Getting The News
10/17/2011 - 12:42
Douglas Bloomfield

  If you think the Daily Alert news summary published by the Conference of President of Major American Jewish Organizations leans too far to the right and you'd like to see another view of current events, take a look at the News Nosh, a bright new publication of Americans for Peace Now. 

You can read both on line or subscribe and have them sent to you daily. 

The Daily Alert is prepared by the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs, which is run by Dore Gold, a hawkish former Likud official and U.N. ambassador in Benjamin Netanyahu's first term.

Both offer synopses of the top stories and links to read the full articles on line. News Nosh tends to offer a much wider variety of stories but nearly all from Israeli media, while the Daily Alert includes more international media and is very unlikely to offer anything unflattering to the Israeli government.

The News Nosh may be geographically more limited but it covers a wider range of viewpoints than the Daily Alert, which is often likely to suppress news that doesn't fit into its hasbarah mission.

A few years back a report on illegal settlement activity, commissioned by then-Prime Minister Ariel Sharon, was making headlines in all the Israeli media, but if you depended on the Daily Alert for your news, it never happened. In the three weeks following the Sasson Report's release, not a single item about it appeared in the Daily Alert.

There is always a lively and sophisticated debate going on in Israel about current developments – today it is the Shalit deal with Hamas and rising settler violence – and American Jews should have access to all sides of these debates. 

That is critical if Jews here are to make informed decisions as they pursue their pro-Israel activism.  Few people have the time to surf the Web and read all the newspapers and all their e-mail and to pick up all the nuances. They need sources that can present them with a good sample of the day's coverage to evaluate on their own

Both the Daily Alert and the News Nosh are worth reading; make your own judgment. You can't beat the price.

 

Comments

I receive both publications -- the Nosh and the Daily Alert. Mr. Bloomfield calls the Daily Alert's editor "hawkish," but no where does he label the Nosh and its Peace Now source "Leftist" or "Dovish."

I read both publications fully, and half of the Nosh's editions contain attacks on Israeli settlers, usually in the opening Quote of the Day section. I rarely see articles critical of the Palestinians in the Nosh. Quoting Kadima's Tzipi Livni is par for the course for the Nosh.

The Daily Alert, on the other hand, reflecting an attempt to be impartial, avoids the internal Israeli political issues, religious differences among Jews, or settlement issues.

When Pres Obama spoke at the UN and eloquently raised Israel's case the Nosh highlighted criticism of Obama for insulting the Palestinians.

For American supporters of Israel, it's important to read material on US policies, Iranian threats, and Palestinian anti-peace actions. I find that in the Daily Alert.

The Nosh and American for Peace Now are too partisan to be fair. And Mr. Bloomfield is too partisan in his praise of the Nosh. Shame on him and the Jewish Week for running this peace.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.