A Mother's Prayer: Like Chametz, Take My Resentment
03/25/2013 - 13:37
Rabbi Rebecca Schorr
Rabbi Rebecca Schorr
Rabbi Rebecca Schorr

Seder night is almost upon us and I am dreading it.

I never used to feel this way. Like so many Jews, some of my most-cherished childhood memories are of Seders from years past. With beloved relatives and friends, now gone but always  youthful and full of zest in my memory. Songs of freedom strummed on a guitar. And after all the rituals completed, dishes washed, and folding chairs put away, bridge games far into the night while the little ones fell asleep in odd locations around the house. How I had hoped my children would have those same treasured memories.

No longer. As the mother of a child on the spectrum, this holiday is a nightmare. From start to finish.

When Ben was five, Warren and I took a class to help us better understand his behaviors. One of the most important things we learned was the “ABCs” of Behavior Modification.

Antecedent: what occurs just prior to the displayed behavior

Behavior: what actions occur, intensity, and length

Consequence: what occurs immediately after the displayed behavior, and does it discourage or encourage the behavior

In other words, with this information, my husband, Warren, and I ought to be able to help Ben avoid meltdowns by knowing which antecedents will set him off. While we are not able to accurately predict all the possible antecedents that will cause a meltdown, we know that any one of the following is enough to cause a melt-down:

Any change in schedule

Late nights (in Ben’s case, after 7:30 pm)

Wearing “scratchy” clothing (Ben has some sensory issues and prefers to wear certain material that is less painful to him)

Doing anything that will draw attention to himself (such as reciting the Four Questions)

Food (Ben likes certain foods and has aversions to particular smells and textures)

So with  these antecedents in play, seders are difficult for all of us. And I feel as though we have set Ben up for failure by placing so many stumbling blocks before him.

If Ben had to stay up late for just one seder and not three (my family, Warren’s family, congregational seder), dayeinu.
If Ben had to wear a button-down shirt and not also wear nice pants, dayeinu.
If Ben had to listen to the seder and not read the Four Questions, dayeinu.
If Ben had to refrain from bread and not refrain from all leavened products, dayeinu.

Each year we hope that it will be better. That a year of further maturation and therapies will make it easier on Ben. And, therefore, for me too.

Dear God,
As we have removed the chamtez from the crevices, I pray that You help me remove the resentment that sometimes rises within the recesses of my heart.

Rabbi Rebecca Einstein Schorr is a CLAL Rabbis Without Borders Fellow whose work appears regularly on the Rabbis Without Borders blog and Kveller.com as well as a variety of other online sites. Writing at This Messy Life (www.rebeccaeinsteinschorr.com), Rebecca finds meaning in the sacred and not-yet-sacred intersections of daily life. Follow her on Twitter @rebeccaschorr.


view counter

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


This was so beautifully written and expressed. It - you - brought tears to my eyes. I thank you for sharing and to me, I think, let him wear what works, and let him do what he needs to, and you continue to support him and be the strong family he needs. And you will feel love. And strength. And all of it. I send you my own love, my friend.

I get it. I sometimes wonder if our first born's struggles (oh so similar to Ben's) makes us isolate ourselves for protection - for all of us. May you have a joyful seder with all of its parts!