Separate But Unequal
03/04/2013 - 13:58
Douglas Bloomfield

In the same week that the President of the United States and Congressional leaders unveiled a statue of Rosa Parks in the U.S. Capitol honoring the woman who refused to move to the back of the bus in Montgomery, Alabama, Israel inaugurated its latest version of segregated busing.

Defenders called it a security measure, critics called it racism.

Israel has begun two Palestinian-only bus lines in the West Bank in response to demands from settlers opposed to riding with Arabs.  Not everyone agreed with the Transport Ministry's description that this is would "improve public transport services for Palestinian workers entering Israel."

What's really going on is the government bending to settlers' complaints that letting Palestinians on their buses was a security risk. The Transport Ministry said Palestinians would not be prohibited from using public buses in the West Bank and inside Israel. Human rights groups said the segregation is racist and unjustifiable.

A police spokesman was quoted saying all Palestinians returning to the West Bank from Israel would continue to be routinely searched for stolen property.

This is not Israel's first experience with segregated busing. Bus lines that served only ultra-Orthodox areas have long been gender segregated. The Supreme Court two years ago ruled that forced segregated buses were illegal but allowed them to continue on a voluntary basis. But even beyond those neighborhoods, ultra-Othodox men often harass women passengers on public buses, demanding they move to the rear, and when they refuse the women have been spit on, cursed and shoved by haredi men.

This comes at a time when thousands of pro-Israel activists are in Washington spreading the message about our two countries' shared values.  Apparently not all values.

view counter

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


My partner and I are both minorities and disabled. I, the older of the two of us, have lived among the era of segregation and the legal ending of segregation here in the United States of America. I am saddened to know "my Israel" maybe no better than the racist and prejudiced America I live in today. Yes, we have a black man elected as President but that does not change the racism and prejudice pluralistic society we live in. We would like to visit and maybe live in Israel. However, would we find the same racism, elitism, sexism, bigotry and religion intolerance we experience here from American Diaspora Jews, and Whites and other racial and economic groups? My partner and I would hope not. Separate does not mean equal. It means unequal. The pain of segregation, whether it is in transportation, service in the arm forces, religion, housing, education and other areas of societal life will leave a stinging pain, that will be passed generation to generation. The best way to stop this pain is to not build barriers at all. Apologies are hollow and have little meaning, after the damage has been done.

Seems that Political Correctness is even more important as time goes on. Unfortunately this and PR in general, continue to be fundamental weaknesses for Israel.