The Real ‘Catastrophe’ Of The Nakba
Tue, 05/15/2012

Palestinians marked Tuesday as the day commemorating the Nakba, or “catastrophe,” by protesting in Israel, some throwing stones and Molotov cocktails in what has become an annual ritual of anger, frustration and violence. The real catastrophe is that the Palestinians continue to mourn the past and forfeit the future by refusing to acknowledge the present — the reality of the State of Israel and its right to exist.

The Nakba protests underscore the essential obstacle to peace, with Palestinians claiming that much of Israel has been “occupied” since 1948, and the rest since 1967, making all of the country illegitimate.

As noted by Palestinian Media Watch, children are taught that all of Israel is “occupied,” with schoolbooks describing “colonialism” as “the British occupation after the First World War in 1917, and the Israeli occupation in 1948.”

The catastrophe of the Palestinian people is that their leaders are grounded in victimhood, responding to repeated attempts at compromise and negotiation from Israel with defiance or violence, going back many decades. Surely the Palestinians would have had a state of their own today if they had leaders with the courage to tell them Israel is a country to be accommodated, not eradicated.

Today, there is little serious talk of renewed, meaningful negotiations. President Barack Obama, months away from elections, is not pressing the issue. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu calls for talks with no pre-conditions while Palestinian Authority President Abbas insists on another settlement freeze.

Perhaps the Israelis and Palestinians each believe time is on their side and the best strategy is to hold fast. But demographics do not remain static, and the possibility of a viable two-state solution diminishes with each passing day.

It is in Israel’s interest to push for progress, but none will come as long as Palestinians try to reclaim the past instead of ensuring a peaceful future.



Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


The real catastrophe ,is people like you who keep placing the blame on the Palestinians only. If Israel means peace, it would have implemented peace a long time ago. Read Miko Peled's book, The Generals son. Based on the official documents of 1967 war debates. Israeli Zionists, have a plan, it's not done yet. The world is not fooled any longer, and it's time for the rest of blind sleeping supporters of Israel to wake up, if they want to talk about peace.Israel, is no longer the home for the Jews, it's the coming Catastrophe of the Jews, if it continues on this path.

It is not true that "the Palestinians" refuse to recognize the right of Israel to exist; some do and some don't, but Abbas and the Palestinian authority does, along with the Arab League, which has promised Israel in the now ten-year old peace initiative both peace and recognition within its June 1967 frontiers. Is Abbas sincere? Israel has only to cease further colonization of the West Bank to find out. Moreover it has nothing to lose; if it turns out Abbas refuses a settlement within the Clinton parameters, it can resume colonization once again. This is not to say that colonization of the West Bank is justified even in the absence of a settlement. It is to say that the Netanyahu government clearly prefers to keep the colonization going rather than to negotiate a settlement that once and for all would define its frontiers.
Irwin Wall

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.