The Republicans' Pollard Problem
11/26/2010 - 10:33
James Besser

With congressional efforts to win convicted spy Jonathan Pollard's release on the uptick, it's interesting to consider the Republicans awkward Pollard problem. (Read the Jewish Week editorial "Release Pollard Now" here)

That problem was evident earlier in the month when 39 House members signed a letter calling for Pollard's release – every last one of them a Democrat.

Rep. Barney Frank (D-Mass.), one of the letter's organizers, said he tried to get some Republican signatures, to no avail.

The problem is, the GOP is caught between some strong political interests when it comes to Pollard. And the plain fact is, one is stronger than the other.

Yes, they love the Jewish right when it comes to issues like the Middle East peace process, Jewish settlements in the West Bank and terrorism. And you'd think that would make them natural supporters of the get-Pollard-out-of-jail movement, which is anchored in the Jewish right despite increasingly broad support from major Jewish organizations.

But the Republicans are also national security hawks who tap traditional veins of American patriotism; the idea of freeing a spy, no matter how much time he's served, is hard for many to swallow.

Back in the late 1990s, when former President Bill Clinton was considering swapping Pollard as part of a Wye River agreement, there were reports many Republican members of Congress were nervous about releasing a spy whose supporters hailed him as a hero of Zion.

That fear probably helps explain the lack of GOP support for the recent congressional letter – along with a loathing of supporting anything the Democrats are for.

I'm not saying the Democrats are good and the Republicans bad on Pollard.

The fact 39 Democrats signed the Pollard letter represents a bit of a shift in the political landscape, but it would be an exaggeration to say Democrats are swarming to the commutation crusade, either.

In reality, the idea of releasing a convicted spy, even if there's no sound legal or national security rationale for his continued incarceration, is something that makes politicians of all stripes – Republicans and Democrats alike- nervous.

I'm guessing more members would like to speak out for commuting Pollard's sentence - but worry that if he IS freed and arrives in Israel like a conquering hero, there could be some uncomfortable political blow back.

That's more of a problem for the Republicans than the Democrats right now –which is undoubtedly a big reason Barney Frank got bubkes when he tried to get GOP colleagues to sign his Pollard letter.


No one who cares about the US relationship with Israel and has actually thought this through wants Pollard released. (Yes, I know plenty of people who care a lot about Israel want him released, but their appeals clearly show they're either ignorant of the facts surrounding his case or haven't thought them through to their logical conclusion.) The democrats would be more than happy to see that relationship disintegrate and that's why so many of them are gung ho on this crusade. Republicans (or most of them, anyway) do understand the nuance that Besser suggests here, but doesn't carry far enough. It's not only the idea of releasing a spy to a hero's welcome, which the MSM will play for all it's worth. It's the timing of that release in the middle of (mostly) national bi-partisan angst over the dramatic disclosure of our state secrets in someone else's ideological crusade. The Wikileaks fiasco couldn't have come at a worse time for Pollard. A very faint silver lining, AFAIC.
nonsense. many republicans are in favor of releasing pollard. i doubt that frank tried to enlist republicans on this.
It's about justice now, now about anything but justice.
1 in seven sitting Dems sign the petition. Likely because they had pitty on Pollard, and were clueless over what he stole. Pollard was one of the most dangerous and damaging spys in US history. Pulitzer Prize winning jounalists have written articles on why he should never be released from prison. Heck Israel didn't even admit he was their guy for a decade after he was captured, and to date Israel has refused numerous apeals for a comprehensive list of what Pollard stole. Estimated to be a pile of paper rougly equivelent in volume to a large family car. Any American polititian who releases pollard is likely ending his own political future, regardless fo party. It does the US Israeli special relationship no service for Israeli's to continously misrepresent what Pollards stole, why, and what that information was used for.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.