view counter
The Most Important Funding for Jewish Schools That You've Never Heard Of
Wed, 03/13/2013 - 20:00
Special To The Jewish Week
Jeff Leb is the Director of Political Affairs for the Orthodox Union’s Teach NYS' Initiative.
Jeff Leb is the Director of Political Affairs for the Orthodox Union’s Teach NYS' Initiative.

The challenge of day school affordability is not just an economic but an existential one; it is about the continuity and vitality of the next generation of Jews. While enrollment is at an all-time high, so are tuition bills. 

That is why securing greater government support for our schools is an absolute priority focus for communal organizations. This is done by both advocating for greater support for our schools in Albany and by establishing relationships with our elected officials who represent the areas where we live and work.

Groups like the Orthodox Union's Teach NYS Initiative, UJA-Federation of New York, Agudath Israel of America, the Jewish Education Project and Torah Umesorah have proven to be great advocates for schools in need. For years, we have proposed or supported bold proposals that would deliver new aid to day schools and their families. But in today’s tough economic times, new initiatives are merely academic discussions. 

Thus, we have turned our advocacy efforts to the resources and funding streams that currently exist in New York State and, in particular, to expanding support from a government program you probably have never heard of. There are approximately 400,000 students attending private schools in New York State and private school students account for 13 percent of all students throughout New York. However, the private school community receives only 1 percent of the funding that goes toward education. This seems patently unfair, and it is.

Since 1974, New York law has imposed several requirements on our schools, including: reporting student enrollment and faculty employment numbers each year; administering tests to students in elementary school and high school; reporting which students graduate each year;  and verifying that all students are vaccinated, among other responsibilities.

These Mandated Services Reimbursements (MSR) were accompanied by a promise to reimburse private schools for the cost of compliance, estimated at $90.4 million for this school year. For 33 years this promise was kept. Then, faced with a budget shortfall in 2007, the State abandoned the idea of full reimbursement and cut MSR by a hefty amount. Although we have collectively managed to get MSR restored to its full funding level, the State still owes the private school community over $30 million for the years that our schools were underpaid.

Another type of service that is mandated by the State is the Comprehensive Attendance Policy (CAP), which requires private schools to report student attendance for every grade by every class period. CAP requirements first took effect in the 2003-04 school year and cost private schools $38 million that year alone. Unfortunately though, New York State wasn’t nearly as accommodating in its payments of CAP as it was with MSR.

From the start, the state ignored its obligations to reimburse private schools for CAP. For the 2003-2005 school years, the Education Department did not allocate any CAP funding, claiming that the schools failed to submit student attendance data. In fact, the Education Department could have gathered attendance data from the private schools’ Mandate Services Reimbursement forms. Since then, the state has continuously under-funded CAP. Currently, the private school community should be receiving $58 million in CAP funding, but received $33 million last year.

In addition, the continued underpayment for CAP has resulted in a deficit of over $210 million. That's a lot of money that would go a long way if it were allocated to the private schools. MSR and CAP are real funding streams that go directly to each school that complies with the reporting, which includes most private schools. They go directly to the school’s bottom line and relieve a large part of the financial burden that every school faces.

Albany's budget negotiations are reaching their conclusion in these final weeks of March. It is crucial that all those who care about the viability and affordability of our schools to contact their legislators and urge that MSR and CAP funding must be fully restored and that a payment plan must be enacted so that the schools can receive the full funding that they deserve.


Agudath Israel of America, Board of Jewish Education, Orthodox Union's Teach NYS Initiative, Torah Umesorah, UJA-Federation of New York

Our Newsletters, Your Inbox


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


In case you missed it, here is a link to more massive education funding fraud in the New York area ultra Orthodox community:

This expose follows that e-rate scandal exposed by this newspaper a few weeks ago. It appears that the frum community thinks that it is OK to steal from the goyim. Maybe it is time for Rabbi Hier and Abraham Foxman to stop looking for 90 year old Nazis under every bed and to start speaking out on corruption in the ultra Orthodox Jewish community.

Mr. Leb,

Did you read Chaim Levin's blog on the education he never received when it was appeared on the Internet last year? If you didn't, you should. He left his Yeshiva at the age of 17 with the equivalent of a grade 3 secular education. What becomes of people like Chaim? In many cases, they end up on welfare after marrying young and having lots of children that they can't afford to raise on their own. The bill for their food stamps, Section 8 housing vouchers and part of their cash assistance (TANF) and Medicaid is picked up by the Federal government but New York State and/or local counties pick up the rest of these costs. The more functionally illiterate Jewish "graduates" turned out by ultra Orthodox day schools, the more financial pressure there will be on other state (and locally) supported programs. Instead of asking for more money that isn't there, maybe you should be lobbying for higher educational standards at schools like the one Chaim attended. At least you won't have to worry about Chaim becoming much of a burden on the taxpayer anytime soon, as he is gay and is not likely to father lots of children that he can't afford to look after.

Whatever happened to "No Child Left Behind" and why isn't it helping Jewish boys from ultra Orthodox families?

"... private school students account for 13 percent of all students throughout New York. However, the private school community receives only 1 percent of the funding that goes toward education. This seems patently unfair, and it is." No, it is perfectly fair, if you elect to send your child(ren) to a non-public school, then you must face the consequences as well. New York, as well as every other municipality, has trouble enough funding public schools; to expect them to give even more of those precious education dollars to private schools is unfair and unrealistic.