It's Party Time After Shul. Mixed Drinks, Clear Message
02/18/2013 - 16:56
Gary Rosenblatt

Maybe Lucette Lagnado’s piece in The Wall Street Journal (Feb. 8) on how some high-profile Orthodox synagogues are drawing large crowds to their Shabbat morning services with expensive booze and elaborate catering at kiddush will prove embarrassing enough to tamp down this trend. But I don’t think so.

More likely the article will have the opposite effect, with officials of synagogues suffering poor attendance saying, “hey, let’s try it here.”

As noted, these affairs can be quite costly, exceeding $10,000 for one Shabbat kiddush at Rabbi Marc Schneier’s chic West Hampton Synagogue. And at The Shul in Bal Harbour, Florida, last year a donor provided $500-a-bottle Scotch each week and, notes Rabbi Sholom Lipskar, the shots “went pretty fast.”

So while some rabbis urge congregants to come to services for a spiritual high, members may be experiencing a more earthly one.

The Orthodox Union has spoken out in the past against “kiddush clubs,” where men leave the sanctuary during services for a “l’chaim,” and sometimes come back a bit rowdy, or don’t come back at all.

But rabbis are in a tough bind. They don’t want to alienate their regular attendees who find that the kiddush club makes shul more enjoyable, but they also don’t want to suggest to young people that drinking alcohol – especially in the morning and as an excuse to take a break from services – is cool.

In the meantime, the booze flows, the lavish food is consumed and the message is clear.


view counter

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


I wrote out a "shiur" on this subject (about 6 weeks before the article came out). It's a little long, but it gives many arguments for why those who follow halakha (or who try as much as possible) should not be participating in these ventures. Many halakhic strikes against it.

The fundamental issue with Lagnado's article is the assumption that Judaism is afraid of carnal pleasure when, at it's Biblical and Rabbinic foundations, it is not.

While single malt and shema make for an awkward pairing, the issue Lagnado takes with the pricey kiddush is even more superficial than a $200 bottle of whisky. Perhaps the kiddush club members who choose to sponsor a $10,000 kiddush should give that money to a better guess is they already do. Perhaps the people that support the social aspect of the synagogue are the same supporting the poor, education and the future of the Jewish people.

I do not drive to Shul on Shabbat, however the Rabbi drives me to drink once I get there.