view counter
Murder In The Headlines
Wed, 01/08/2014

Our prayers go out to the family of Menachem Stark, the 39-year-old chasidic real estate developer and father of eightwho was brutally kidnapped and murdered late last week.

Whether the crime is tied to outstanding debts or a grudge from bad business dealings, as implied in media coverage of Mr. Stark’s murder and quotes from anonymous police sources in the past few days, there is no justification for such a cruel act of vengeful violence. According to authorities two people pushed him into a van and he was held prisoner before being burned and suffocated, his still-smoldering body left in a Long Island dumpster.

That makes Sunday’s callous New York Post front-page headline suggesting Mr. Stark’s murder was inevitable – “Who didn’t want him dead?” -- that much more jarring. We understand the tabloid’s attention-grabbing, often coarse style; here the editors played up the fact that detectives believe there is a long list of suspects. But the headline focuses indignation against the victim rather than against the killers. In its response to reader outrage, The Post said “our reporting showed that he had many enemies, which may have led to the commission of this terrible crime.” Again that comes close to saying Mr. Stark had it coming.

At the same time, we wish those who have voiced their indignation about The Post headline would be equally outspoken against members of their own community who besmirch its image. Public records show that Mr. Stark left behind a trail of defaulted loans, angry tenants and civil suits as his real estate empire spread across Brooklyn and Queens.

Sadly, we have gotten used to reading about scandals linking ostensibly religious people to heinous acts, from money laundering to trafficking in drugs and human organs to sexual abuse. And a percentage of the city’s worst slumlords bear Hebrew names. The reality is that some of these people stay in the good graces of their community. We have no doubt that the majority of the haredi communit live ethical and pious lives. But the ritual observance of wrongdoers should not mask their bad behavior.

Still, Menachem Stark’s business dealings must be viewed separate and apart from outrage over his murder, the urgent need for his killers to be apprehended, and sympathy for the wife and young children he left behind.


Our Newsletters, Your Inbox

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


As a Jew, I have little sympathy for any Satmar tragedy. The NY Post was right in publishing that Stark was a slumlord.I don’t see why Jews are upset when the truth is revealed. Read the 2 main Satmar weeklies, Der Blatt and Der Yid, and how they rejoice at and mock the deaths of Zionists, and curse them with the ugly “yemach shemom vezichrom.” For example, Ezer Weizmann, the late president of Israel and defence minister, had a son who was killed in a car accident. Der Yid was happy that he died because was driving on Shabbos. Similarly, Der Yid has regularly rejoiced at the fate of Theodor Herzl and his family, all of whom died young or tragically. Every week, those two Yiddish weeklies spread pure hatred of Zionism and Zionists. You'd never know that the greatest enemies of the Jews were the Nazis. Similarly, the Satmar Rebbe, Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum, who died in 1979, and is utmost revered by his Hasidim, passionately hated the Zionists, even though he was saved by the Zionist Rudolf Kastner during the Holocaust. Indeed, in his Sefer (religious book) Divrei Yoel he calls all Zionists Amalekim (the archenemy of the Jews). The Satmars were the ones who introduced hatred among Jews with their regular demonstrations against Israel and the ads on radio and in newspapers denouncing Zionists as inauthentic Jews, costing millions of dollars. In the stores on Lee Ave., the heart of Satmar Williamsburg, you will never see any other Jewish weeklies sold, but the Satmar ones. Satmars hold all others, even Haredi ones, as treif.

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.