Let's Disagree, But Not Dismiss
01/03/2013 - 10:24
Visitors to the Western Wall leave written prayers as well. Getty Images
Visitors to the Western Wall leave written prayers as well. Getty Images

The end of 2012 saw an increase in arrests of women at the Western Wall who demand the right to pray there in groups, out loud and wearing prayer shawls and tefilin.

The conflict between those women and their supporters, and those who believe that women should pray at the wall only quietly, and individually, goes back decades and is something that we’ve covered here at the Jewish Week and will continue to cover.

I won’t go into those details here, but I want to use this issue to highlight a human weakness, one that I share, and that I want to work on: the temptation to see those with whom one disagrees as provocateuers motivated by the pleasure they get from your distress.

This came up around the Kotel question in a letter I received from a reader after our most recent article on the subject ran, which I happened to write.

In this letter, the Orthodox writer described with admiration a non-Orthodox relative of his who held an egalitarian Bat Mitzvah ceremony at the wall, but at some distance from the contested areas, in deference to the sensibilities of those whom he saw as the large majority of those who pray there.

So far, so good. I’m impressed with anyone who chooses to subordinate their point of view, out of generosity or even for strategic reasons. It takes strength either way.

But then came the kicker, as it usually does.

“Any fair-minded person without an axe to grind nor an agenda to push will see my [relative’s] point of view,” the letter concluded.

And there’s the problem, the notion that those who wouldn’t make the same decision regarding the Bat Mitzvah’s location can’t be fair-minded, and must inherently have an axe to grind, or an agenda to push, because they disagree with the writer of the letter.

It’s too bad we all can’t be more like this relative of his, honoring through our actions the sincerity of opposing beliefs, even when we don’t disagree with them. Including those who deny women the right to pray out loud at the wall.

Let’s disagree, but try not to dismiss. It’s a start.

helenatjewishweek@gmail.com; @thesimplechild

view counter

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


I saw a video clip of "rabbi" Elyse Frishman being arrested.I cracked up because she doesn't understand Hebrew and needed Anat Hoffman to translate.Rabbi...right.

That guy may have been an idiot, as you say, but using him as an excuse for you to go from "orthodoxy to freedom," is on you, not him. Ok, if you needed an excuse not to be religious, you have one. Feel better? Blame someone else for your being inadequate in your religious believes. The trick is to work on yourself in life and not blame the world for your problems.

my mother went to the kotel to pray for a child after loosing a girl pre birth .in 1941 there were no black hats in control any body could go and stand anywhere the got a space.

in 78 i got to the kotel first time and was over come and set down in tears.some idiot came up and complained that one must have ones head not shoulder against the wall .that interfering idiot set me on a journey that took me out of orthodoxy to freedom .the line between me and the god they allegedly worship