survive with the help of Almighty G-d. Blessings and Shalom

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.