Bukharians Are Different
Tue, 07/24/2012

 Steve Lipman’s article, “New Generation of Russians Now Making Its Mark” (July 13), may be an accurate portrayal of a major proportion of the 200,000 Russian-speaking Jews in the Greater New York area, but Russian-speaking Jews are not monolithic. 

We must differentiate between those born in Moscow, St. Petersburg, Odessa and the European-influenced parts of the former Soviet Union (FSU) from those who emanate from the Muslim-influenced Central Asian countries of the FSU — Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, Kazakhstan — known as Bukharian Jews. 

The former group came here nearly four decades ago, while Bukharian Jews immigrated in great numbers (40,000) during the mid-late 1990s, settling mostly in Central Queens, where many continue to live. The European-Russian Jews were primarily secular, while Bukharians are from very traditional, observant backgrounds, and were generally accustomed to living with other Jews. The Bukharians came to New York to settle together as one people — and to remain as one tightly knit group.

Jewish Child Care Association has worked very closely with this community since its mass immigration to Queens. We have found Bukharian youth and young adults to be deeply respectful of and more connected to their parents’ values.

Having been here far less time, second generation Bukharians — now high school teens — have not become as Americanized as their counterparts, and struggle with their identity. Young Bukharian professionals who participate in our Kalontar (Leadership) Program are learning about and embracing the concepts of volunteerism and philanthropy, values highly regarded by the American Jewish community. 

Our hope is that by engaging in grass-roots community building, Russian speaking Bukharian Jews will feel more connected to the broader Jewish community, and will be strengthened as they face the ongoing challenges of being “newcomers” in New York.

Deborah H. Perelmuter,
Vice-President: Services in the Jewish Community

Lisa Sherman-Cohen, Director, Communications & Marketing Jewish Child Care Association

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


Nice article, but I do not see any mention of strengthening the "Jew" in Bukharian Jews. What I mean to say is that how does the JCCA foster a greater emphasis on religious learning and observance as opposed to a secular vision of Judaism which has lead the members of the reform and conservative movements to lose their Jewish identities?

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.