Chelsea's Smorgasbord
08/12/2010 - 11:08

I know. It's been almost two weeks since Chelsea Clinton-Mezvinsky's wedding. Why bring it up now?

Because people are still talking about it. My 14-year-old daughter's mouth dropped open when I showed her the cover of People magazine which, possibly for the first time in its history, featured a man in a yarmulke. Details are leaking out now about the affair, and Jonathan Mark does an excellent job deconstructing the officiating rabbi, James Ponet, who is almost in a league by himself. Or is he? At a time when there are almost as many denominations within the denominations as there are Jews who care about denominations, how hard can it be to find a rabbi with no qualms about officiating at a mixed marriage on a Saturday alongside a Methodist minister?

It's a bissele difficult, it seems. Julie Wiener reported last week that while the number of rabbis willing to preside at an interfaith wedding appears to be growing even the most liberal denominations, Reform and Reconstructionist, still draw the line at co-officiating and reject such practices by their member rabbis. But that taboo may fall, Julie says, post-Chelsea. Already, 40 percent of the 400 rabbis and cantors in a database compiled by an interfaith Web site are willing to co-officiate. Some are in defiance of their movements, others are independently ordained.

About a year ago I wrote about smorgasbord Judaism in response to a letter writer who complained about people who "pick and choose" their observance, something that, apart from the strictest haredim and chasidim, is done by the vast majority of Jews who observe any tradition at all. The Clinton-Mezvinsky wedding was a textbook smorgasboard affair, with a rabbi and, reportedly, kosher food; the groom wore a tallit and yarmulke and so, lax attitude toward Shabbat notwithstanding, there was clearly a desire by Mark Mezvinsky and his family to feel they were loyal to Judaism. It doesn't take two wealthy families to find a rabbi's blessing for that anymore. Just a large directory and some time to spend on the phone. We know there are at least 160 of them.

My point here is not to make judgments (I pick and choose quite a bit myself), but to observe that, other than strict Orthodox Judaism, where women will never be rabbis or divorce without a get and no word of any prayer will ever be updated or deleted, denominational life in America is doomed, because this is anything but a one-size fits all society. Probably more than any other organized faith on the planet Jews, particularly in America, have the luxury of being able to reject almost anything that was once central to that faith and still find an institutional way to feel embraced in their practice.

But for how long? Already Conservative congregations are being torn apart over egalitarian splits and many Reform congregations can't hold their members. The day can't be far off when non-Orthodox rabbinical schools will close their doors. In a society where everyone is their own rabbi, who will need them?

view counter

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.


"In a society where everyone is their own rabbi , who will need them ?"... well who will officiate at your funeral? As for Rachel's comments , poor Chelsea not being welcome ... welcome into what afterall .. if she is not Jewish, which is her choice , what are the Jews going to welcome her into ?
I am surpised jewish people would even show the cover of people to their children. I have been reading around on the jewish blogs and it seems poor chelsea is beign shunned by the jewish community for having the nerve to marry a jewish man and not be jewish. That can't make her feel welcome. It seems jewish people get away with having these biggoted views and no one cares. No one even dare utter that maybe marc should convert and no one in the christian community is saying their kids wont be christian but the jews sure think their kids wont be jewish.