From Williamsburg To Bushwick

Raised Neturei Karta, Sara Erenthal served in the IDF and journeyed to India before discovering she was an artist.

05/30/2013
Jewish Week Book Critic
Photo Galleria: 

At a close look, what appears to be a tear on the cheek of one of Sara Erenthal’s painted portraits is actually a hole in the wooden board the piece is painted on. The painting is one in a series called “Out of the Drawer” — the boards were pulled from a drawer she found on the street.

The brightly colored painting is a representation of a girl with two tight braids. This, like much of Erenthal’s work is autobiographical, recalling a childhood in which she always wore her hair that way. Her father usually braided it, insisting that she wear them until she was 10 when she began wearing one braid down her back instead, as in a companion painting. As her story unfolds in a recent interview, the tear seems as though it was meant to be there.

Erenthal’s family was Neturei Karta, ardent ultra-Orthodox anti-Zionists. At age 17, she ran away, rather than face an arranged marriage. She never returned. She’s now a 32-year-old artist in New York City and is zealous about making art.

Several other paintings, including the “Out of the Drawer” series, are on view in the Manhattan offices of Footsteps, an organization that assists fervently Orthodox men and women interested in exploring life in the secular world. Her painting, “Undecided,” which appears on the invitation and cover of the exhibition catalog, has been sold. In addition, a new series of paintings called “A Window Into My Life,” iare on view in Bushwick, Brooklyn.

Erenthal, who is entirely self-taught, works with acrylics on canvas and often on found objects; she also uses coffee to color her work, and has created pieces with cut paper and safety pins. She did a series of work using the fringes of tzitzit along with black leather straps once part of a pair of tefillin (given to her by a friend who found them). About a year ago, she started painting on canvas, and before that did a lot of drawing, doodling and assemblages.

Her work is self-reflective, bold, inventive and lately in bright colors. She’s spontaneous; many paintings are started and completed quickly. When asked to describe her style she says, “I just work, I don’t think I have a style. It’s explorative.” She adds, “There’s so much going on within me when I paint.”

When we meet at the Footsteps office, she’s dressed in a short polka-dot sundress with work boots, and her short dark hair is tinted teal blue. One of the first things she did when she ran away from home was to cut off her braid. She still has some of the turquoise paint in her new work on her arm, where she also has words penned in henna, including, “Life is art. My body is my diary.”

Erenthal was born in the Mea Shearim section of Jerusalem. The family moved to New York when she was 4; they lived in Borough Park, Monsey, Kiryas Joel and, for a year, France. As she explains, they didn’t quite fit in anywhere, so they moved a lot. When she was 17 her parents returned to Israel, and she joined them a few months later after finishing Beikvei Hatzon School for Girls in Williamsburg. When her parents tried to introduce her to a potential husband, she ran away the night before she was to meet him.

She tried to enlist in the Israel Defense Forces, even though she spoke no Hebrew. The person who was translating for her became a friend, introducing her to people who helped her and found her an apartment on Kibbutz Palmachim. She inspired headlines in Israel about the first Neturei Karta soldier, and her father sat shiva for her. Now, her parents are divorced and she is not in touch with them. Her siblings remain religious.

“Since I can remember,” she says, “I always felt like I was born into the wrong place, the wrong family. I always knew I wanted to be different. I wasn’t sure I could do it. It was my dream.”

Frequently, she thought about running away, but didn’t think it was possible.

“If you leave, you have to give up so much: your family, your community. It’s really scary; you’re born again. But you’re not a baby, and no one is taking care of you.”

Asked what she misses, she says, “Kugel, food. A sense of community is nice. Other than that, I don’t miss anything. Nothing about that part of my life was good.”

Upon completing her army service, she came to New York and worked in various jobs. Although she dreamed about painting, she mostly focused on trying to fit into the secular world. After nine years, she went to Israel for a month. When she met with the old friend, an artist, who had helped her leave home, he encouraged her to go to India. She spent 10 months there, the last five in the Pravati Valley, which she found breathtaking.

“There’s no way you can be there and not want to create,” she says. Daily, she would grab her sketchbook upon waking up. Recalling those days, she signs her paintings in Sanskrit.

Now Erenthal works wherever she can, sometimes in friends’ studios or homes, sometimes in the Footsteps office, where they have helped pay for art supplies. She’ll spend this summer living and working in Crown Heights. The recipient of a fellowship from Footsteps, she’ll work as an apprentice to the Haitian artist Engels, and will be working on her own art in a studio in the home of a collector.

Lani Santo, executive director of Footsteps, which has served more than 750 individuals since its founding in 2003, says that the organization’s biannual art shows “bring the voices of our members’ experience to our walls.”

“I think that we see people who are out-of-the box thinkers. They are brought up in highly structured environments, emphasizing the collective over the individual. It takes a creative person to imagine a world beyond what they’re facing.”

Erenthal says, “I realize now that I have always been an artist. I didn’t know it when I was younger.”

While her parents were both involved with art — her mother is a painter and poet, her father a graphic designer — she was never encouraged to pursue it.

To support herself, Erenthal has worked with children in art workshops and taken on random jobs. Last summer, she worked as a drawing model at the Art Students League but was very uncomfortable. Lately, she has been selling hand-painted canvas bags on etsy.com, with some featuring the poised, enigmatic figures and fresh compositions of her new series. 

I see a bit of Modigliani, an artist she admires, in her long-necked women.

“You have to understand,” Erenthal says, “I had no idea about art history until I started going to museums.” And she’s never been to certain museums that charge admission.

Erenthal may be best described as an outsider artist, referring to art created outside the boundaries of official culture.

Selig Sacks, a partner with the law firm Foley & Lardner, who has collected outsider art for more than 20 years, explains that outsider art encompasses many things. “It’s a very large category,” he says. “These artists are outside of the mainstream.

One unifying characteristic is that they are not academically trained as artists — they don’t come out of art schools, some have attended or graduated from Harvard or other universities but they didn’t study art as a discipline. They can be reclusive or very much part of their community, they take inspiration from the experience they observe or universes they have created from within.”

Erenthal does think about art school, if she could find the money, but admits, “I like where I’m going on my own. My process of learning comes with exploring myself. I don’t know if I would have the same sort of process in the classroom, whether I would be so free.”

Her dream as an artist: “I would love to do work that is accessible to the public, like street work and murals. I feel like part of my mission is sharing my story, not just with people who can buy a painting.”

“Un-Arranged,” an art exhibit by Sara Erenthal, which was part of last weekend's Bushwick Open Studios, is on view for additional hours, Wednesday, June 5-Friday June 7, 2 p.m.-5:45 p.m.at Loom Yoga Studio, 1087 Flushing Ave., Brooklyn. Her work is also on view in “The Pursuit…: A Group Exhibit of Footsteps Artists,” though October 2013. Viewing by appointment only, for hours and address, contact info@footstepsorg.org
 

Comments

Sara - all the best to you. You have guts girl . . and deserve all the happiness and praise from your so very difficult decision to leave the community, and pursue art.
For those who are so critical of Footsteps - I think this organization is a miracle. Allan, I understand how you feel, but can YOU can understand how someone like Sara & the others who have left their ultra-Orthodox background feel?? These Jews must find their OWN way to HaShem, however that is. I know of Jews like them who have sunk into suicidal depressions because they saw 'no way out' of their ultra-Ortho families. Would you RATHER have a Jew commit suicide and/or suffer tremendous depression than have an organization who offers them a Jewish way out?? Please understand that your criticisms, lashon harah, help no Jews.

good luck with your work, Sara. I know your journey has been a long one. I'm so glad you have found your calling.

Thank you, Beth.

Sara.erenthal@gmail.com
www.facebook.com/touchofparvati

June 5, 2013

As a response to Sara Erenthal, I did not say anything in
regard to her story or lifestyle. What I did say is that
her support for Footsteps is shameful. Why?
What the Footsteps program does is to ween the
people in their program from religious observance
( keeping kosher and Keeping Shabbat, for example)
and keep the people in its program from associating
with Orthodox Jews. Who says that ? The spokesmen
for the Footsteps program. This sounds an awful like
deprogramming. If that is the case, aren't you saying
that Orthodox Judaism is a cult. If you do say that, aren't
you just as intolerant as the Haredim and Hasidim you
so abhor.
Two more points I will make before I close. First,
of all, most of the people being mentioned were not abandoned
by their families but left their families. That is their choice.
Secondly, I must say that I am fed up with people who exercise their
right to leave various frum communities and then feel the
need to return as a guided missile and trash the communities
they came from.
In short, Footsteps may do some good but there is harm
also.
By the way, the author of this e-mail is neither Haredi nor
Hasidic, he is a modern Orthodox Jew who graduated from
Yeshiva University.

ALAN

June 1, 2013

The organization that you are supporting,
Footsteps, does not only help ex-Haredi and ex-
Hasidic men and women adjust to secular life
but also pushes them to abandon their religious
practices as well as cut ties with their family and
friends. Could they not be encouraged to take
some of the heritage into the transition into
the secular world. Had an Orthodox institution
tried to do the same with secular Jews, it would
be rightly denounced.
For this reason, for raising money for such
a group, Sara, you should be ashamed of yourself.

ALAN

If anyone is turning people away from religion, it's the Ultra-Orthodox.

Dear Alan,
I'd like to suggest that you read the article before making assumptions about me or Footsteps. It's very clear that you have not paid attention to what's written, nor have you done your research on this wonderful organization that literally saved so many lives. Many formerly ultra orthodox Jews including myself have been abandoned by our families and communities because of our choice to leave that sheltered lifestyle. Thanks to Footsteps, we now have a family and community that supports us in every way possible.
Sara Erenthal

There are too many scars that even footsteps cannot help. If the haredi lifestyle wasnt so toxic, footsteps wouldn't be needed. Their existence is just more of an indictment of the chasidic upbringing. And if the cultish culture and the family it contains, is what footsteps pushes one from, they are doing great work.

You're completely wrong, Alan, Footsteps does nothing of the sort. They help people with education, socialization, job finding, and things of that nature, they absolutely do not encourage people to abandon any religious practices or abandon their families.

Sorry Allan, but your statement is totally false. They encourage peoples decision, and never once did I see or hear anyone at Footsteps tell someone what to do let alone abandon their family.

The only one abandoning are some (not all) of the ultra orthodox families abandoning their loved ones who decide to live a life that they choose.

Totally false.

We're all very proud of you Sara! Keep going with the good word and your personal courage.

Thank you. Benjamin!

Comment Guidelines

The Jewish Week feels comments create a valuable conversation and wants to feature your thoughts on our website. To make everyone feel welcome, we won't publish comments that are profane, irrelevant, promotional or make personal attacks.

Add Your Comments

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.