Ham It Up On Hanukkah (Again!)
12/07/2010 - 00:02
Rabbi Jason Miller
Hey, isn't this the same Hanukkah ham I saw back in '07?
Hey, isn't this the same Hanukkah ham I saw back in '07?

Just like the return of the clothing fashion styles of yesteryear, many things on the Web tend to make a comeback too. It seems like every few years the same hoaxes, urban legends, videos, jokes and funny photos get recycled around Cyberspace.

I noticed that this is the case with a photo of ham -- yes, ham! Through Facebook, hundreds of users are recirculating the photo of the boneless spiral ham on sale at a store with the sign "Delicious for Chanukah."

It appears however, that someone decided to write their own midrash about the photo by including the caption: "Dear Walmart, I think you are barking up the wrong tree. Love, The Jews." Based on the name on most of the reposted photos on Facebook, it appears that Kathy Ohsman Hoffman of Scottsdale, Arizona is the one who penned the Walmart statement.

The photo is actually from 2007 and it had nothing to do with Walmart. It was taken at Balducci's, a specialty food store in New York City (of all places... shouldn't they know better?). I blogged about this FAIL marketing idea at Balducci's back in December 2007 and even included some faux holiday sale signs from other stores in my post. A quick search for "Hanukkah Ham" on snopes.com will also let you know that this poor choice in advertising occurred not at Walmart, but at Balducci's.

In my Facebook news feed I noticed that Shir Yakov Feinstein Feit, the musical director at NYC's Romemu, posted the Walmart/Ham accusation to which Jay Michaelson responded with a link to an article on the satire site The Onion from 1997 explaining that the 6,000 year old Jewish ban on ham has been lifted by the Jewish elders.

One of my Facebook friends added this comment to the Hanukkah Ham posting: "Nothing like a good sprial sliced smoked ham to go with latkes and applesauce....and a good glass of whole white milk. Yum".

I suppose that just like the old holiday fruitcake, we can expect that the Hanukkah Ham photo will get passed around yet again during future Hanukkahs.

Cross-posted to Blog.RabbiJason.com

Comments

I never heard of ham being used ever for Hanukkah but seeing it at Wal-mart or where ever what is the real thing I am asking seriously Because I am learning about the customs and i wish to know. I would not want to get in trouble you know.

I saw a slightly different photo than this one, with a different price.

Kathy it is "teshuva" not "tishuva".

Rabbi, No, I am not the one that penned that Wal-mart saying, it was sent to me by a real friend, and I chose to put it on MY Facebook wall as a joke to MY actual friends...not any sort of midrash. I have sent out dozens of messages to total strangers that have commented on it with the link to the Balducci's article from 3 years ago, because, not that I am a big fan of Walmart, but I don't think they deserve the hate that accompanied many of the comments nor the blame for making the mistake. I also got a message from the gal that actually took the photo 3 yrs ago asking me to give her credit! The fact that you know where this originated, you could have sent me a private message as well and NOT used my name in your articles and blog without A.) Knowing if I did indeed pen that comment, and B.) without my permission. I don't know how big your reader audience is, but I expect you to print an apology to me...tishuva if you will. Kathy in Scottsdale

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.