Our Duty, In The Diaspora
11/27/2012 - 21:54
Noah Yaffe
From the Baha'i Gardens in Haifa, the author could glimpse Lebanon, home of Hezbollah. Getty Images
From the Baha'i Gardens in Haifa, the author could glimpse Lebanon, home of Hezbollah. Getty Images

Once again, Israel is being attacked. But this time around, after having been to Israel, I know what kind of danger they are in.

It is striking. If Israel was proportionate in size to all the attention it gets from the U.N. and the world press, Israel would be at least as big as Russia. But alas, it is smaller than England, and its borders much less defensible. And there's no Israeli Channel to buffer surrounding hostile governments. There is no way around it: Israel is a mighty small chunk of land.

This realization struck me hard when I was in Haifa visiting Lihi, my tour bus guard and medic. The havdallah stars had finally come out and we were visually touring the gorgeous area from atop the Baha'i Gardens. "There is the main harbor and way up there is Rosh HaNikra. Everything past that is Lebanon."

I turned my head and did a double take. "Wait... That's where Hezbollah fired off the rockets from in 2006? That close to Haifa?" It can't be more than a twenty-minute drive, I thought.

"Yes, the rockets easily reach here," Lihi  said. "Rockets could have hit where we're standing now. They were only fired during the day though, so we slept well at night. Harder to see from where the rockets come during the day."


No illusions of natural security here. Israelis work tirelessly to maintain every bit of their security.

Now, Haifa isn't currently in any danger from the Gaza rockets. But a large civilian-populated area is currently being fired upon. And Israelis have already died.

My hope with this little piece is to remind you how geographically small Israel is and how immensely important defense issues are. Being attacked in Israel is the historical status quo. But we in the diaspora have a duty to recall and remember what the citizens and soldiers are dealing with before we heap on solutions and advice.

The fear is real and tangible. Especially in times of war.


view counter

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


For added perspective, I'd like to point out that the Palestinians have half the population, a quarter as much territory (ergo twice the population density), and six times as many deaths over the last decade plus.

Perspective is such an important thing! There are far too many people who have absolutely no perspective ( or historical knowledge) of this situation. Well done, son.

Well said, Noah!

You're so right, Noah! Keep up the good work.