A WaPo editorial on Arizona immigration law echoes concerns of Jewish groups
04/29/2010 - 12:50
James Besser

 A strong editorial in today's Washington Post sheds some light on why a number of Jewish groups think Arizona's new illegal immigration law is stupid and dangerous.

The Post writes that the new law 'will turn immigrants who came here illegally into quarry for law enforcement agencies statewide,” and that it “twists the Constitution."

Read the whole editorial here.

Jewish groups that have spoken out against the new law – which is generating threats of boycotts against the state – include the Union for Reform Judaism, the Anti-Defamation League and HIAS.

Rabbi David Saperstein, director of the Religious Action Center of Reform Judaism, said “this inhumane and retrogressive bill virtually invites racial and ethnic profiling by broadly defining reasonable suspicion of undocumented status as grounds for questioning by police officers. Allowing an individual’s accent or skin color to precipitate an investigation into his or her legal status is an anathema to American values of justice and our historic status as a nation of immigrants. The bill is also likely to endanger our communities by discouraging immigrants from cooperating with law enforcement on issues of national security.”

Groups like the RAC and HIAS hope the controversy surrounding the Arizona law will spur passage of long-delayed comprehensive immigration reform, which they hope will include both enforcement provisions and a route to citizenship for those here illegally.

But hey, this is an election year and anti-immigration groups, peddling fear about crime, terrorism and lost jobs, are always louder than those who want balanced legislation. And I don't see many signs this Congress, already spooked by the anti-incumbent mood of the electorate and the tea partiers, are going to put themselves on the firing line to get it done.

view counter

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


Did any of those organizations even read the bill? Or do they get their news directly from Olbermann? This has been blown way out of proportion by the MSM. I live in Phoenix and this bill is desparately needed to stop the invasion of our southern border. The federal government won't do this. There is a terrible drug war occuring, a Pinal County deputy was shot by drug smugglers and recently a Jewish Chandler, AZ police officer was killed in the line of duty by an illegal alien. Phoenix is the kidnapping capital of the US. There is a huge amount of human trafficing happening here too. I am Jewish and have compassion for families who want a better life, but it is putting a major stress on our state's finances. We are voting on another tax increase this month, and as a Phoenix resident, we have just had a food tax imposed to keep our essential services going. These illegals have come here and received free education, healthcare, and human services. Let them come in through the legal process.