Rabbis Haskel Lookstein & Yehuda Gilad Respond to Those Who Are Against Selling/Renting to Arabs In Israel
12/10/2010 - 14:00
Jonathan Mark

This was sent by Rabbi Haskel Lookstein, December 10, 2010, to his congregation, Kehilath Jeshurun.
Dear KJ Family:
The Jewish and general world has been rocked in the past few days by a statement signed by rabbis in the State of Israel that prohibits selling or renting a home to a non-Jew in the Land of Israel. It is important for those who disagree with that statement to make that disagreement clear – and public – because silence can be construed as agreement. 
In the interest of my making my own views clear, I am attaching below a very strong statement by Rav Yehuda Gilad, the Rosh Yeshiva of Yeshivat Maaleh Gilboa in the Galil.  Rav Gilad, the son-in-law of the late Rav Yehuda Amital, and the Rabbi of Kibbutz Lavi, is a great exponent of Modern Orthodoxy in Israel. His statement speaks for me and, I would hope, for the KJ family.  I am grateful to Rabbi Weinstock for bringing it to my attention.  The following are Rav Gilad’s words.
Very cordially yours,
Haskel Lookstein

“Ani Mitbayeish” by Rav Yehuda Gilad

There have been a few rare instances in my life where I have felt ashamed to be a believing Jew committed to Halakhah, and to bear the title Rabbi. Seeing the recent rabbinic ruling that categorically prohibits selling or renting a home to a non-Jew in the land of Israel was one of these moments. This ruling is a perversion of halakhah and ethically repugnant.  Moreover, it is a public desecration of God’s name.
Anyone even remotely familiar with the world of Halakhah knows that it is possible to quote Biblical verses, Talmudic statements and Halakhic precedents to support almost any position. There is in the vast treasure of our Torah, statements of law and lore that give expression to diverse and contradictory trends of thought for different times and changing circumstances.

So, too, in relation to Gentiles, on the one hand, we find statements that reflect the mainstream of Jewish tradition such as "beloved is all mankind, created in the Divine image" and the like.  On the other hand, the statement, “kill even the best of the Gentiles” (which apparently was uttered in extreme circumstances when we were under the brutal reign of the Romans) appears in our sources. The wisdom of the rabbis and leaders of every generation was to issue Halakhic rulings that were appropriate to their time and place in a manner that did justice to the tradition while simultaneously sanctifying God’s name.
Regarding the sale and renting of homes in Israel to non-Jews, outstanding rabbis of recent generations, led by Rabbi Herzog, first Chief Rabbi of Israel, ruled that the prohibition "you shall not show them favor" (Deut. 7:2) written in the Torah and part of the cannon of Halakhah, is not relevant to the reality of a Jewish democratic state -- a member of the family of nations, which promised before the entire world to grant equality to its citizens regardless of religion, race or sex.

As a resident of the Galilee, I cannot ignore a real problem that exists in certain places and requires solutions on a national level. Maintaining the Jewish character of Israel is a real concern, especially in light of internal and external voices questioning our right to a Jewish national home.

However, we should remember the country's Jewish character is measured first and foremost through moral parameters. Dozens of times the Torah abjures us to love the stranger. "You shall love the stranger because you were strangers in Egypt." As a people who suffered over the generations discrimination and racism, we bear a responsibility to be a paragon of decency to the minorities that live among us. This is the way of Torah and Halakhah from time immemorial.

As the Rambam writes in another context: "the Torah’s laws are not to bring revenge into the world, rather they are to bring mercy and grace and peace into the world." Anyone for whom the Torah of Israel is dear, must rise up and protest against this perverse ruling. For just these types of circumstances it was said, "where there is a desecration of God, one pays no honor to the Rabbis."


Get The Jewish Week Newsletter

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


Arab Racism VS Israeli Woories http://freeisraelnow.wordpress.com/2010/12/12/arab-racism-vs-israeli-worries/ -- While anti-Israel bigots, Arabs, Muslims have for so long tried to cast Israelis’ legitimate concern over a growing racist Arab threat that seeks its annihilation – in a bad light, the recent phenomenon is that radical leftysts inside Israel cast at times these worries and subsequented defensive actions also with such bombastic -unfair- definitions, though their aim is political, the damage is simply horrific, nevertheless. Now, why don’t we talk about the real racism in the area, outside or even inside Israel, the Arab racism of course, that which since (at least the 1920s) tried to commit genocide on the Jewish population and together with Islamic bigotry, these two fascisms motivated the expulsion of 1,000,000 Jews and the anti-Israel campaign. The latter campaign has never been discntinued. [Racism by Israeli Arabs include: creating - via intimidation and violence- an "off limits to Jews and "pure" Arab (areas) zone; Arabs' targeting of innocent Jews, simply for being Jews; the massive rationalization for support of attackers in the Arab public.]
I was very saddened by the intemporate remarks by Rabbi Lookstein. Before being "ashamed" of being a rabbi and Jew that follows Halacha, he should understand that these are strong words which should not be used against rabbis seeking to address an intolerable problem. The tension, pressure, and sense of isolation that Jews living in a area that has a rising, aggressive, anti-Israel, and anti-Semitic Arab population is felt first and foremost on these people and their rabbis who feel their pain. Being a well-heeled rabbi on the upper East side or a well connected Rosh Yeshiva in Israel provides a major insulation against the problems which these rabbis felt a need to address. Their angst would be better directed against a government that allows these Jews to suffer at the hands of Arab aggression, just as it allowed the Jews in Yamit, Gaza, Yaffo, and the West Bank to suffer, in the interest of being P.C. and "democratic Israel". For shame.
1) ARAB RACISM VS ANXIOUS ISRAELIS Why does everyone follow the Haaretz/Meretz/PeaceNow radical anti-Judaism bombastic language to cast all Israeli-worries of Arab attackers as "racism"? Maybe the Arab attackers and their sympathizers in therir freligious leadership are the real racists that target Jews, for being Jews? And what about Aparrtheid Palestine where it's punishable by death from ISLAM authorities in PA to sell land to non-Muslims, especiall;y to Jews? 2) ISLAM & RACISM Is there such an equivalent to the 100% racist dehumanization of the "holy" Quran about Jews being: apes and pigs??? 3) QUOTE??? Where does it say "best of gentiles kill"???
The list of those speaking out is growing rapidly. Rav Aharon Lichtenstein, Rav Yoel Bin Nun, Rav Meidan, etc.
I think that saying that rav yaakov meidan "spoke out" is a serious misstatement see http://www.inn.co.il/News/News.aspx/212823
This is one article. In the hebrew press the Rav Elyashiv (leader of the Israeli ultra-orthodox community), and the Rav Ovadia Yosef (former cheif rabbi and leader of political party Shas) spoke out against the letter. It's always harder for the sane and normal people to shout - that's what makes the extreme voices be heard...
Excellent - thank you for speaking out. The only thing that would make it better would be a "call to action," and a link to whatever that was (e.g., petition, website, email, etc.). Thanks again!
Nice article, but does it really reflect any following in Israel? I mean, 40 municipal Rabbis signed the original letter, and more are joining. A survey published on Ynet yesterday said that 55% of Jewish Israelis support the letter. Isn't it time we reconsider whehter the UN had it right that Zionism is racism? Or at least most Zionists are racists? What a very sad situation...

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.