At His Untraditional Bar Mitzvah, A Son With Autism Leads The Congregation
05/01/2013 - 12:33
Rabbi Rebecca Schorr
Mom and Ben at the Walk for Autism. Ben cut the ribbon to start everybody off. Photo courtesy Rabbi Rebecca Schorr
Mom and Ben at the Walk for Autism. Ben cut the ribbon to start everybody off. Photo courtesy Rabbi Rebecca Schorr

A piece of my soul died when we decided that Ben’s autism would necessitate a reexamination of a conventional Bar Mitzvah service. Having guided so many young people through their studies towards becoming Bar or Bat Mitzvah, I yearned to have the unique privilege of preparing my own son, my firstborn, the way my father, also a rabbi, had long ago prepared me.

Though Ben’s desire to mark this occasion by participating in our local Walk Now for Autism Speaks was one which we fully embraced, I mourned the demise of a fantasy: standing beside my child as he took his place in the chain of our family’s tradition, led his congregation in prayer, chanted from the Torah and delivered a d’var Torah, or commentary, upon reaching the age of commandments.

Martin Buber, one of the preeminent Jewish theologians of the last century, divides the human experience into two categories: I-It, in which we hold something back from another person, I-Thou, in which we share ourselves totally. He posits that our lives are enhanced and defined by our relationships – with our goal of being in relationship with God as the Ultimate Thou. Between a parent and child, I-Thou moments occur more frequently as the child matures. But parents of a child on the autism spectrum fear they might never come.

Yet as we moved through the weekend, I was taken aback by the abundance of I-Thou moments. At several points, I remember thinking to myself that I was experiencing such abject holiness and perfection that I had to emblaze it on my very soul.

One such moment was so unexpected that I have returned to it dozens of time in hopes of searing it into my memory for the rest of my time here on earth. Just as we were about to kindle the Sabbath candles, I leaned over to Ben and asked him if he would like to start the Kiddush. I have no more idea what made me ask than I do what made him say yes.

Ben had certainly started the Kiddush many times at home, but his fear of speaking in public is typically so anxiety-producing that it never occurred to me that he would agree to lead any of the prayers. In a clear, strong voice, he began. I wondered if his voice might taper off once everyone joined in the prayer. I wondered if he might stop at the conclusion of the first line. But he kept going. With no visible hesitation.

Standing beside him, as I have done for scores of Bar and Bat Mitzvah students, I served not as worship leader but as the supportive worship wing-man. Ben never once faltered, leading us all in the prayer that proclaims the sanctity of the seventh day.

When I asked Ben about his personal highlights of the weekend, the first one he mentioned was leading Kiddush on Friday night. “I was so nervous,” he admitted. I reassured him that it was not apparent to anyone – even me. He was surprised; he thought it was obvious to everyone. When I wondered how he was able to get up in front of everyone and lead the entire prayer, he responded, “because I was totally prepared.” Not because it had been an assigned prayer or because we had ever worked on it together. Rather, a lifetime of Shabbos dinners acted as the ultimate preparation.

In all of our planning and all the anticipation, never did I expect my shy, fearful, anxious son to grasp such control of a blessing and prayer with pray with such skill and stunning kavannah, or intention. It was the ultimate I-Thou moment.

Rabbi Rebecca Einstein Schorr is a CLAL Rabbis Without Borders Fellow whose work appears regularly on the Rabbis Without Borders blog and as well as a variety of other online sites. Writing at This Messy Life (, Rebecca finds meaning in the sacred and not-yet-sacred intersections of daily life. Follow her on Twitter @rebeccaschorr.


view counter

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


The journey of a special needs parent (heck, any parent) is filled with adjusting our dreams. I found this beautiful and honest ....and accepting.

To the person that said calling him autistic because he is verbal is unfair.....being non verbal is not a diagnostic symptom of autism. It is a spectrum disorder and many on the spectrum are highly verbal. What is impaired are social communication skills. Even that is severe for some and not for others.

Thank you for sharing! Lovely.

He's clearly verbal so I think labelling him autistic is unfair. I think he deserves alot better than this article. what if he wasnt autistic and just was nervous about public speaking?

I doubt this situation alone is why he's labled autistic. Many people with autism are verbal. (Heck...some have jobs and families of their own)
To have this diagnosis this child surely had an evaluation where he showed challenges in several areas.
What is unfair to assume a parent knows less about their own child than you do.

So I am reading about a female rabbi that is upset because her autistic son does not live up to her standards. Ma'am, it doesn't appear to be your son that is lacking.

I absolutely recommend for any children with special needs or autism.... Rev. Johnny Lorraine creates bespoke Haftorah portions that you can actually learn with a video and audio recording.
Email him directly on
or call me directly to put you in touch 07886 037 970.

Dear Rebecca,

It is heartbreaking to see how sad you are that your Ben cannot make a Bar Mitzvah as you desire. Have you ever stopped to think about your child and how important a mitzvah celebration is compared to him? Am sure that within your moment of prayer and making this comparison, Adonai will allow you to see all of the positive that Ben has and the feelings that he has inspired in you from the moment he was born. More than anybody else in the whole world, besides your husband and your parents, Ben is the one who needs you the most, solely for himself and his sibblings. Motherhood is a blessing, do not waste it :-) The world can repair itself as we treat our lives lovingly and do what is right for ourselves and for others. For Adonai and other people, the Bar mitzvah is a ritual, but what is most important is what lays within our hearts, same goes for your Ben within his own ways of expressing himself. Just be quiet with him and attentive to him, my suggestion of pure intuition and common sense coming from the bottom of my heart. :-) Hugs and warm regards. Elisheva Yisrael L'Olam L'Dor in Yorba Linda, CA May 25, 2013

You have created a Jewish home in which your son is not only comfortable, but empowered. Mazel tov to you!