Continuity: Why Dual Faith Families Matter
Tue, 03/18/2014

While the debate rages around intermarriage and Jewish continuity, it’s important to remember that: dual faith families make up some 25 percent of all the intermarried, according to Pew; they are interested in religion; without attention, they are likely to drift entirely away from any religion; and with attention, they offer real promise to sustain connections to Judaism and open avenues to greater engagement.

The choice to raise one’s children “Jewish and something else” should not be feared or dismissed. I speak from experience as the Jewish partner in a longstanding Jewish/Christian marriage.  My commitment to Jewish continuity led me to found an organization that provides dual faith families with authentic education about both traditions.

The thousands of families we have reached not only have much potential for deep Jewish engagement, but they will keep the roots of Judaism nourished. And these are families from whom the Jewish community has much to learn about what keeps many contemporary families connected to Judaism.

The families are not some odd syncretistic, Messianic, or indifferent assemblage. They are an ordinary mix of people – your friends, your relatives, perhaps your children -- whose inclinations and choices are frankly being ignored or dismissed by the Jewish community.   

Like most 21st century couples, they are working to incorporate social, cultural, geographic – and religious  – differences into the new families they are forming. They appreciate differences and learn from them; they are motivated by an ethos of fairness and the injunction to “to do unto others….”

And, unlike many couples today, they care about religion.

From those I have worked with over the years in workshops, most want to sustain the religious identity of the Jewish spouse and to ensure a proud and grounded Jewish identity for their children, just not necessarily an exclusive Jewish identity – at least not initially.  These are not the “nones” who declare no interest in religion; these are families whose very seriousness about religion makes them prospects for Jewish continuity.

These couples value religion but recoil at making a choice about religion “under the gun” of an impending wedding ceremony; they want their choice to be based on education, understanding and a maturing marital relationship.  They resist pressures for premature decisions that would marginalize the Christian spouse. 

Processing differences and arriving at a shared balance takes time – and varies by couple. Whatever their journey, they want to learn more about their two religions and to have their children develop a knowledge of both traditions – if only so they can respect the rituals and ceremonies of both sides of the extended family.

Without institutional support for their choices, some are satisfied with a superficial menu of holiday celebrations. Others attempt to educate on their own at home. Still others attempt complicated combinations of church and synagogue attendance and even separate religious education in both.

All find that it is difficult – and isolating – to provide positive exposure to both traditions. As a result many look to be with other interfaith couples in settings that feel safe and neutral.  They are happy to find one of the handful of formal “interfaith communities” that provide support and education -- Interfaith Community’s six chapters in the greater New York area and Boston, IFFP/Interfaith Family Project in the Washington, DC area, and, in the Chicago area, the Family School/ Jewish-Catholic Couples Dialogue Group, and the Interfaith Union.

Emerging over three decades from the genuine grassroots needs of such families, these interfaith communities are intentional in providing authentic education about both Judaism and Christianity. In particular, the Interfaith Community’s curriculum was meticulously conceived and developed by educators trained at The Jewish Theological Seminary and Union Theological Seminary.

For many couples that join interfaith communities, maintaining a balance between both religions becomes a satisfying arrangement in their marriage. For others, the opportunity to engage comfortably with both allows them to choose a primary religious affiliation.  And that choice is almost always in favor of Judaism. 

Often, it is the 11-year-old child who asks to have a bar or bat mitzvah. Interfaith communities help facilitate such journeys and connections to Jewish professionals. We see adult children in their 20s or 30s – even without the motivation of a marriage partner – build on the dual faith foundation and become seriously engaged in Judaism. And, regardless of their family’s journey, Jewish partners consistently tell us that being in an interfaith marriage – while enhancing their understanding and respect for Christianity -- has increased their appreciation and involvement with their own Jewish heritage.

Moreover, religious educators say that teaching our interfaith curriculum deepens their own theological clarity.

If Judaism is to continue to thrive tomorrow, recognizing dual faith families must be one strategic element today.  Advocating for these families, we strive to:  expand our reach so that more families have authentic religion in their lives; extend our programs to reach high school and college level; expand our work with seminaries to educate religious professionals about dual faith families and prepare educators to serve them; and establish vibrant partnerships with Jewish institutions to welcome our thoughtfully dual-faith families.

To continue this strategy, dual faith families need acknowledgment and support from existing institutions. In turn, the perspectives of these families offer crucial insights into issues of continuity. Investing in them is an investment in the future.

Sheila Gordon is founding president of Interfaith Communities, Inc.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.

Comments

We speak of the"tragedy" of our children "marrying out," but the real tragedy is that so many of our Jewish institutions won't accept the people our children love. Too many rabbis still refuse to marry an interfaith couple, even when that bride or groom has grown up in that rabbi's congregation! By rejecting the young people who we need to nurture as the next generation of committed Jews we are instead throwing that couple into the welcoming arms of some other tradition.

I must dissent from the position by
Sheila Gordon and the letters that
preceded mine. Real commitment
to a religious faith requires a
commitment to one faith. Religion
is not a menu from a Chinese
restaurant when you can chose one
from column A and one from column B.
For an interfaith couple to be include
within the Jewish Community, there
ought to be an undivided commitment
to Jewish identity. If you can not make
that commitment, you should find a
religious community outside the Jewish
Community. To do otherwise will water down
Jewish identity over several generation to
the extent that it is meaningless. In addition,
failure to decide on one identity is confusing
to the children.
As a final thought, the participation of
Jewish educators from JTS boggles my mind.
Inclusion of dual faith couples will water down
Jewish identity. How then do you say it is
important to Jewish continuity.

Alan Levin

Well said. As Sheila Gordon lays out in her piece, we must welcome interfaith couples and their children as members of the community looking for a home in Judaism. It's hard work, but work that must be done none the less.

Well said! We have raised our two children in a mixed faith household and they both have a deep appreciation for and connection to Judaism. I applaud the work that Interfaith Community is doing.

Thank you Sheila Gordon for a thoughtful approach toward understanding the hearts and challenges encountered by Jewish-Gentile couples. IMHO it is so important to treat both partners with respect and to create a safe community in which they can discuss their core values and beliefs. In my experience, they need to be heard and aided in their cross-cultural expression of those values and beliefs. Clear communication seems to creat understanding.

Yes! A well-articulated piece explaining why "doing both" is decidedly NOT the same as "doing nothing." Many interfaith families are in fact very dedicated to Jewish continuity…they are just teaching their children about Judaism within the context of their dual faith family. Religious institutions adopting a welcoming instead of an alienating posture towards dual faith families IS the key to Jewish continuity among this population.

It is great to see this type of approach getting recognition from the Jewish Week. Any strategy that increases a family's comfort with Judaism is great for the Jewish community. We, as a community, need to recognize that dismissing interfaith families means severing any connection between future generations and the Jewish people. Anyone who is truly concerned about Jewish continuity needs to make room for this sort of education.

I agree with Dr. Gordon, dual faith families allow a unique perspective on how religious identity is created and maintained in our modern, inter-religious, world. It is important for all of us to learn from those families and to include them in our interfaith dialogue.

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.