One-Week Workshops
view counter
Demilitarize Gaza, End Occupation
Tue, 07/15/2014 - 20:00

I want first to establish my credentials as a strong supporter of the Israel founded by the early Zionists. I grew up in a Zionist home, and as a teenager I led the junior congregation of the Conservative synagogue to which my grandparents and parents belonged. In the 1940s, while in college, I was the head of the Wisconsin chapter of IZFA, the Intercollegiate Zionist Federation of America. Although secular, I am and have always been a synagogue member.

I found Gary Rosenblatt’s column, “’Revenge’ Is Not Our Way” (July 11), to be shortsighted in its analysis of the Palestinian Arabs’ situation. They are not acting solely in response to the murder of Muhammad Abu Khdeir. Their hostility to Israel is also directed, understandably, to the harsh, unjust occupation of the West Bank, and its extreme repression of the Palestinian population of the area.

Of course, that does not justify, by any means, the bombing of Israeli territory or its population. Israel has every right to try to stop the rockets from Gaza — and from Lebanon. But if Israelis are to be able to permanently live in peace, other steps must be taken. First, Gaza must be demilitarized — as Israel proposed with respect to the West Bank under a two-state solution. A peaceful Gaza, under international guarantees and oversight, would solve the threat of Hamas rockets. Along with that an independent and demilitarized West Bank will enable Israel to terminate its horrendous occupation and to become the peaceful, idealistic nation its founders envisaged.

Without these steps Israel will continue to be a militaristic nation and, ultimately, will be an apartheid state. It is incumbent on every lover of Israel to work to avoid such an outcome.

Our Newsletters, Your Inbox


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


Agree with M. Davison.

You never mention the fact that the Arabs of the West Bank are Jordanian citizens and since Jordan is 80 % Palestinian they have a homeland. Read some history. It is the Arabs of the westbank who occupy Jewish land.

One question--what happens after your plan is implemented, when the Arabs decide that all of Palestine is occupied? Should Israel be compelled to cease its occupation of Haifa and Tel Aviv?

Unlike you, I have not been a life-long Zionist, I have just lived my entire adult life in Israel. After 45 years, I think I understand the Arab mentality just a wee bit better than you.

Until you can understand that "Arab pride" and "Arab honor" will not allow the Palestinian Authority to accept any agreement that they cannot show their own public as an achievement of victory over Israel that restores that "honor" and "pride", you do not understand the confict at all.

"The occupation" and "the settlements" are just excuses--excuses made for gullible Westerners who mistakenly believe at the average Palestinian in the street is no different from the Western person in the street. Nothing could be further from the truth.

Unless Western diplomats and liberals stop excusing every violation of the Geneva Conventions and the Hague Conventuions that the Palestinians commit while condemning Israel for every real and imagined violation, there can never be peace in the Middle East, and the West is the enabler.