Huckabee v. Obama and the (divided) Jewish vote
04/13/2011 - 14:44
James Besser

 Over at his Spiritual Politics blog, Professor Mark Silk looks at the unannounced candidacy of former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee for the 2012 Republican presidential nomination.

“Amidst all the hand-wringing about the state of the Republican presidential field, one potential candidate seems to be sailing blithely along--undeclared, familiar, discounted, and atop the polls,” Silk writes. “It's Mike Huckabee, of course.”

It's far too early to handicap the 2012 presidential race, especially in the current overheated political environment, but it strikes me Huck - not officially in the race, but making all the right noises - is pretty well positioned in a chaotic GOP field.

If Huckabee does get the nomination, it could provide the best illustration yet of the big and still growing gap between single-issue pro-Israel voters and a broader Jewish electorate that sees Israel as only one of a long list of important issues and whose focus tends to be domestic.

Huckabee's outspoken support for Likud positions, his insistence that the Palestinians can have a state but not in Palestine and his apparent support for ongoing Jewish settlement in the West Bank will galvanize the Jewish right – and undoubtedly generate anti-Obama rhetoric that will make the 2008 campaign look tame.

But Huckabee's identification with the domestic agenda of the religious right in this country will likely make him anathema to most multi-issue Jewish voters – a much bigger segment of the Jewish electorate.

The liberal majority is much bigger, but the right, with its pinpoint focus on Israel, may be more energized by this election.

It would take something on the order of a miracle for Huckabee to surpass Ronald Reagan's 39 percent of the Jewish vote in 1980, but an energetic turnout from the Jewish right for Huckabee and an anemic one for Obama from Jewish liberals who are disappointed with President Obama's performance could see the GOP candidate do significantly better than 2008 nominee John McCain, who won about 22 percent.

On the other hand, if Huckabee runs hard to the right in the GOP primaries to snag the critical evangelical bloc, that could energize the liberal-leaning majority to turn out in force for Obama.

In short, an Obama-Huckabee race just might turn out Jewish voters in record numbers.

Speaking of gaps, I'm wondering about the impact of an Obama deficit reduction plan, announced in a speech today, that includes tax increases for more affluent Americans.

Jewish liberals have no problem with phasing out the big tax cuts for wealthier Americans, but Jewish mega-givers – the folks who keep the communal infrastructure afloat, and who have benefited handsomely from Bush-era tax cuts – may not be so enthusiastic.

As the debate over competing deficit reduction plans gets into high gear, will we see mounting tensions between rank-and-file activists, who may tend to favor the Obama plan, and top lay leaders, who may line up behind the Republicans?

Stay tuned; it's going to be a lively year in the Jewish world.

view counter

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


Huckabee would absolutely support Israel. I think a lot of military threats to Israel would die down. Also, Huckabee is more domestically moderate than most think he would be...but not neocon. Think more Jacksonian democrat.

I don't understand why the liberal Jewish community would be turned off to Huckabee's hard right domestic issues. I know that the Jews have the ten commandments from Moses. In those commandments, there is one commandment, "Thou shall not kill". Don't the Jewish people know that killing babies in the womb (abortion) breaks that commandment? If they follow these commandments, how can they support the Democrats who are all for abortion? Please help me understand the Jewish people better.

**of the big and still growing gap between single-issue pro-Israel voters and a broader Jewish electorate that sees Israel as only one of a long list of important issues and whose focus tends to be domestic.**

Hate to break this to you , James, but some of us Pro-Israel voters care about other issues too (including domestic issues), and would still support a candidate like Huckabee over Obama.

You are trying to portray the Jewish Right a single-issue driven group, but you are very wrong.

...on the economic front we don't buy the Democratic party line of big government and big spending, because it makes no sense whatsoever, despite George Soros' approval of the concept.

We are also very concerned about national security, and Obama's apology tour around the world just strikes us as portraying the United States as weak and ineffectual.

**I'm wondering about the impact of an Obama deficit reduction plan, announced in a speech today,**

Seriously, you actually try to attach Obama to the concept of deficit reduction? Did you have a smile on your face as you wrote that? That qualifies as an oxymoron if I've ever heard one.

Have you noticed that the administration claimed that the $500 Billion it was going to slash from Medicare to help fund ObamaCare was simply coming from waste, but now that the Republicans are presenting a budget that will actually tackle the deficit, they are claiming the cuts proposed to Medicare are "Draconian"?

What did I miss here? Obama's $500 Billion cut for Obamacare is from waste, any cuts proposed by the Republicans are going to kill seniors? Do they think we are idiots and aren't going to see through this hypocrisy?

The Jewish Right are multi-dimensional voters who are concerned about all the issues facing America today, and your attempt to portray them as one-dimensional is self-serving.

I'm sorry, James, I don't mean for the facts to get in the way of your good story.

Ah yes, the ever hopeful search for the Jewish Republican vote, ever doomed to disappointment. Rest assured that Obama will get his 80% of the Jewish vote regardless of how would-be pundits try to spin out implausible scenarios suggesting otherwise.