view counter
Hey, Jewish Orgs: #ResistFads

The Jewish community needs to consider the possibility that social media is a bad investment.

Mon, 05/05/2014 - 20:00
Special To The Jewish Week
Russel Neiss
Russel Neiss

Last week, in the run-up to Yom HaShoah the Israel Defense Forces' Interactive Media Branch called on their followers to "contribute to Holocaust remembrance" by posting "a photo of yourself together with a Holocaust survivor on Facebook, Twitter, or Instagram with the hashtag #WeAreHere."

They tweeted this example.

Within hours, the hashtag had predictably been taken over by Palestinian activists who hijacked the feed and recast "#WeAreHere" as a slogan lamenting Israel's military presence in the West Bank & Gaza Strip.

To be fair, the IDF is by no means the first organization to have their twitter campaign taken over. It’s happened to McDonalds, Walgreens and other corporations.

But just two days earlier, the NYPD made the news for their #MyNYPD campaign which was also hijacked by activists who instead of tweeting cheerful pictures of citizens engaging with police officers, posted pictures of cops engaging in police brutality. Sure, hindsight is clearly 20-20, but how did the IDF not see this coming?

It turns out that organizations are woefully bad at using social media. A recent Harvard Business Review report tells us that two-thirds of users have no formalized social media strategy, and just 7 percent have integrated social media into their overall marketing strategy. Less than a third measure the effectiveness of their investment in social media.

This is an even bigger problem in the Jewish communal world. Far too often, we get enamored by a shiny new tool or idea and put on blinders that keep us from recognizing the potential pitfalls. We're afraid that if we aren't "innovative" enough we won't be able to remain "relevant" or attract and maintain the interest of the people who matter.

So instead of focusing on our core goals and objectives we get bogged down worrying about fads, even if they don't do much to advance the mission of our organization or the Jewish people. With social media in particular, we've become so focused on the metrics of followers, retweets, Facebook fans, likes and the like that we fail to even address what value if any these tools add to our mission.

We don't think or care that the average Facebook post from an organization doesn't even reach 7 percent of our Facebook Fans. We don't care about really engaging with people on Twitter, only our follow to following ratio. We don't even ask the question is social media effective at all in terms of building a volunteer base or soliciting donations, two actual measures of real engagement with a not-for-profit. (It's not.)

What is the allure of these tools that we continue to spend our energy and resources in investing in them? Why, despite significant evidence to the contrary, do we believe these will be useful in advancing our core mission? Why did the IDF invest resources that could have been spent keeping Israel safe and secure on a cockamamie social media campaign?

Why does the Jewish community like to flit around from one new initiative to another?

I think it may have to do with the fact that it's often easier to just go along with the masses than to make a reasoned argument justifying why you're going against the grain.

This isn't a new problem. In 1924, Maurice Hexter, in his role as President of the National Conference of Jewish Social Service (a forerunner to today's Jewish Federation system) lamented the lack of rigor in examining the efficacy of Jewish organizations at the time.

"To the careful observer of social facts it must be apparent at once that much of what passes as knowledge is mere dogma ... There is a glowing future before us when we have once learned that we know very little and that with this humility of spirit we begin our labors."

I couldn't agree more. I believe strongly in the value and work of Jewish communal organizations and the mission of the Jewish people to be a light unto the nations, but sometimes I wish we were more skeptical of the latest buzzwords and fads.

We need to be willing admit what we don't know, and we need to be willing to scrutinize our efforts and challenge the status quo and consider alternative approaches and solutions. If we don't, we'll have about as much control over our future as the IDF over their twitter hashtags.

Russel Neiss is a Jewish educator, technologist and activist, and the coding monkey behind PocketTorah, The AlephBet App and a myriad of other Jewish ed tech initiatives.

#MyNYPD, #WeAreHere, Facebook, IDF, NYPD, Social Media, Twitter, Yom HaShoah

Our Newsletters, Your Inbox


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


It is foolhardy to let organizations that use social media without a coherent strategy determine the decision basis for using social media. Just because many use it poorly doesn't mean it is a waste of time. They are wasting their time, but those who use it well are not. This article is clearly an example of throwing the baby out with the bath water. Shameful.

It wasn't so long ago that web sites were a "fad", too!

And any organization that attempts to reach teens had better have a Facebook page!

What do you expect? The non-Orthodox Jewish world continues to believe there is always some new magic-bullet, like social media, around every corner that will magically reinvigorate their movements by being "inclusive and engaging". You won't get many young people to live a Jewish life that is meaningfully distinct from non-Jewish life (e.g. Shabbat, Kashrut, endogamy, etc.) unless their parents set the example like the Orthodox do. Otherwise, most of the kiruv effort and resources are utterly wasted.

It has always taken time for people to master new technology, especially those whose primary function involve social interactions. After a hundred years and billions of dollars, we still can't predict in advance whether a tv show or movie will be a success, whether an ad will draw new customers or whether a campaign speech will motivate people to vote. We pre-test them, focus group them, analyze them for their impact on desire demographic groups and the dread of negative unintended consequences always seems to lurk in the background.

Perhaps that is as it should be - social media gurus notwithstanding. Human beings are incredibly complex and our ability to respond to new situations in often unpredictable ways is one of our great strengths. In retrospect, someone probably could have anticipated the highjacking of the IDF's warmhearted and feel good idea. But then again, perhaps not. Books have been around for 500 years and more than a few have had consequences fully unintended by their authors.

Considering the fact that Russel Neiss is involved in many innovations in the Jewish world, including creating an amazing tool for learning to leyn Torah, I'd have to say that the previous commenter is missing the point.

These days organizations strive to innovate because innovation is the newest cool thing-- innovation liShmah. Russel's point is that if orgs weren't in a rush to be seen as hip, cool and "with it," they might be able to develop outreach that reaches people in an authentic way, not through schlock and gimmick.

At least I think that's his point!

I am afraid I do not agree with Mr. Neiss. It is much easier to sit and point at those that try to innovate than to find solutions. Even easier than that is to pick on some fabulous misfortune (like the IDF example) and to generalize it. I do not see any useful advice in here except for "just go back to your roots" (pah-lease).

I am not saying that we should jump on every innovative idea (I wish we did behave like Mr. Neiss is describing). The Jewish community suffers from a much greater illness in the form of not taking risks... far greater than jumping on "fads". I wish Jewish organizations would start using more metrics for their success to engage the community.