Remembering Sharon
Wed, 01/08/2014

“Old soldiers never die, they just fade away.”

That line from an old ballad, cited by U.S. military hero Gen. Douglas MacArthur in his farewell address to Congress in 1951, could well be applied to Ariel Sharon. The larger-than-life Israeli general, statesman and prime minister, who began his long, slow fade from the public conscience eight years ago, will be remembered as a man who made history, both in war and in politics. Praised or reviled, he was a commanding presence, a leader who usually got his way.

On the eve of the massive stroke that left him in a coma, he was a powerful prime minister expected to soon win re-election. Once revered by the settler movement for his unstinting support, he was reviled when he withdrew Israel’s troops and thousands of citizens from Gaza in 2005, believing that was the price to pay for maintaining Israel as both a Jewish and democratic state. The Likud party that he had led turned against him for the Gaza withdrawal, so he formed a new party, Kadima, determined to continue on his path. That’s what Sharon was like – bulldozer, visionary or both.

His biography reads like the history of the State of Israel. A war hero at 20 in the War of Independence, he was then chosen to lead the famous, or infamous, Unit 101, which was brutally successful in combatting Arab terrorists. He built his reputation as Israel’s greatest commander for his success in the Sinai desert, first in the Six Day War, and six years later during the Yom Kippur War, when he defied his military superiors and led an end-around attack that encircled the Egyptian Third Army and effectively saved Israel from a disastrous defeat.

Military experts around the world still teach the lessons of that typically bold, defiant and brilliant move by Sharon. But another of his rebellious military actions, in 1982 – to extend the invasion against Yasir Arafat and seek to finish him and the PLO off – proved disastrous and left Israeli troops in Lebanon for many years. Sharon was accused of deceiving Prime Minister Menachem Begin, and for his indirect role in the Sabra and Shatilla massacres, he was forced to step down as defense minister. His military and political career appeared over.

But Sharon came back and was elected prime minister in 2001, defeating incumbent Ehud Barak after being blamed by some for setting off the second intifada by touring the Temple Mount complex.

It was Sharon who struck back forcefully against Palestinian strongholds at the low point of the suicide bombing campaign, who built the security fence, and who planned and carried out the evacuation of Jews from Gaza. To those who would argue that he wavered in his actions -- now using force, now pulling back – he would insist that he was being consistent: defending the Jewish people, whatever that required.

However he is judged by history, he was a man of his convictions, dedicated to his mission, gruff at times, tender at others – a native sabra and the personification of a proud, brave Israeli.

editor@jewishweek.org

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.

Comments

Ariel Sharon's Israel was an Israel where all of its neighbors, on a daily basis, threatened to annihilate the State and drive all the Jews into the sea. It was and is an Israel where the Palestinians name their streets in honor of terrorists who have slaughtered innocent men, women, and children on busses, in restaurants, schools, shopping malls, and supermarkets. It was and is an Israel that witnessed Arab terrorists targeting little children and being lauded in Arab cities for murdering Jewish children.

In 1979 Palestinian Sami Kuntar and his group of terrorists broke into an apartment building in Israel and kidnapped a young father, 31-year-old Danny Haran, and his 4-year-old daughter, Einat, taking them to a nearby beach. Kuntar was found guilty of murdering Haran in front of Einat, then turning to the child and crushing her skull against a rock with the butt of his rifle. When he was released from jail many years later in a swap with Hezbollah for two Israeli soldiers who had been captured he received an heroes welcome with people dancing in the street upon his return. It is easy for the Diaspora, living in the comfort of their homes in America, to criticize Sharon's strong arm tactics but he did what had to do for his people.

The Left will never understand a man like Sharon. They don't have to worry about the safety of their children going to a nightclub, to school, getting on a bus, going out for lunch to a restaurant, or going to a shopping mall to meet their friends. Israeli's have endured dozens and dozens of terrorist attacks. What happened in Boston a year ago at the Marathon has been duplicated a hundred times all across Israel with terrorist attacks against innocent men, women, and children. What the Left will never understand is that you cannot negotiate with people who want your annihilation. There is nothing you can ever offer them that will placate them except your death and destruction. Sharon understood that, and yes, his tactics were brutal at times, but they were effective.

Unless you have family living in bomb shelters as many families in the North of Israel have during Hezbollah missile attacks, and unless you have received that horrible call about a loved one who was blown to pieces while on a bus, a restaurant, a school, or a shopping mall then you cannot and never will understand what the average Israeli had to deal with on a daily basis. Sharon responded in the only language those sending out terrorists to slaughter Jews understood. Should he be lauded? No. Understood? Most definitely yes.

I think after 8 years of being in a coma,it is time to pull the plug and let him rest in peace and let the country mourn him.

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.